Themes: Madness and Sanity
In the first sentence of “The Tell-Tale Heart,” the narrator demands to know why his listener regards him as mad. It is a question which, coming suddenly out of nowhere, seems to answer itself. The narrator sounds deranged, not least because he keeps asking questions about his own sanity and accusing the reader of doubting it.
An anachronistic tradition has grown up of attempting to diagnose specific mental illnesses, such as paranoid schizophrenia, in the narrator. Edgar Allan Poe would not himself have thought in these medical terms. His approach to the question of madness is philosophical, similar to Hamlet’s. Like Shakespeare, Poe presents his audience with conceptual questions about what madness means. For instance, the narrator tells the reader: “Madmen know nothing.” He then goes on to boast about how cunningly he concealed his intention to murder the old man in the week before killing him. It seems reasonable to object that the charge from which he is defending himself here is incompetence, not insanity. Does it make a madman less mad if he pursues an obviously insane objective in an efficient manner? On the contrary, the efficiency itself seems to be an indication that he has none of the doubt and hesitation a sane person would have.
It is not clear to whom the narrator thinks he is speaking. He may be confessing his crime to the police after his arrest, or speaking to a judge or a doctor. He may even have thrust himself on an unfortunate cellmate. What is evident, however, is that “The Tell-Tale Heart” is both confession and defense. Since he admits to the crime almost immediately, madness takes the place of legal guilt as the accusation against which the narrator is continually defending himself. As the typical suspect only increases the perception of his guilt by continually protesting his innocence, so the narrator sounds more and more insane as he insists upon his sanity.
Expert Q&A
Why does the narrator in "The Tell-Tale Heart" hear the old man's heart beat loudly when police arrive?
The narrator in "The Tell-Tale Heart" hears the old man's heart beat loudly when the police arrive due to his overwhelming guilt. The auditory hallucination symbolizes his guilt and growing paranoia, leading him to believe that the police must also hear it and are mocking him. Unable to bear this perceived torture, he confesses to the crime. The heartbeat, heard only by the narrator, either represents his subconscious urging him to admit his guilt or a supernatural force seeking justice.
What is the meaning of this quote from "The Tell-Tale Heart" by Edgar Allan Poe?
" 'Villains!' I shrieked, 'dissemble no more! I admit the deed!—tear up the planks—here, here!—It is the beating of his hideous heart.' "
The quote from Edgar Allan Poe's "The Tell-Tale Heart" signifies the protagonist's guilt and psychological torment. The phantom heartbeat he hears is his own conscience, driving him to confess his crime to authorities. However, an alternate interpretation could suggest a spectral force inducing his madness. The quote, being the story's final line, reveals the protagonist's paranoia about the detectives discovering his crime and his eventual confession induced by the unbearable phantom heartbeat.
In "The Tell-Tale Heart", what does the narrator claim about his mental state? Do you believe him?
The narrator insists he is not insane, but his actions and speech suggest otherwise. He kills an old man without a rational motive, driven by obsession with the man's eye, and later becomes agitated, believing he hears the dead man's heart. His frantic, disjointed speech patterns further imply instability. These factors make it difficult to trust his self-assessment of sanity, suggesting he is indeed mentally unwell.
Why does the narrator in "The Tell-tale Heart" claim his perceived madness is acute senses?
The narrator claims his madness is actually acute senses to convince the reader of his sanity. He acknowledges sounding insane, particularly due to his obsession with the old man's eye, which he describes in detail. His insistence on his cleverness and rationality is an attempt to gain the reader's respect. Despite this, his actions, like killing his roommate over the "evil eye," and his eventual breakdown, reveal his true madness.
What does the narrator in "The Tell-Tale Heart" say when he is crazy?
The narrator in "The Tell-Tale Heart" insists he is not insane, claiming his actions are driven by heightened senses rather than madness. He believes his careful planning and intelligence prove his sanity, despite his irrational motive for murder: the old man's eye. His delusion is evident as he misinterprets his own heartbeat as the dead man's and describes his creeping actions with distorted perception, further highlighting his unstable mentality.
Why do the police in The Tell-Tale Heart chat calmly with the murderer, ignoring the sound?
In "The Tell-Tale Heart," the police chat calmly with the murderer because the sound of the beating heart is likely a hallucination caused by the narrator's guilt, not something they actually hear. The narrator believes the officers hear the sound and mock him by ignoring it, but it is more plausible that the sound is his own guilty conscience, projecting his desire to be exposed onto the officers.
Why doesn't the narrator in "The Tell-Tale Heart" commit the perfect crime and what makes him confess?
The narrator in "The Tell-Tale Heart" fails to commit the perfect crime due to his overwhelming guilt and mental instability. After murdering the old man, he hears what he believes is the victim's heart beating under the floorboards, which is actually an auditory hallucination. This imagined sound becomes unbearable, leading him to confess to the police. His mental breakdown and guilt prevent him from maintaining the facade of innocence, proving there is no perfect crime.
How does the following quote from "The Tell-Tale Heart" relate to the story's theme?
"... It was the low stifled sound that arises from the bottom of the soul when overcharged with awe. I knew the sound well. Many a night, just at midnight, when all the world slept, it was welled up from my own bosom, deepening, with its dreadful echo, the terrors that distracted me." (Poe)
In "The Tell-Tale Heart," what does the narrator reveal about himself through his murder plans?
The narrator reveals his obsession with proving his sanity, despite his meticulous murder plans. He repeatedly insists he is not mad, suggesting an awareness of how others perceive him, possibly addressing a doctor or an authority figure. His fixation on sanity rather than the morality of his actions highlights his unstable mental state, as he is more concerned with being seen as sane than with the gravity of murdering the old man.
Unreliable Narrator in "The Tell-Tale Heart"
In Edgar Allan Poe's "The Tell-Tale Heart," the narrator is distinctly unreliable and mentally unstable. Throughout the story, his attempts to convince the reader of his sanity are contradicted by his irrational actions and perceptions, such as hearing supernatural sounds and murdering an old man due to his "Evil Eye." The fragmented syntax and paranoid assertions further undermine his reliability. His hallucinations, particularly hearing the dead man's heartbeat, highlight his guilt and instability, making his account untrustworthy.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
