Student Question
Does Roland view religion as a guide to life or an excuse to fight?
Quick answer:
Roland primarily views religion as an excuse to fight rather than a guide to life. His motivations are largely secular, focused on maintaining his reputation and honor rather than religious devotion. Although he invokes God and the saints, it serves more as an oath than a true expression of faith. Roland's reluctance to summon help reflects a concern with personal honor over religious guidance, highlighting his secular worldview even in a divinely influenced context.
Roland's motive to fight throughout the book is largely secular in nature. At the climax of the work, when Roland faces almost certain death, his primary concern is to maintain his reputation. When his friend and comrade Oliver asks if he should blow the horn to summon the main body of Charlemagne's force, Roland replies angrily:
Answers Roland: "My anger is inflamed.
Never, please God His Angels and His Saints,
Never by me shall Frankish valour fail!
Rather I'll die than shame shall me attain.
The non-Christian Saracens are portrayed as bound for hell, and Roland does, obviously, invoke the name of "God...and his Saints," but it is more as an oath than any confession of faith. While steeped in a worldview that emphasized a divine hand in most aspects of life, he is primarily concerned with his honor, not an appeal to religion. The reader is caught up in a debate between the pragmatic Oliver and the honorable, if arrogant, Roland. By the time Roland agrees to blow on the oliphant, his fate is sealed.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
References