Themes: The Immortality of Poetry
In the second half of the sonnet, the poet argues for the immortality of poetry. He frames this written form as a consolation for the brevity of youth and beauty. Although the physical beauty of his beloved is unlikely to endure, the beauty of his “summer” will be "eternal" because it will be committed to paper in words that ring out across centuries, recording his lovely appearance for readers yet to come. Indeed, the sonnet broaches the theme of writing and its enduring qualities, arguing that written work can confer immortality upon its subjects. The poet suggests that the "eternal lines" of his work will prevent his beloved from being lost in the spell of death. Although he may literally and physically die, the poem will "give life to" him for as long as people are still living to read it. The sonnet is at once mournful and joyful, grieving the beauty that must fade but celebrating the creative means by which the speaker maligns death and subverts the inevitable. Poetry becomes an eternal record the speaker uses to reverse the natural order in the name of love and adoration.
Expert Q&A
How does Shakespeare immortalize his friend in "Sonnet 18"?
In "Sonnet 18," Shakespeare immortalizes his friend by glorifying him through the sonnet itself. The friend is portrayed as more lovely and temperate than a summer's day, with the poem's immortality ensuring his "eternal summer" will not fade. The sonnet's theme is encapsulated in the last two lines: "So long as men can breathe, or eyes can see, / So long lives this, and this gives life to thee." Thus, as long as the sonnet is read, the friend's memory lives on.
What does "eternal lines to time" mean in Sonnet 18 and how does it connect to the prediction in lines 9-11?
"Eternal lines to time" in Sonnet 18 means that the subject's beauty will be immortalized through the poem. This connects to lines 9-11, where Shakespeare predicts that her beauty will never fade and death will not claim her because she will live on in the poem. As long as people read the poem, her beauty will endure forever.
Has the speaker in Sonnet 18 successfully immortalized his love? Is this merely a poetic device?
The speaker in "Sonnet 18" successfully immortalizes his love by comparing his beloved's unchanging beauty to the fleeting nature of summer. Although his beloved cannot literally survive death, the speaker achieves immortality through the poem itself. The final lines, "So long as men can breathe or eyes can see, / So long lives this, and this gives life to thee," suggest that as long as the poem is read, his beloved's essence remains eternal.
Is the argument for immortality flawed in Shakespeare's Sonnet 18? Why?
The argument for immortality in Shakespeare's "Sonnet 18" is flawed because the speaker immortalizes his love and feelings rather than the beloved's actual qualities. The poem captures the speaker’s rapture and perception of beauty, but not the beloved's essence. This focus on abstract emotions rather than the individual leads to a fleeting nature of relationships, as the poem immortalizes the speaker's feelings, rather than the beloved's true beauty or character.
What is the irony of seeking immortality through art according to the theme of Shakespeare's Sonnet 18?
The irony in seeking immortality through art, as depicted in Shakespeare's "Sonnet 18," lies in the fact that while the poet promises eternal life to the beloved through the poem, it is the poem itself that achieves immortality. The beloved's memory endures only because the poem does, highlighting the paradox that the subject gains eternal life indirectly through the enduring nature of the art itself.
What gives life to the speaker's beloved in Sonnet 18?
In "Sonnet 18," the speaker's beloved is given life through the poem itself. Although the beloved's physical beauty will fade and he will eventually die, he is immortalized in the sonnet's words. Shakespeare asserts that his beloved's "eternal summer shall not fade," contrasting the transient nature of a summer's day with the enduring power of art. Thus, the beloved's essence is preserved forever in verse, showcasing art's ability to transcend time.
What does "But thy eternal summer shall not fade" mean in Shakespeare's "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?"
In Shakespeare's sonnet, "But thy eternal summer shall not fade" means that the speaker's beloved possesses a beauty and loveliness that will not diminish over time, unlike a summer's day. While summer is fleeting and subject to decline, the beloved's "eternal summer" signifies enduring beauty. The sonnet itself serves to immortalize the beloved, ensuring her beauty and essence live on as long as the poem is read.
What words or phrases in Sonnet 18 suggest the opposite of death?
In "Sonnet 18," phrases suggesting the opposite of death include "eternal summer," which implies perpetual life and beauty, and the assertion that death will not "brag thou wander’st in his shade." The speaker promises his beloved an "eternal summer" through his poetry, which ensures her immortality. The concluding lines declare that as long as people live to read the poem, it will continue to give life to her, thus defying death.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
