Summary
Arnold Toynbee's A Study of History explores the rise and fall of civilizations, offering insights into their development, challenges, and interactions. Toynbee delineates how civilizations grow from creative responses to adversity and examines the reasons behind their decline. He also considers the interplay between civilizations and their influence on one another over time.
Chapter 1: The Unit of Historical Study
Toynbee proposes that historians should focus on civilizations as the primary unit of analysis rather than individual nations. He identifies five active civilizations: Western Christian, Orthodox Christian, Islamic, Hindu, and Far Eastern, alongside sixteen extinct ones that have given rise to contemporary societies. Toynbee distinguishes between the numerous primitive societies and the relatively few civilizations, dismissing the notion that modern civilization is singularly Western or that all civilization traces back to Egypt.
Chapter 2: Geneses of Civilizations
In Toynbee's view, civilizations spring not from racial characteristics or favorable environments but from inventive reactions to challenging conditions. He argues that adversity, rather than ease, is the catalyst for civilization's birth. Toynbee outlines five types of challenges that can stimulate growth: harsh environments, new surroundings, setbacks like military defeats, ongoing pressures such as border threats, and social injustices like slavery. However, when challenges are too overwhelming, they can impede rather than foster development.
Chapter 3: Growths of Civilizations
Examining why some societies, such as the Polynesian or Eskimo, stagnate, Toynbee explores how to assess a civilization's growth. He finds military or political expansion and advancements in agriculture or industry to be inadequate measures. Instead, he introduces the concept of "etherialization," where societies shift focus from external to internal challenges, requiring spiritual evolution. Growth is propelled by individuals who periodically withdraw from and reengage with society, driving innovation.
Chapter 4: Breakdowns of Civilizations
Toynbee contends that civilization's collapse is not preordained by cosmic forces nor by losing control over the environment or technical decline. Instead, it occurs when a once-creative minority loses its inspiration and the majority ceases to follow willingly. This leads to societal fragmentation and the rise of a disenchanted "proletariat." The minority fails because it becomes complacent after past successes, neglecting new challenges.
Chapter 5: Disintegration of Civilizations
Disintegration manifests in a civilization splitting into a "dominant minority," an "internal proletariat," and an "external proletariat." The dominant minority, now a degenerated form of its creative predecessor, loses loyalty from the internal proletariat, which may eventually rebel. External proletariats resist assimilation. While initial reactions from the internal proletariat might be violent, they may later find solace in a "higher religion." Social disintegration is marked by altered behaviors, beliefs, and a sense of chance or guilt, replacing lost creativity. The process involves a rhythmic cycle of setbacks and recoveries, where new "saviors" may arise.
Chapter 6: Universal States
During a civilization's decline, universal states emerge during the "rally" phase, attempting to unify politically after a "Time of Troubles." These states, however, are part of the disintegration process. Although they fail to preserve themselves, they inadvertently benefit higher religions within their internal proletariats by promoting cultural exchange. Universal states often govern with tolerance, aiding the spread of these religions, and their institutions like legal systems and infrastructure are utilized by other communities.
Chapter 7: Universal Churches
Toynbee examines the dynamic between churches and civilizations, rejecting the view of churches as societal parasites causing state decline. He also challenges the notion of churches merely preserving civilization. Instead, Toynbee argues that civilizations exist to foster the emergence of higher religions such as Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, and Islam, suggesting that religion is the ultimate purpose of civilization.
Chapter 8: Heroic Ages
When disintegrating civilizations fall to...
(This entire section contains 911 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
previously co-existing barbarians, a Heroic Age ensues. Although these barbarians lack the sophistication to capitalize on the defeated civilization's achievements, they might immortalize their conquests in epic narratives. A Heroic Age serves as a transitional period between the collapse of one civilization and the rise of another, eventually leading to a Dark Age before a new civilization emerges.
Chapter 9: Contacts between Civilizations in Space
Interactions between various civilizations often result in conflict, with potentially devastating outcomes. An assailed civilization might respond militarily, through ideological warfare, by reinforcing its religious practices, or by developing a higher religion. However, a triumphant civilization might become overly militaristic, harming itself, and may inadvertently absorb foreign cultural influences with negative effects. Subjugating another civilization might lead to viewing the conquered as "heathens" or "barbarians."
Chapter 10: Contacts between Civilizations in Time
Toynbee explores historical renaissances where civilizations have drawn inspiration from their predecessors. The most well-known is the influence of the ancient Greek civilization on Western Christendom during the Italian Renaissance, highlighting how past civilizations can inspire new development and innovation.
Chapter 11: Law and Freedom in History
Toynbee argues that history is guided by natural laws rather than being entirely random. He provides examples from economic and business practices that demonstrate predictable patterns and notes cyclical patterns of conflict and peace in Western history. Disintegrating civilizations also follow a rhythm of decline and recovery. Humanity, while subject to these laws, can use them advantageously, contingent on society's psychology and its relationship with a higher moral authority.
Chapter 12: Prospects of Western Civilization
Toynbee acknowledges both the positive and negative features of modern Western civilization, condemning nationalism and militarism while praising its strides in democracy and education. He envisions potential for world peace and governance and discusses the impact of technology. The trade-off for economic security is increasing regulation, which can restrict personal freedoms. Nonetheless, Toynbee remains hopeful that technological advances will free time for spiritual pursuits.