Themes: Trauma and Recovery
Speak covers about a year in the life of Melinda, a teenage girl who suffered a trauma the summer before the book’s action begins. A teenage boy, Andy, who attends the same school, raped her during a party. The rape was so traumatic that for most of that year she cannot even use the word, even to herself, but remembers that he “hurt” her. She generally does not use his name, calling him “it.” Because the returning memory and her being able to say the word take many months, and the novel is told from Melinda’s perspective, the reader learns late in the book just how serious an issue she has been handling.
For Melinda, the recovery process is aided by some of her friends and one teacher, but she does not receive counseling or medical attention. She devises her own methods of coping with her emotions but for months is blocked in terms of recalling or speaking of the rape. The limits of medical attention are shown when she loses her way one day and wanders through the wards of a hospital. There she feels disconnected from the patients but senses that they are more ill than she is.
Melinda’s personal safety at home and at school becomes increasingly important to her. Her bedroom at home, still decorated in a childish style that her mother selected, represents both her lost innocence and her difficult relationship with her mother. Melinda spends considerable time outfitting an otherwise unused closet at school as a secure hideaway and a vehicle for self-expression. She realizes later that it is not secure, but it is the place where she faces and resists Andy, including through recovering her voice. Thus, having a safe space is an important component of, but not a fully adequate strategy for, recovery.
Expert Q&A
What does the quote, "When people don't express themselves, they die one piece at a time," from Speak mean?
The quote "When people don't express themselves, they die one piece at a time," from "Speak" signifies the detrimental effect of suppressing emotions. Mr. Freeman, who says this to Melinda, believes that repressing feelings, even if they are painful, is harmful. This statement directly applies to Melinda, who stifles her emotions and memories by not discussing a traumatic incident. Mr. Freeman encourages her to channel her feelings through her art to prevent her emotional deterioration.
In Speak, what are three instances where Melinda begins to find her voice?
Melinda begins to find her voice through several key events. First, she forms a friendship with Ivy in art class, which helps her reconnect with her creativity and confidence. Second, she boldly protests giving a speech in class, showing growing self-assurance. Third, Melinda anonymously warns others about Andy Evans by writing in a bathroom stall, indicating her readiness to confront her trauma indirectly. These moments mark her gradual emergence from silence and isolation.
How does Melinda's art development reflect her healing process in Speak?
Melinda's art development in Speak reflects her healing process by symbolizing her emotional growth and self-perception. Initially, her art is dark and lifeless, mirroring her trauma and silence. As she engages with Cubism and receives support, her creativity flourishes. By spring, her evolving tree project represents renewal and her regained voice, culminating in a completed painting that signifies her recovery and newfound strength.
How does the motif of "speaking" in the novel Speak develop the protagonist's character?
The motif of "speaking" in "Speak" represents Melinda Sordino's journey from silence to finding her voice. Traumatized by a rape at a summer party, Melinda initially refuses to speak, symbolizing her isolation and fear. Her silence alienates her from friends and family, further deepening her withdrawal. The novel's title underscores the critical need for Melinda to overcome her trauma by eventually speaking out and reclaiming her agency and identity.
In Speak, what are Melinda's deepest fears and does she overcome them?
Melinda's deepest fears are rooted in her traumatic experience of being raped by Andy Evans, which leads to her fear of him and her reluctance to speak about the incident. Throughout the school year, she struggles with isolation and silence. However, she gradually begins to heal through art and gardening. Ultimately, Melinda confronts Andy, reveals the truth to her friend Rachel, and overcomes her fears, setting her on a path to recovery.
How can the following passage from Speak be analyzed?
I know my head isn't screwed on straight. I want to leave, transfer, warp myself to another galaxy. I want to confess everything, hand over the guilt and mistake and anger to someone else. There is a beast in my gut, I can hear it scraping away at the inside of my ribs. Even if I dump the memory, it will stay with me, staining me. My closet is a good thing, a quiet place that helps me hold these thoughts inside my head where no one can hear them.
In Speak, what is the significance of Andy Evans' assault on Melinda?
Andy Evans' assault on Melinda is significant as it highlights the devastating impact of sexual abuse, illustrating how such trauma can silence and crush a victim's spirit. Throughout the school year, Melinda's silence symbolizes this emotional death, but her eventual recovery parallels the rebirth of her spirit, akin to the art projects she creates. Andy's predatory behavior reflects a dehumanizing attitude, which Melinda counters by referring to him as "It," emphasizing her struggle to comprehend his inhumanity.
What is the significance of the quote, "I figure it's the best chance I have to make eye contact with one of my friends, if any of them have decided to talk to me yet"?
The quote highlights Melinda's isolation and the silence surrounding her during her first marking period of high school. It underscores her social alienation following traumatic events, including an assault and being ostracized for calling the police. Eye contact becomes her only means of communication with her former friends, indicating her struggle to reconnect and speak. This reflects her state of isolation, which she begins to overcome as the school year progresses.
Why does Melinda's father suggest she needs professional help?
Melinda's father suggests she needs professional help because he cannot understand the changes in her behavior, such as her silence and withdrawal, due to his ignorance of her traumatic experience of being raped. Preoccupied with his own issues, like unemployment, he views her as simply "depressed" or a "typical teenager." His suggestion for professional help reflects his inability to grasp the true depth of her struggles and offer the necessary emotional support.
The causes of Melinda's silence and what prompts her to finally speak in Speak
Melinda's silence in Speak is caused by the trauma of being raped by Andy Evans and the subsequent social ostracization she faces after calling the police at a summer party. She finally speaks out when she sees Andy attacking another girl, which empowers her to confront her own experience and reclaim her voice.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
