Discussion Topic
Identifying the "you" in Maya Angelou's "Still I Rise."
Summary:
The "you" in Maya Angelou's "Still I Rise" represents the oppressive forces and individuals, both historical and contemporary, who have tried to subjugate and diminish African Americans. It embodies the collective voice of those who perpetuate racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination, against which the speaker asserts her resilience and determination to rise above adversity.
In "Still I Rise," who is referred to as 'you' and how can we determine this?
Who is meant by 'you' in the poem "Still I Rise" by Maya Angelou is American society in general and the thoughts held by some in this society. She addresses, for example, those who record history, whether its academic historians with prejudices against black people; newspapers and magazines with the same intent, or anyone or any group that records in a malevolent way stories about black people and their particular organizations.
Angelou writes:
You may write me down in history
With your bitter, twisted lies,
It is obvious in these lines that she is taking historians and others to task for their prejudicial writings and oral storytelling. These are those who report inaccurately and sometimes totally wrong the history and contemporary stories about black people and their life experiences.
She challenges these people, asking them (this subset of society) if her being sassy upsets them. She talks with confidence and lets these people (who subscribe to putting blacks down) know that she will not be defeated by them, that she will counter them confidently and win.
Maya Angelou also writes:
You may cut me with your eyes,
You may kill me with your hatefulness,
This refers to peoples detestable looks full of animosity towards blacks as they may pass a black person in the street, in a mall, or wherever. This also refers to the deaths that have occurred against the black race in the form of lynching parties and other heinous acts.
We can tell that Maya Angelou is addressing society in general in this poem, in that she does not single out any one individual or group particularly. The 'you' of the poem is a general, all-encompassing term meant for this specific prejudicial group in society.
Nonetheless, someone of this ilk who may read this poem, may take this 'you' personally. Therefore, as an alternative, the 'you' can in some cases be addressed to a specific reader. It depends on who the reader of the poem is, as others who read this poem may not feel it is addressed to them at all.
Hence, this is why overall, the poem is addressed to that entire segment of American society that has untoward feelings, thoughts and actions towards blacks and to their culture, and sometimes act wrongly towards black people because of these proclivities.
References
In "Still I Rise," who does Maya Angelou refer to with "you"?
Maya Angelou uses the words ‘you’ and ‘your’ fifteen times in her poem “Still I Rise.” “You” certainly stands for the white oppressors of the black people. The fact that Angelou was a black woman and her identifying herself as “a black ocean” and “the dream and the hope of the slave” leave no doubt that the ‘you’ in the poem is nobody else but the whites who subjugated and tyrannized blacks.
Angelou was a prominent African-American writer whose poems and autobiographical works could well be read as her defense of black culture. Among black literary figures and social activists, she had been one of the most vocal proponents of black rights.
“Still I Rise” can be read as both a personal and a political poem. It had first appeared in the collection published as And Still I Rise in 1978.
It must be remembered that African-American Civil Rights Movement had led to passing of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. This legislation outlawed discrimination based on color, religion or sex. This was a great victory for the African-Americans.
This poem records the triumphant mood of the blacks. The speaker sounds extremely buoyant, high-spirited, confident, fearless and determined.
Thus, when Angelou says ‘you’ in the following lines, she directly refers to the whites who are not really happy and comfortable seeing the blacks 'rise:'
Did you want to see me broken?
Bowed head and lowered eyes?
Does my sassiness upset you?
Why are you beset with gloom?
Does my haughtiness offend you?
Does my sexiness upset you?
Who is the "you" in "Still I Rise"?
In order to figure out the "you" in the poem—the person or persons being addressed by the speaker—it is helpful to figure out the "I," or the person who is actually speaking. The speaker identifies herself as a Black person when she says that she is
Bringing the gifts that my ancestors gave,
I am the dream and the hope of the slave.
We also know that she sees the people she addresses in an adversarial way: she expects them to lie about her in history books, to attempt to "trod [her] in the very dirt," to "want to see [her] broken" and crying. She believes that she "offend[s]" them, that they do not want to see her laugh, that they would "shoot" her with their words, "cut" her with their eyes, "kill" her with their hate, feel upset by her "sexiness," and be "surprise[d]" by her vitality and confidence. It seems, then, that she is addressing white people.
In the United States, there is a long history of oppression of Black Americans by white Americans, beginning with slavery but extending through the Reconstruction, Jim Crow era, and Civil Rights era into the present day. Racism is still everywhere; stereotypes and biases live on, and Black Americans continue to deal with violence and hatred directed at them, just as this speaker does. Would she anticipate this kind of violence from another Black person? Another person of color? This seems unlikely. Therefore, it is most likely that the "you" in the poem is white people.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.