Snakes and Earrings

by Hitomi Kanehara

Start Free Trial

Snakes and Earrings

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Hitomi Kanehara’s Snakes and Earrings begins as the young and beautiful “Barbie Girl” Lui finds herself mesmerized by the split, snakelike tongue of a young man named Ama. Although Lui is never quite certain whether it is Ama or his enviable tongue that attracts her, she immediately enters into a sexual relationship with him. The next day Ama takes Lui to a tattoo parlor called Desire, owned and operated by Ama’s friend Shiba-san, who will begin the piercing process that will culminate in a tongue just like her lover Ama’s. The reasons for Lui’s immediate partnering with Ama, as well as the reasons for her fascination with acquiring a snakelike tongue, remain ambiguous. Although Lui’s motivations with regard to a number of situations will, to some extent, remain mysterious, such questions of meaning and motivation are at the core of this novel.

One can interpret Lui’s wish for a forked tongue as part of a desire to feel acute pain, arising from her conviction that there is nothing for her in which to believe and nothing for her to feel. Often detached from her emotions, Lui experiences a desire to have her tongue pierced which can be viewed as an effort to secure at least the reality of her own body, and the pain it feels, in a world empty of any reliable meaning. The pointlessness of her life throughout the story seems to be related to her status as a rootless young woman and part-time “freeter” in the Japanese economy. Her adoption of a counterculture lifestyle, however, leaves her adrift. Despite her efforts to awaken her flesh through the use of pain, she feels strangely disembodied.

Her drinking binges, self-starvation, and peculiar love affairs, along with her obsessional interest in body piercing, seem to amount to nothing of any particular significance. She finds it difficult to attach any actual meaning or recognizable human motive to anything she does. The transgressive aspects of her behavior do suggest, however, that she is determined to identify herself as a nonconformist, in flight from mainstream Japanese society, which would regard her alteration of her body as a violation of the tradition of filial piety. Even as the underworld of tattoos and piercing have a deviance Lui might read as liberating, this world at the same time seems little more than an aspect of the modern consumer industry. Her pursuit of such countercultural symbols acquires some of the banality associated with modern recreational shopping.

After Ama introduces Lui to Shiba-san, she begins a clandestine sadomasochistic sexual relationship with him, evidently motivated by little more than a desire to trade sex for Shiba’s tattoo and piercing services. Like the tongue-piercing, however, sex with Shiba involves levels of pain that shock her out of her apathy. Although Shiba is far more abusive as a sexual partner than Ama, both men have violent tendencies. When a local gangster makes a pass at Lui on one of the dense, neon-lit streets of the Shinjuku district, Ama loses control and beats the gangster to a bloody pulp, pulling out two of the man’s teeth to give to Lui. Lui begins to feel that Ama could one day kill her as well. Even though she is unsure of her feelings for him, she decides to protect him from the possibility of arrest for this crime by making sure he changes his appearance.

Although Ama is increasingly devoted to her and emotionally dependent on her, it is clear their relationship does not awaken any similar feelings in Lui, who instead begins a depressive descent into alcoholism and anorexia, all the while...

(This entire section contains 1746 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

increasing the size of the hole in her tongue by inserting larger studs. Her inability to connect emotionally with Ama is demonstrated in her continued encounters with Shiba, in secret, for brutal sex. Attracted to his violence, Lui also desires the cosmetic alterations of her body Shiba can provide. In addition to Lui’s pierced tongue, Shiba creates an elaborate tattoo on her back that joins the mythical figure of a dragon with that of a kirin, or unicorn. Significantly, Lui asks that the dragon and the kirin both be made eyeless because of a superstitious belief that sightlessness will keep these treasured tattoos from escaping her skin. This reminds the reader that, rather than her increasingly alcohol-fueled life with Ama, or Shiba’s rough sex, it is the imprints on her flesh that have an overriding importance for Lui.

It is possible that Lui’s double life with her two lovers would eventually have been disrupted by her escalating anorexia and alcoholism, but it is the sudden disappearance of Ama that precipitates a crisis. The routine of Lui’s life with her lover comes to a halt when she learns he has been brutally tortured, raped, and beaten to death. Ama’s death produces a number of different reactions from Lui. Whatever grief she may have felt for a man she is not sure she knew or loved is almost immediately translated into the pain she causes herself to endure when she introduces a lower-gauge stud in her tongue in order to further advance the splitting process. She also asks Shiba to tattoo eyes into the mythical animals on her back, a gesture that seems to suggest she has not only given them their spiritual freedom but that she has also set Ama and herself free.

During this period of unconventional mourning for Ama, Lui finally becomes fully conscious of the defects in their relationshipsuch as the fact that she never knew, or particularly cared to know, his real name or anything about his family or his job. The recognition of her own incuriosity and lack of affect feeds into a self-loathing that has surfaced throughout the narrative, suggesting that Lui has always, to some extent, been aware of her personality disorders. Although Lui realizes she failed to develop a real bond with Ama, to commemorate his love for her she smashes his courtship gift of the gangster’s two teeth into a powder, which she downs with her ever-present bottle of beer. This incident, like so many in Lui’s narrative, remains enigmatic in terms of motive and meaning.

Such rituals as the smashing of the gangster’s teeth seem to exert a strange healing effect on Lui. Another healing aspect of Lui’s response to Ama’s death is her effort to develop a greater emotional intimacy with Shiba. Complicating her relationship with him, however, is her discovery of evidence that suggests it was Shiba who committed the sexually sadistic murder of Ama. Although Lui realizes she is very likely living with her former boyfriend’s twisted killer, she destroys the evidence that may lead to his arrest, putting the disturbing crime behind her with surprising equanimity. Once again, an initial interpretation of Lui’s behavior may suggest that she is operating on an extremely shallow and superficial plane. Underneath the surface, however, there is the suggestion that Ama’s death held deep and important psychological ramifications for her. It was Ama who was her guide and mentor on her journey into this nihilistic countercultural underworld, and his death has somehow allowed Lui to begin to rise out of it.

Throughout the story, Kanehara has employed imagery of lightlessness as a way to describe Lui’s situation, indeed, as a way to describe the rest of her character’s life. Lui anticipates her future as pitch-black, filled with shadows and ashes, or as an exitless tunnel. She is seeking to create an underworld of dark materiality, without sunshine, love, or laughter, in which there is nothing spiritual and in which she herself is little more than a shadow. Ama’s grisly death at the hands of Shiba, however, and the tattoos, piercings, and the sexual abuse she receives at his hands returns to her a nascent will to live.

After Ama’s death, when Shiba introduces eyes into the faces of the mystical creatures he has tattooed on her back, Lui intuitively and instantly understands that he will no longer abuse her and that he will instead look after her and love her. The final lines of the novel incorporate a welcoming sunlight for the first time, in direct opposition to the metaphors of lightlessness that had previously characterized the narrative. On the day the novel concludes, in an ambiance of powerful morning sunlight, Lui chooses water instead of beer to drink, the flow of the cool water down her throat leading her to feel as if suddenly a life-giving river had grown inside of her.

Euphoric amid the experience of water and light, Lui nevertheless is still, to some extent, seeking a split tongue of the kind inspired by Ama. Her pursuit returns the narrative to the issue of the painful body piercings that began her journey. It may be that she will continue to transform her tongue into a snakelike shape. Whether or not she will decide her tongue piercing is little more than an empty consumer preference, Lui knows her journey into the world of tattoos and piercing has not been simply meaningless or defiantly deviant. By the end of the narrative, the reader is allowed to consider all of her risky, masochistic behaviors as, on a deep level, healing-related. Perhaps they are even part of a larger spiritual process, so that her pursuit of her forked tongue at the end of the novel is, surprisingly, placed within a context of an ultimate quest for health and wholeness. Additionally, the imagery of the snake, the dragon, and the kirin point to totem animals that traditionally carry mythical powers and virtues. These may suggest that Lui herself has been in search of such positive attributes.

Deploying a direct, pull-no-punches prose style that does not shy away from graphic sexual passages, Snakes and Earrings shocked readers in Japan with its unblinking depiction of the dark side of a Japanese youth culture utterly estranged from traditional beliefs or values. Kanehara’s youth and gender particularly contributed to the public’s surprise at her ability to present a stark but powerful picture of the depression and dissociation of a generation coming of age in a demoralized, post-“bubble” economy. Beyond its relevance for modern-day Japan, her astute psychological study of a disaffected personality can also be appreciated within a global context; Kanehara’s young people are denizens of a pervasive contemporary counterculture that transcends national boundaries.

Bibliography

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Artforum, June-September, 2005, p. 52.

Booklist 101, no. 16 (April 15, 2005): 1432.

Entertainment Weekly, May 27, 2005, p. 146.

The Guardian, May 30, 2005, p. 8.

Kirkus Reviews 73, no. 6 (March 15, 2005): 307.

Library Journal 130, no. 5 (March 15, 2005): 72.

The New York Times, March 27, 2004, p. A4.

Loading...