Summary
Set in the forbidding landscape of central Alaska, The Smell of Other People’s Houses (2016) is a coming-of-age narrative that intertwines the stories of four very different teenagers as they each come to terms with the realities of their dysfunctional families. In each other and their improbable friendships, they find a pathway to hopeful futures.
Although marketed as Young Adult fiction, educators and parents praised the novel as much for its poetic prose as for its unflinching portrayal of the complex issues teens must often confront, including unexpected pregnancy, poverty, racism, divorce, religious bigotry, alcoholism, and sexual abuse. The novel received numerous YA awards, most notably shortlisted for the prestigious William C. Morris Medal, presented annually by the American Library Association for the most accomplished debut YA novel.
The novel opens in 1970. Sixteen-year-old Ruth Lawrence, growing up in the poorer neighbors of Fairbanks, Alaska, barely remembers her father, a passionate advocate against Alaskan statehood killed in a plane crash on his way back from Washington when she was five. Her mother, who never recovered from the trauma, was committed to a nearby Catholic-run hospital soon after.
Ruth and her younger sister, Lily, were raised by their grandmother, Marguerite, whose staunch Catholicism makes her an intimidating disciplinarian. When Ruth finds herself pregnant after a reckless night with a casual boyfriend, she is not sure where to turn. She confides in her close friend, the ever-upbeat Selma, who is raised by her aunt, Abigail Flowers.
Abigail’s other niece, sixteen-year-old Alyce, helps out her father, a commercial fisherman. Her mother, despairing over the dead-end of life in Fairbanks, divorced her father years earlier. Alyce, a gifted dancer, dreams of pursuing ballet and has her hopes pinned on an approaching audition for a prestigious ballet company. She hesitates because she believes her father relies on her to help run the struggling fishing business.
Teenager Dora Peters faces an uncertain life. Her father, an alcoholic given to violent rages, is in jail after shooting up the bathroom at a local dive. Her mother, a barely functioning alcoholic, scrounges for money to provide for her daughter. Dora spends much of her time at the home of her friend, the good-natured Dumpling. Dora enters a local lottery to predict the day in the spring when the ice on the nearby river will finally thaw. Dora wins the $2000 prize, which only enrages her greedy father.
Meanwhile, down the coast in Sitka, seventeen-year-old Hank and his two younger brothers, Jack (14) and Sam (16), face a grim future when their mother, a widow, decides to remarry. Their father, a fisherman, died in the massive 1964 Good Friday Earthquake when he took out his boat after the earthquake and a resulting tsunami overtook him. Deciding that life with an abusive stepfather is untenable, the three brothers stow away on a ferry headed north.
Cramped in the baggage deck, the boys sneak on deck to find something to eat. Sam is momentarily mesmerized by a passing pod of orcas, recalling his belief that his father was saved by whales. As he stares into the water, he accidentally falls overboard. Alyce, out on the water with her father, rescues the floating boy.
Meanwhile, Ruth’s grandmother, now aware of Ruth’s pregnancy, dispatches Ruth to a Catholic orphanage in the Canadian Yukon. Marguerite was raised there when her parents abandoned her. Before Ruth boards the bus, she gives Dumpling a note to deliver to her mother. In return, Dumpling gifts Ruth with a red ribbon she says will bring her love.
On the ferry, Hank and Jack search for their missing brother....
(This entire section contains 1093 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
They befriend Phil, the night watchman. Phil, trying to reassure them, shares how, years ago, he found a newborn abandoned by her mother and took the baby to child services. Tearfully, Phil admits he never knew what became of her, save that she was sent to a foster home in Fairbanks. Recalling this, he offers the boys help, adding that he knows a large family in Fairbanks that might be willing to take them in temporarily. He writes the girl’s name, Selma, on a paper towel and gives it to Jack in case they meet her. When the ferry docks in Prince Rupert, Phil commits Hank and Jack to the care of Isabelle from child services. She offers to drive the boys to Fairbanks herself, explaining she is Alyce’s aunt and is heading to Fairbanks anyway for her niece’s dance audition.
Two days later, while taking a break at a gas station, Hank tries to comfort his younger brother by buying him a sno-cone. Ruth is at the same gas station, having accompanied a nun to deliver soap made at the convent. Watching the two brothers interact, she tears up over the boys’ love.
Hank is transfixed by the pregnant girl, noticing as she and the nun depart that she dropped a red ribbon in the mud. That night, Hank, determined to return the ribbon, sneaks out and heads to the nearby convent. Naked, he swims the river to the convent, where he encounters a stunned Ruth who gratefully gifts Hank the ribbon.
Back in Fairbanks, Dumpling sets out to deliver Ruth’s note to her mother in the hospital outside town. Accompanied by Dora and Lily, she takes several three-wheelers, and together, they head to the facility. However, Ruth’s mother is too agitated to understand why Dumpling is there. On the way back, Dumpling’s three-wheeler upends on the muddy road, pinning her. When medivac teams arrive, Dumpling is airlifted to a Fairbanks hospital in a coma.
Weeks pass. At the convent, Ruth meets the young couple who want to adopt her baby. Back in Fairbanks, as the time for the audition approaches, Alyce discovers her father knows about the opportunity and is determined to give her a chance. Along with Sam, who has found a new life working the fishing boat with Alyce, he gets Alyce to the auditorium. Her aunt Isabelle arrives with Hank and Jack in tow. Alyce dances beautifully. In the happy confusion after the performance, the brothers are reunited.
Months later, Alyce, accepted by the dance academy and now involved with Sam, prepares to dance The Nutcracker. Dumpling has recovered from the accident. Ruth returns to Fairbanks and reunites with Hank, who kisses her tenderly. Jack shares Phil’s paper towel note with Ruth, who tells Selma and, in turn, arranges a reunion between Selma and a very nervous Phil. Ruth makes peace with her grandmother and feels her wounded heart beating.