What happens in Spoon River Anthology?
In Spoon River Anthology, Edgar Lee Masters collects 246 poems ("epitaphs"), each written from the point of view of a deceased citizen of Spoon River. Each citizen has his or her unique view of the world, and the epitaphs they deliver collectively form a narrative of their small town.
The collection opens with a poem titled "The Hill," in which a cemetery speaks about the villagers buried on its grassy hill.
Some of the characters in the collection include: Mr. Painter, the lawyer; Mr. Trainor, the druggist; the self-righteous Judge Somers; and the drunkard, Chase Henry, who has been gifted an expensive tombstone, much to his amusement.
Many epitaphs refer to previous poems, giving the reader the the sense that Spoon River was a small community in which the lives of its residents were deeply intertwined.
Spoon River Anthology encourages and almost demands the rereadings of epitaphs, because almost all these poems make references to characters and events mentioned in other poems. The reader soon comes to appreciate that each inhabitant of Spoon River expresses a partial and very personal perception of reality. The speakers, who are all now dead, will never understand that their views of themselves differ greatly from the opinions held by their fellow villagers. Each rereading of epitaphs helps one to see beyond appearances in order to discover the hidden and complex emotional and social realities in this village.
Spoon River Anthology is certainly not merely a work of historical interest about life in small American towns in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. These 246 epitaphs express a microcosm of almost any town—be it in the United States or elsewhere—from any century. Successive generations of readers have discovered many different levels of meaning in these poems.
Masters began this book with a powerful poem titled “The Hill.” As its title suggests, this poem is spoken by the cemetery itself, which is located on a hill overlooking the town. The cemetery asks repeatedly “where” certain villagers now are; the answer is not that they are in Heaven. The cemetery repeatedly answers its own question by responding: “All, all are sleeping on the hill.” This eternal “sleep” has brought little consolation to those whose lives were filled with unhappiness. The solitude and loneliness of those “whom life had crushed” have become permanent.
Although the dead speakers in the Spoon River Anthology are extremely diverse in their social backgrounds and personalities, Masters included several similar sets of poems that are spoken by spouses and by other members of the same family. These series of poems show clearly that personality conflicts or an unwillingness to communicate can doom a marriage to failure. Some critics have suggested that Masters was thinking about his own unhappy first marriage or of the profound incompatibility of his parents.
Among the most effective epitaphs spoken by...
(The entire section is 1,398 words.)