Tell Them Not to Kill Me!

by Juan Rulfo

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Juvencio's perspective on his deed in "Tell Them Not to Kill Me!"


Juvencio views his deed with a mixture of regret and justification. He acknowledges the gravity of killing Don Lupe but feels it was necessary to protect his own livelihood. Despite his remorse, he believes his actions were driven by survival, reflecting his internal conflict over the morality of his decision.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What does Juvencio's line "he had to kill Don Lupe" reveal about his view of his deed in "Tell Them Not to Kill Me!"?

“Tell Them not to Kill Me!” is a short story written by Juan Rulfo. It deals with the story of Juvencio, who is in prison because he killed Don Lupe Terreros.

In the story, Juvencio states that “he had to kill Don Lupe.” This tells the reader that Juvencio did not commit this murder voluntarily, but because he did not appear to have a choice. Juvencio refers to it as a “business,” which indicates that he is not looking at his deed emotionally or empathetically but more in a cold and business-like manner. It also shows the reader that Juvencio does not feel any guilt or remorse about what he had done all those years ago.

Juvencio justifies the killing of Don Lupe as something that served a clear purpose, as he states that it had been “not for nothing.” The reason he gives for Don Lupe’s murder is the fact that Don Lupe would not let him pasture his animals when he needed to. There had been a drought, and his animals did not have anything to eat, yet Don Lupe refused to help him. As the animals were Juvencio’s livelihood, he had been desperate to get them fed in order to not lose them to starvation. In fact, he was so desperate that he tried cutting holes into the fence to be able to get them to feed on the grass in secret. He seems to justify Don Lupe’s killing with the fact that he tried to solve the issue differently first, by repeatedly trying to smuggle the animals onto the fields in secret and also by arguing with Don Lupe about this. But as none of this had any success, Juvencio couldn’t help but resort to murdering Don Lupe to ensure that his animals survive.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What does Juvencio's line "he had to kill Don Lupe" reveal about his view of his deed in "Tell Them Not to Kill Me!"?

When he states that "he had to kill Don Lupe," Juvencio reveals that he still thinks of the deed as morally justifiable and necessary—so necessary that he had no other choice.

In lines 41–101, Juvencio says that the murder happened "thirty-five years ago." He thought that it had been "buried" or forgotten because it was "so long ago," the implication being that he thinks any responsibility he might bear for the murder has been "buried" beneath the "thirty-five years" that have passed.

Juvencio explains that the murder of Don Lupe was "Not for nothing," but because Don Lupe "refused to let him pasture his animals" on the land (the Puerta de Piedra) that he, Don Lupe, owned. Consequently, Juvencio's animals began "dying off one by one." Juvencio responded by cutting a hole in the fence surrounding Don Lupe's land so that his animals could graze there. In response, and by way of a warning, Don Lupe killed one of Juvencio's animals. In lines 41–101, it becomes clear that Juvencio considers Don Lupe's actions to have been grossly unfair, vindictive, and deserving of murder. As far as Juvencio is concerned, he "had to kill Don Lupe" from a moral perspective and also for practical reasons, so that no more of his animals would die.

Juvencio also says, revealingly, that all of Don Lupe's children were taken away to live "far off with some relatives," which meant that "there was nothing to fear from them." This latter quotation is revealing, because Juvencio doesn't express any sympathy for Don Lupe's children but only relief that they were taken far away so as not to be a threat to him. This suggests that Juvencio is a particularly selfish, remorseless character, especially given the brutal nature of the murder revealed towards the end of the story.

Juvencio also says in this passage that he has repeatedly paid off the judges (with, for example, "ten cows") and "the rest of the people" who have come looking for him, implying that he thinks he has more than paid his dues for any responsibility or guilt he might have, or rather might have had, for the murder.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What does Juvencio's line "he had to kill Don Lupe" reveal about his view of his deed in "Tell Them Not to Kill Me!"?

Juvencio says that he had to kill Don Lupe because “he had refused to let him pasture his animals," in spite of him being Juvencio’s friend and the owner of Puerta de Piedra. There had been a great famine and Juvencio hadn’t really understood how Don Lupe could claim to be his friend, yet refuse to allow him to graze his animals on his pastures, even as the animals died in their numbers. Driven to the wall, Juvencio had broken through the fence of Puerta de Piedra to allow his poor animals to graze his friend’s lands in the dead of the night. After repeatedly breaking into his friend’s farms, his friend retaliated by killing one of his animals. It is at this point that he killed his friend.

When Juvencio says that “he had to kill Don Lupe," he seems to believe that his deeds were justified and that killing Don Lupe was the only way he could resolve the conflict between him and his friend at the time.

In the lines immediately following this statement, he further explains why his actions were justified. The reader clearly sees that Juvencio placed a lot of value on his animals. He valued them more than he valued the life of his friend. Thus, to him, his friend was to blame for the murder. Even as he faces his own death in the hands of the colonel, he does not regret his deeds those many years ago.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What does Juvencio's statement about killing Don Lupe reveal about his perspective on his deed?

Juvencio killed Don Lupe for not allowing Juvencio's animals to graze on his land and for ultimately killing an animal that had wandered across the fence. We learn by the end of the story that this is an extremely brutal murder and all for a feud over whether or not the animals could cross into Don Lupe's land, which had much more and better grass.

The murder itself tells us a lot about Juvencio and his sense of morality. In his statement that he had to kill Don Lupe, we see that he feels justified in his action. He truly believes that Don Lupe was in the wrong and that killing Don Lupe for killing an animal was his only option.

We see no form of redemption for Juvencio throughout the story. He shows no remorse for his deed, and in the end he begs for his life but never admits to himself or to the colonel that he may have been wrong to kill Juvencio.

There are many possible reasons why Juvencio felt he needed to kill Don Lupe. It's likely that his animals were all he had and were his primary mode of making a living. We also know that the feud had been ongoing, and there were several days of opening and closing the fence leading up to the murder. Finally, we can see a sense of honor in Juvencio's memories. Not only had Don Lupe killed an animal, but he had offended Juvencio's honor and fanned the flames of this ongoing and quickly escalating feud.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on