I Stand Here Ironing

by Tillie Olsen

Start Free Trial

Student Question

How would "I Stand Here Ironing" change if a part directly involving Emily was retold from her perspective?

Quick answer:

If "I Stand Here Ironing" were retold from Emily's perspective, the narrative would shift to explore her feelings of fear, neglect, and isolation more intimately. Emily's experiences after her mother's remarriage, her time at the convalescent home, and her eventual discovery of comedy could be depicted with a focus on her emotional responses. This perspective would provide insight into her jealousy and distance from her mother, and highlight her personal growth through her talent.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Tillie Olsen's story "I Stand Here Ironing" would be much different indeed if it were told from Emily's point of view. Let's brainstorm some ways you can rewrite part of the story to let Emily herself speak.

Your first step in this assignment is to choose a section of the story to focus on. You might choose to concentrate on Emily's experiences after her mother's remarriage. Emily must stay home alone, and she is often scared. Then when her mother gives birth to her little sister, Emily again finds herself alone and sick with the measles. She is often plagued with nightmares. You could express the girl's terrors and feelings of neglect.

Alternatively, you could zoom in on Emily's experiences at the convalescent home. These are almost torture for a sensitive child like Emily, who has little to no contact with her mother and is almost completely isolated. If you choose this section, also discuss why Emily is stiff with her mother and jealous of her sister when she returns home.

Finally, you could choose Emily's winning of the school amateur show and her discovery of comedy. Here is a good opportunity to show how the girl's personality changes because of her newly discovered talent. Emily finds a comfort and a delight in her performances.

Remember, as you write, to narrate in Emily's voice and thoroughly express her emotions. If, for instance, you select the second option above, you might start out with something like "I never did understand why my mother sent me away to that horrible place where I lived almost completely by myself for eight whole months."

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial