In A Tale of Two Cities, why is Dr. Manette imprisoned?
This is something that we are only actually told in Book the Third, Chapter Ten, and this is one of the central questions that lurk behind the rest of the action of the novel. Let us remember that in this chapter, Defarge reads the letter that Dr. Manette wrote before be slipped into insanity whilst he was a prisoner. It details how Darnay's father and uncle raped a peasant woman, killed her husband and mortally wounded her brother. Dr. Manette is ordered to care for them. When Dr. Manette discovers the truth of what has happened, he refuses to agree never to divulge what he has seen and the horrific acts of the Evremonde brothers. As a result, they arrange for his wrongful imprisonment in the Bastille.
It is of course particularly important that this truth which is hinted at throughout the novel is only revealed at this critical juncture...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
when Darnay's life is in the balance, and Dr. Manette believes that, as before, his presence can actually save his son-in-law. The tremendousirony of this event is of course that it is Dr. Manette who, out of his own mouth (or hand) condemns him to a certain death.
Where and how long was Dr. Manette imprisoned in A Tale of Two Cities?
In A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens, Doctor Alexandre Manette is by all accounts a brilliant physician who was wrongly imprisoned in the Bastille for eighteen years for reporting to a minister of the French government that Charles Darnay's father and uncle (whose surname was actually "St. Evrémonde") raped a peasant woman, killed her husband, and fatally wounded her brother.
To avoid further disclosure of these facts that would certainly ruin the St. Evrémonde family, Dr. Manette was seized by Darnay's father and uncle, taken away from his family, secretly imprisoned in the Bastille, and essentially left there to die.
Dr. Manette, "Prisoner 105, North Tower," is released from prison prior to the events at the start of the novel, and his release is the subject of the first part of the book. Eventually, Dr. Manette is reunited with his daughter, Lucie, overcomes the terrible effects that imprisonment had on him, and gradually resumes his work as a physician in England.
Dr. Manette later tries to help Darnay escape execution by the revolutionary court, but a bitter, vengeful letter that Dr. Manette wrote in prison against the St. Evrémondes helps to seal Darnay's fate.
What is a summary of Dr. Mannette's imprisonment at the Bastille in A Tale of Two Cities?
Known as prisoner number 105 North Tower, Dr. Alexandre Manette has been held in the Bastille for eighteen years. During this time, he recorded how he came to be imprisoned there. He describes how he was approached by two identical men one night in December of 1757 and compelled to climb into their carriage which took him to the countryside. Hearing cries from an upper chamber, Manette is led to a beautiful young woman who is bound. She screamed and called out, “My husband, my father, and my brother!” Then she counted to twelve and said, “Hush!” One of the brothers produces some medicine, and Dr. Manette administers the dosage he needs to her.
Later, one of the brothers tells Manette there is another patient. Lying on some hay on the ground with a cushion under his head is a peasant boy of no more than seventeen, dying from a wound made by a sword. When Manette asks one of the noblemen how this injury occurred, the man replied that the boy was “A crazed young common dog” who came at his brother, who was forced to defend himself.
The boy explains that the noblemen have had their way with his sister, who married a good man. His family, he explains, are tenants of the nobles—he calls one of them “the worst of a bad race”--who tax them, pillaged and plundered. One day, he says, the one he calls "the worst of a bad race" spotted his beautiful sister and asked her husband to lend her to him. The husband acquiesces, but his sister refused. So, they harness the man and make him pull a cart; they kept him outside in the “unwholesome mists” all night, and ordered him each day into the harness. Finally, one day when he was taken out of the harness to eat, he fell into the arms of his wife, counting twelve times, and died. The brother then took his sister away for his pleasure. After learning of this action, the brother hid his younger sister and came with a sword to kill the nobleman. His violated sister ran in, throwing coins at him, begging him to stop, but he challenged the nobleman, anyway. Finally, calling upon all his strength, the boy tells the nobleman,
"I summon you and yours to the last of your bad race, to answer for them. I mark this cross of blood upon you, as a sign that I do it...."
When Manette returns to the woman, her condition is grave, especially because she is in the early stages of pregnancy. Manette is told by a twin that he must never talk of what he has witnessed. However, the brothers are careless about their conversations, as though Manette were dying, also. After a week, the woman died. When the brothers offered him gold, Manette refused it. Later, it was sent to his home, but the physician had decided to write privately to the authorities without mentioning names. He was then visited by the wife of the Marquis St. Evremonde, who hoped to "avert the wrath of Heaven from a House...long hateful to the suffering many" as she was in dread of her husband and his brother. As Manette notices her boy, she says that she fears that atonement for the crimes will be expected.
On the night of the day that Dr. Manette delivered his letter, a man in black garb came to visit him, saying there was an urgent case in the Rue St.Honore. Crossing the road were the two brothers with the letter Manette has written. They burned it, and Manette is taken to prison. As he ends, Manette denounced the Evremonde brothers to Heaven and to earth.
Why was Dr. Manette imprisoned in A Tale of Two Cities?
Dr. Mannette was imprisoned in the Bastille, a notorious fortress prison that stood as a hated symbol of pre-Revolutionary France and whose fall is generally thought to represent the start of the French Revolution. He rotted away in that hellhole for eighteen long years: his lengthy period of incarceration taking a terrible toll on both his mental and physical health.
Dr. Mannette was imprisoned for informing on Darnay's father and his uncle, the wicked Marquis St. Evrémonde. They were responsible for the rape of a peasant woman and the murders of her husband and brother. The Evrémonde brothers obtained what's called a lettre de cachet to keep Dr. Mannette quiet and send him to prison.
A lettre de cachet was a sealed letter from the king that contained his express orders, normally relating to the punishment without trial of certain individuals. There was no appeal against a lettre de cachet, and they were wide open to abuse, often used to settle scores or personal vendettas. That's precisely what happened to Dr. Mannette. Two aristocrats were able to get away with breaking the law; not only that, but they were able to send an innocent man to prison for eighteen years, and all because he had the courage to do the right thing. It's no wonder that the revolutionaries hated the Bastille and the manifestly unjust system it represented.