Themes: Cultural Conflicts
The play depicts two Southern cultures at odds. The first is the old-fashioned world in which Blanche and Stella were raised and which Blanche continues to embody. This old-fashioned culture has its roots in the plantation system that formed the foundation of the South’s economy and culture until the Civil War—and far some time after. This culture is rigidly hierarchical with regards to both race and class, and well-to-do white families, such as the DuBois family, bore a genteel air.
The other culture is that of New Orleans, whose diverse, cosmopolitan population places little stock in the hierarchies that once defined Southern life. In Williams’s New Orleans, there are characters of many ethnic and racial backgrounds who coexist without overt tensions. At one level, this harmony is attributable to New Orleanian culture, which has been defined by a richly diverse population for centuries. But Williams’s New Orleans is also representative of the broader shift in Southern—and even American—culture away from racial and ethnic hierarchies.
Blanche clashes with this comparatively progressive New Orleanian culture, bringing as she does the assumptions and airs of the old South. Indeed, Blanche’s longing for an idyllic past can be read as representative of the demise of the plantation system she comes from. Stanley, whose working-class, Polish background reflects the ethos of the new South, particularly despises Blanche’s genteel pretensions. In a sense, the conflict between Blanche and Stanley is a microcosm of the broader conflict between the old and new cultures Williams depicts.
Expert Q&A
In Scene 8 of A Streetcar Named Desire, why would Stanley admire Huey Long?
Stanley admires Huey Long because he agrees with Long's belief that every man should be the master of his own home, a sentiment reflected in Stanley's domineering behavior. Long's criticism of the wealthy elite and his "Every man a king" slogan resonate with Stanley's disdain for Blanche's class snobbery. Additionally, Stanley's tyrannical nature mirrors the dictatorial image some had of Long.
How does Stella's child reconcile the opposing worlds of Kovalski and Debois in A Streetcar Named Desire?
Stella's child in A Streetcar Named Desire does not reconcile the opposing worlds of the Kowalskis and the Dubois. In the play, the child symbolizes Stella's permanent shift to the Kowalski world, as she remains with Stanley. The child represents the triumph of the New South over the Old South. In the 1951 film adaptation, Stella leaves Stanley with her baby, symbolizing escape rather than reconciliation, and a new beginning apart from both worlds.
How do women's roles in A Streetcar Named Desire reflect Simone de Beauvoir's ideas in The Second Sex?
In The Second Sex, Simone de Beauvoir argues that women are kept from realizing their true potential by clinging to the idea that they must depend upon men, as well as by not finding solidarity with other women. Applying those ideas to A Streetcar Named Desire, they can be seen in the situation of Blanche Dubois and in the lack of solidarity between women against tyrannical men.
Tensions and Animosity Between Blanche and Stanley in A Streetcar Named Desire
The tensions and animosity between Blanche and Stanley in A Streetcar Named Desire stem from their contrasting personalities and values. Blanche's pretensions and desire for a genteel life clash with Stanley's raw, pragmatic nature. Stanley resents Blanche's intrusion into his home and perceives her as a threat to his authority and relationship with Stella, further fueling their conflict.
Blanche vs. Stanley: Key Contrasts in A Streetcar Named Desire
In Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire, Blanche Dubois and Stanley Kowalski symbolize the Old South and the New South, respectively. Blanche embodies the fall of the Southern aristocracy with her genteel manners and romantic notions, representing the decline of plantation society. In contrast, Stanley represents the New South's proletariat, characterized by his raw, industrial background and dominance. Their clash highlights the transition from traditional Southern values to modern industrial ones, underscoring changing social dynamics post-Civil War.
The basis and effects of the conflicts in A Streetcar Named Desire
The conflicts in A Streetcar Named Desire are rooted in class differences, personal insecurities, and the struggle for power. Blanche's arrival disrupts the Kowalski household, leading to clashes between her and Stanley. Stanley's aggression and Blanche's delusions highlight themes of reality versus illusion. These conflicts ultimately culminate in Blanche's mental breakdown and institutionalization, illustrating the destructive effects of unresolved tensions and miscommunications.
The presentation of the old versus new conflict in Scene 2 of A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams
In Scene 2 of A Streetcar Named Desire, the conflict between old and new is evident through Blanche's traditional Southern ideals clashing with Stanley's modern, industrial worldview. Blanche's delicate, refined demeanor starkly contrasts with Stanley's brute force and practicality, highlighting the tension between past gentility and contemporary reality.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
