armed with sword and shield and his horn at his side, Roland attacks another soldier

The Song of Roland

Start Free Trial

Critical Introduction

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The enduring epic, The Song of Roland, stands as a fascinating testament to the chivalric romance literature of medieval France. Categorized among the chansons de geste, it captures the heroic and religious ethos of its time, weaving together tales of knighthood, battles, and Christian virtues. Despite its historical inaccuracies, the poem offers a compelling glimpse into the medieval mindset and remains a vital piece of literary heritage.

Chansons de Geste: The Epic Form

The chansons de geste are epic narratives that flourished between the eleventh and thirteenth centuries, primarily written in French verse. These stories, composed initially in ten-syllable lines and later in twelve-syllable Alexandrine lines, explore themes centered around battles, heroism, and knightly ideals. As time progressed, the narrative style shifted from verse to prose, and rhyme began to replace assonance in the latter part of this era. Although driven by heroic feats and epic battles, these tales left little room for themes of love or female characters, contrasting with later medieval romances that emphasized chivalric pursuits and romantic adventures.

The Song of Roland, situated within this genre, is a "song of great deeds" showcasing the exploits of Charlemagne and his knights. While other epic tales like Lodovico Ariosto’s Orlando Furioso pivoted towards romantic themes of a lovesick knight, The Song of Roland remains firmly rooted in its portrayal of martial valor and loyalty.

Historical Context and Interpretation

The historical foundation of The Song of Roland can be traced back to a real event documented by Einhard in the Annales regni Francorum. This incident describes a Basque ambush of Charlemagne’s army in 778 during a retreat through the Pyrenees. Interestingly, the narrative's focus on defeat diverges from the typical heroic victories celebrated in chansons de geste. Scholars have debated this anomaly, proposing varied interpretations such as the intertwining of Roland’s story with the pilgrimage route to St. James of Compostella or as an adaptation highlighting Christian themes.

Another viewpoint considers the poem as an homage to virtues like courage, loyalty, and patriotism in adversity. Regardless of the explanation, recurring themes of religious fervor and heroic valor permeate the narrative, reflecting the dual obsessions of the high Middle Ages.

Religious Themes and Crusading Spirit

Embedded within The Song of Roland is a potent religious motif contrasting Christians and Saracens, infusing the tale with a crusading zeal. Charlemagne and his cohorts exemplify the seven cardinal virtues, with even Roland displaying humility in death. In stark contrast, the pagan adversaries personify the seven deadly sins, characterized by treachery and greed rather than faith or principle-driven pursuits. Ganelon’s betrayal illustrates the zero-tolerance attitude towards treason, met with severe punishment.

The narrative does not shy away from divine interventions, where the archangel Gabriel aids Charlemagne by defeating the Saracen leader Baligant, and God prolongs daylight for Christian victory. This divine involvement extends to the trial of Ganelon, reinforcing the unquestionable justice of the Christian cause, which includes forced conversions and battlefield conquests. To the medieval mind, such contradictions were reconciled through unwavering faith, obliterating any perceived inconsistencies between religious virtues and wartime actions.

Heroic Ideals and Martial Valor

The heroic theme is inseparably linked with the religious, as most heroic acts in the poem are executed in the name of religious duty. However, the hero’s journey also embraces ideals like loyalty and bravery, which stand independently from religious teachings. These virtues, often implicit within the narrative, drive the plot and character actions. Single combat as a means to resolve significant conflicts underscores another heroic ideal prevalent in the poem.

Within this framework, motifs of victory and defeat, treason and...

(This entire section contains 832 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

revenge, are intricately woven into the heroic code. Roland’s early pride and reluctance to call for Charlemagne’s help, resulting in dire consequences, highlight the lesson of collective teamwork over individual honor. Although Charlemagne ultimately commands authority, his peers actively participate in decision-making, showcasing a blend of autocratic rule and shared governance.

The social and political justice system portrayed in Charlemagne’s court serves as an exemplary model of the heroic ideal, transcending religious imperatives. The characteristics of heroism, thus, exist on a distinct plane from the religious doctrine, contributing to the poem’s unique exploration of medieval values.

Literary Legacy and Cultural Impact

The Song of Roland offers an expansive view of medieval life, capturing the psychological and emotional currents of the era far beyond simple historical representation. Though its narrative is not an accurate historical account, the epic provides deeper insights into the sociological and cultural realities of its time. This aspect of the poem transcends factual data, portraying the spirit rather than the literal history of the Middle Ages.

In this respect, The Song of Roland succeeds as a vibrant document of medieval thought, encompassing the ethical simplicities and literary directness characteristic of the time. Its continued resonance and appeal may be attributed to its ability to encapsulate the essence of the medieval spirit, using fiction to reveal truths about the human condition and societal values of the period.

Next

Critical Overview

Loading...