Sylvia Ashton-Warner Criticism
Sylvia Ashton-Warner, a New Zealand educator and author, is renowned for her innovative contributions to literature and educational philosophy. Her extensive work, ranging from novels to poetry, often reflects her experiences teaching Maori children. Ashton-Warner’s novel, Spinster, exemplifies her distinctive approach to education, emphasizing the integration of the inner and outer self as essential for genuine communication, a theme praised by John Wain for its vivid portrayal of character complexities. Contrarily, Ruth Blackman critiques it for lacking depth in its protagonist. Additionally, her novel Incense to Idols explores intricate themes using Biblical analogies, though Nancy Wilson Ross notes its structural shortcomings. In Greenstone, she blends fable with reality to challenge family and cultural norms, as analyzed by Eleanor Dienstag, despite Elinor Baumbach's view on its dramatic execution. Ashton-Warner’s autobiographical works, such as Teacher, reflect her educational philosophy, praised by Katharine Taylor for their global impact, while Elizabeth Janeway critiques their coherence. Her legacy continues to inspire discussions on the fusion of education and literary art.
Contents
-
Children and Conflicts
(summary)
In the following essay, Ruth Blackman critiques Sylvia Ashton-Warner's novel "Spinster" for its impressionistic style and its failure to convincingly depict the complexity of the protagonist's character, which ultimately undermines the reader's sympathy for the character.
-
Books: 'Spinster'
(summary)
In the following essay, John Wain praises Sylvia Ashton-Warner's novel "Spinster" for its vivid portrayal of Anna Vorontosov, highlighting the novel's exploration of the complexities of communication and the realistic depiction of relationships that transcend the capabilities of average professional work.
-
Celtic Saga
(summary)
In the following essay, Nancy Wilson Ross critiques Sylvia Ashton-Warner's novel "Incense to Idols," arguing that despite the novel's intriguing themes and compelling undercurrents, such as Biblical analogies and character complexities, it suffers from a lack of structural integration and inconsistent prose, leaving a mixed impression of Ashton-Warner's literary talent.
-
Toward the Self
(summary)
In the following essay, Max Cosman explores Sylvia Ashton-Warner's novel "Incense to Idols," highlighting its originality and depth in character portrayal, its technical prowess in the use of interior monologue, and its thematic exploration of the conflict between sin and sanctity, as well as its evocative language and moral implications.
-
The How Is Mightier Than the What
(summary)
In the following essay, Katharine Taylor examines Ashton-Warner's "Teacher" as an insightful narrative that reflects on educational philosophy and its potential global impact, emphasizing the transformative power of nurturing creativity in children as essential for future peace and understanding.
-
Bennie Wasn't Ready
(summary)
In the following essay, Virgilia Peterson critiques Sylvia Ashton-Warner's novel "Bell Call" as an inconclusive exploration of discipline versus freedom, noting its static and repetitive nature compared to her earlier works, yet acknowledges the author's continued imaginative style and pedagogical passion.
-
Mumma and Puppa Were Perfect
(summary)
In the following essay, Eleanor Dienstag praises Sylvia Ashton-Warner's novel "Greenstone" for its imaginative fusion of fable and reality to explore themes of family, education, and cultural interplay, suggesting that its allegorical storytelling challenges readers to rethink their perspectives on family dynamics.
-
In the Valley of the Maori
(summary)
In the following essay, Elinor Baumbach critiques Sylvia Ashton-Warner's Greenstone for its reliance on romantic stereotypes and ineffective dramatic events, arguing that while Ashton-Warner excels in portraying the clash of Maori and white cultures with pedagogical insight, her novelistic attempts succumb to bathos.
-
Teacher Down Under
(summary)
In the following essay, Elizabeth Janeway critiques Sylvia Ashton-Warner's autobiographical work for its lack of coherence and objective distance, while acknowledging her innovative teaching methods and the emotional energy she invested in her educational endeavors.
-
Fiction Chronicle: 'Three'
(summary)
In the following essay, Patrick Cruttwell commends Ashton-Warner's ability to vividly depict the complex interplay of selfishness and genuine love in her characters, highlighting her skill in creating authentic human personalities without moral judgment.
-
A Feel for Teaching
(summary)
In the following essay, Morris Freedman argues that Sylvia Ashton-Warner's book "Spearpoint" is both a reflective account of her teaching experiences and a detailed exploration of educational methods, highlighting her professional commitment to understanding and improving teaching through self-reflection and acknowledging the broader cultural environment influencing her students.
-
She Asks Our Questions
(summary)
In the following essay, Carolyn F. Ruffin discusses Sylvia Ashton-Warner's "I Passed This Way" as a powerful reflection on identity and individuality through her autobiographical narrative that challenges conventional safety and bureaucracy, emphasizing the author's raw, candid style and the poignant, enduring questions she raises about her life's purpose.
-
Organic Teacher
(summary)
In the following essay, Linda B. Osborne examines Sylvia Ashton-Warner's autobiography, highlighting its introspective and impressionistic approach, focusing on personal growth and emotion rather than historical events, and illustrating her educational philosophy of "organic teaching" through selective self-portraiture and memory.