Edmunds' contribution to the Library of American Biography series centers on Tecumseh, a figure whose life holds significant historical value. The series, curated by Oscar Handlin, aims to bring to light the stories of underrepresented Americans, including women, ethnic minorities, and political underdogs. While Edmunds' expertise as a historian is well-regarded, particularly for his work on the Potawatomis, traditional adversaries of the Shawnees, the inclusion of his manuscript in the series appears somewhat unconventional. This is primarily due to his prior focus on Tecumseh’s brother, Tenskwatawa, as evidenced by his earlier work, The Shawnee Prophet (1983).

One might question the motivation behind Edmunds’ portrayal of Tecumseh, especially as certain sections of the text seem to be appendices to his previous research. His introduction of Tecumseh’s narrative feels cursory, and the chapter summarizing contemporary opinions on Tecumseh lacks the depth one might expect. This gives rise to speculation that the integration of these elements was more a response to the thematic requirements of the series than a reflection of Edmunds’ passion or dedication to this particular subject.

Despite these observations, Edmunds remains a scrupulous historian. His portrayal does not distort the historical record nor does it mislead young adult readers, but it may fail to ignite the fervent interest that Tecumseh’s life story deserves. Tecumseh's existence was marked by courage and exemplified numerous commendable qualities, albeit mired by strategic setbacks from a broader Native American viewpoint. This understated approach might dampen the engagement of young readers, who could benefit from a more vivid depiction of Tecumseh as an inspirational figure.