Student Question
Does Stella deserve the most pity in A Streetcar Named Desire?
Quick answer:
One could argue that Stella is deserving of pity because she's married to a brute of a man who subjects her to domestic abuse. At the same time, she genuinely loves Stanley. With a baby on the way, it'll be even harder for her to escape him. A generally weak and passive woman, Stella invites pity.
On the whole, Stella's quite a weak and passive woman, which is why she becomes a pawn in the epic battle of wills between her sister and husband. Caught in the middle of this titanic struggle over her soul, Stella can only do her best to provide a bridge between Blanche and Stanley. That in itself invites pity. No one would really envy someone in Stella's position.
But Stella isn't just caught between Stanley and Blanche. She's also caught between her love and desire for Stanley and the recognition that he's a violent, uncouth brute who really isn't ideal husband material. On an intellectual level, Stella must know that Stanley's not right for her. Yet because she loves him, and because she's attracted to his raw, overpowering sexuality, she remains right where she is: by his side. Stella's about to give birth to Stanley's child, which will keep her even more tied down to the bad relationship. To an outside observer, their union looks like the classic example of an abusive marriage.
Whether Stella realizes it or not, she is trapped. After Blanche is dispatched to a mental hospital, one senses that Stella's last chance at breaking free from Stanley has gone with her. That in itself is enough to invite pity.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.