Themes: Colonialism

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The Tempest explores the theme of colonialism through the interactions between Prospero and the island's original inhabitants, Ariel and Caliban. Written during a time of European colonial expansion, the play reflects the dynamics of power, control, and resistance that characterized the colonization of the New World. Prospero's domination over the island and its inhabitants mirrors the European colonizers' control over indigenous peoples, while Caliban's resistance symbolizes the struggle and resentment of the colonized.

Prospero's arrival on the island and his subsequent control over Ariel and Caliban reflect the European project of colonization. Ariel, a spirit freed by Prospero from a tree where he was imprisoned by the witch Sycorax, serves Prospero willingly, hoping for eventual freedom. In contrast, Caliban, the son of Sycorax, resents Prospero for taking control of the island he considers his own. Caliban's speech in Act 1, Scene 2, highlights his perspective: "This island's mine by Sycorax my mother, / Which thou tak'st from me." This reflects the broader colonial narrative of indigenous peoples being dispossessed of their lands.

This island's mine by Sycorax my mother,
Which thou tak'st from me. When thou cam'st first,
Thou strok'st me and made much of me ...
... and then I loved thee ...
Cursed be I that did so ...
For I am all the subjects tht you have,
Which first was mine own king; and here you sty me
In this hard rock, whiles you do keep from me
The rest o 'th' island. (Act 1, Scene 2)

Caliban's accusation of Prospero's ingratitude further underscores the theme of colonial betrayal. Initially, Caliban welcomed Prospero and taught him how to survive on the island. However, once Prospero's survival was assured, he enslaved Caliban, reflecting the historical pattern of colonizers exploiting and subjugating native populations. Prospero's justification for his actions, including accusations of Caliban's attempted rape of Miranda, echoes colonialist narratives that dehumanize and vilify indigenous peoples to legitimize their oppression.

The play also critiques the moral and ethical implications of colonization. Prospero's treatment of Ariel and Caliban reveals his preference for obedience and submission over defiance. While Ariel's loyalty is rewarded with promises of freedom, Caliban's rebellion is met with harsh punishment. This dynamic highlights the exploitative nature of colonial power, where the colonizer's authority is maintained through coercion and manipulation. Shakespeare uses these relationships to question the legitimacy of imperial power and to open a debate on the consequences of colonization, a debate that continues to resonate today.

Expert Q&A

What is the significance of race and difference in The Tempest?

Race and difference are central themes in "The Tempest," particularly in the treatment of Caliban, who is seen as irredeemably savage due to his "vile race." Despite learning language and some customs from Miranda and Prospero, Caliban is deemed fit only for enslavement. This reflects the colonial attitudes of the time, where racial differences justified the exploitation and oppression of indigenous peoples, mirroring European interactions with the New World's native inhabitants.

What is a post-colonial criticism of The Tempest?

Post-colonial criticism of "The Tempest" interprets Prospero as a European colonialist who seizes control of the island, dominating the indigenous Caliban and Ariel. This reflects the historical context of European exploration and conquest. Prospero's actions symbolize the imposition of Western civilization, often at the expense of native cultures. Caliban, depicted as surly and primitive, embodies the stereotypical view of indigenous peoples, yet also represents the "Noble Savage" concept, closer to nature and untainted by European influences.

What type of rulers would Ferdinand and Miranda be in The Tempest and how would they handle colonization?

Ferdinand and Miranda are good people who will make the best possible rulers for the colony. However, because Miranda is prejudiced against Native Americans, she and Ferdinand may do a lot of harm to the natives.

Does The Tempest's colonial nature and ambiguous justice point to Shakespeare's political views?

Shakespeare's The Tempest reflects his contemplation of political themes, such as legitimate rule and colonization. Prospero's unjust exile and eventual forgiveness suggest Shakespeare valued rightful governance and mercy. The play's portrayal of Caliban highlights the complexities of colonization, showing both oppressive and ambiguous aspects without clear resolution. This suggests Shakespeare was exploring the nuances of these issues rather than explicitly conveying his political views.

The Tempest's exploration of colonialism and imperialism

The Tempest explores themes of colonialism and imperialism through the interactions between Prospero and Caliban. Prospero's domination over the island and its inhabitants reflects the European colonizers' control over indigenous peoples. Caliban's resistance symbolizes the struggle and resentment of the colonized. The play critiques the moral and ethical implications of colonization and questions the legitimacy of imperial power.

Caliban and Ariel in The Tempest: Their Symbolism, Differences, and Relationships with Prospero

Caliban and Ariel in The Tempest symbolize different aspects of servitude and nature. Caliban represents the earthly, physical side, often associated with brute force and resentment, while Ariel embodies the ethereal, spiritual realm, showing obedience and lightness. Their relationships with Prospero differ: Caliban resents his enslavement, whereas Ariel serves willingly, anticipating freedom. This contrast highlights themes of power, control, and liberation.

The portrayal and influence of power and dominance within a colonial context in The Tempest

The portrayal and influence of power and dominance in a colonial context in The Tempest are evident through Prospero's control over the island and its inhabitants. His dominance over Caliban and Ariel reflects the European colonial mindset, where the colonizers exert authority over the native people and resources. The play explores themes of exploitation, control, and the complex dynamics between the oppressor and the oppressed.

The Tempest: Discovery, Colonization, and Power

Shakespeare's The Tempest explores themes of discovery, colonization, and power against the backdrop of European exploration. Characters make personal discoveries, like Prospero's realization of forgiveness over vengeance and Miranda's understanding of love and society. The play also reflects seventeenth-century anxieties about colonization, as seen in Caliban's portrayal as a wronged native. The magical island catalyzes self-discovery, highlighting both the excitement and exploitation associated with new worlds, resonating with Jacobean concerns about power and usurpation.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: Human Nature

Next

Themes: Power

Loading...