Student Question
Why is Sydney Carton's presence at the court important in A Tale of Two Cities?
Quick answer:
Sydney Carton's presence at Charles Darnay's trial is crucial because it establishes their physical resemblance, which introduces doubt about Darnay's identity and leads to his acquittal. This resemblance is pivotal later when Carton switches places with Darnay in prison, sacrificing himself at the guillotine to save Darnay. Carton's actions fulfill his promise to Lucie to do anything for her or her loved ones, cementing his role in their lives even after his death.
The presence of Sydney Carton at the trial of Charles Darnay is important, not from a “legal” standpoint, but to set up the physical resemblance between the two characters as significant. Darnay is released when Carton points out to Stryver that he and the prisoner look alike, thus throwing the possibility of doubt on Barsad’s testimony that he recognized Darnay. This becomes extremely important at the end, when Carton switches places with Darnay in prison, taking his place at the guillotine. Without the similarity that the two have, this ruse would be unlikely to succeed. Thus Carton can fulfill his promise to Lucie that he would do anything to save her or anyone she loved. As the book begins, so it ends: Carton manages to save Darnay’s life, but this time by sacrificing his own. Carton becomes an important part of Charles and Lucie’s life even more after his death.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.