Discussion Topic
Mr. Braithwaite's first day at Greenslade Secondary School in To Sir, with Love
Summary:
Mr. Braithwaite's first day at Greenslade Secondary School is challenging and eye-opening. He encounters unruly students and realizes the difficulties he will face in gaining their respect and establishing discipline. Despite his initial enthusiasm, he quickly understands the tough environment and the need for a strategic approach to connect with and educate his students effectively.
Describe Mr. Braithwaite's first day at Greenslade Secondary School in To Sir, with Love.
After riding a crowded and smelly bus, Mr. Braithwaite arrives at Greenslade Secondary School where he knocks on the door of the Headmaster, Mr. Florian, who greets him warmly, "...we've been expecting you. Do sit down." Mr. Florian, then, suggests that he take a good look around the school as things are "done differently" at this school. When Braithwaite descends the stairs to a narrow hallway, he is nearly knocked down by a tall red-headed girl who rushes out the door of a classroom. As Mr. Braithwaite looks inside the room, one of the students declares that Mr. Hackman is not there, and asks if he is the new teacher.
From here, Mr. Braithwaite heads to the staff room, where he is greeted by the sarcastic remark, "Ah, another lamb to the slaughter," pronounced by a rather slovenly and hairy young man. Asked what has happened to Mr. Hackman and who will take his class, the young man says that Braithwaite will be given it; after this frightening news, he leaves. Then, a tall blond woman, Mrs. Grace Dale-Evans, the Domestic Science teacher, enters. She speaks to Braithwaite asking him about herself as she tidies up the room. Since the room is stale from smoked cigarettes, Braithwaite opens two of the windows, noticing the view out these windows is rather dismal as a high brick wall separates a churchyard from the school.
Soon, Braithwaite goes down the stairs and passes through a doorway to the courtyard, but it is strewn with leaves and debris. Although the day is bright, the courtyard is dim as are Braithwaite's hopes. Then, a handbell is rung and the lunchbreak begins as Braithwaite hurries back to the staff room where teachers enter. He is introduced to Miss Josy Dawes, Miss Euphemia Phillips, Mr. Theo Weston, the hairy teacher, Miss Vivian Clintridge, the art teacher, and Miss Gillian Blanchard. who is also new. While talking with the faculty, Mr. Braithwaite learns that there is no corporeal punishment, nor much of any other kind, at the school.
At the end of the lunch break, the students file into an area by the church where they dance to swing music, the midday dance session. When the tall red-haired girl invites him to dance, Braithwaite is rather disconcerted, while at the same time he is excited at the prospect of teaching such near adult students as he returns to Mr. Florian's office. There, he tells Mr. Florian he will "have a shot at it" and accepts the position. As Mr. Florian begins to explain the socio-economic status of the students, Braithwaite is less inclined to feel sympathy for them, yet he cannot keep from being impressed by Florian's deep concern for the students. He explains,
"As things are we cannot expect of them high academic effort, but we can take steps to ensure that their limited abilities are exploited to the full....We encourage them to speak up for themselves, no matter what the circumstances or the occasion....As teachers, we can help greatly if we become sufficiently important to them...or even outweigh the evil"
As he shakes the hand of Mr. Braithwaite, Mr. Florian tells him they are wonderful children when he gets to know them. Then, Braithwaite returns to the staff room where Mrs. Drew talks with him. On the way home, Braithwaite rejoices at being employed. He vows to learn to cope as he has not entered the teaching field out of any sense of vocation.
What is Braithwaite's impression of the Greenslade School in To Sir, with Love?
When Ricky Braithwaite first arrives at the Greenslade School, he is disgusted by the weeds and garbage in the East End neighborhood where the school is located. When he first tours the school, at the insistence of the headmaster, Mr. Braithwaite is taken aback by what he calls the students' "careless, unscholarly attitudes" (page 14). He calls the scene "soiled and untidy" (page 14), as the girls dress in too-tight sweaters and hair-dos that recall those of their favorite actresses, while the boys wear jeans and t-shirts for the most part. He thinks to himself that the school does not resemble the neat, orderly vision he has of a school but instead looks like a "menagerie" (page 14). When he goes outside, he finds the courtyard dark and depressing, unlike the school where he spent his sunny childhood in British Guiana. He notices that the children shove and push each other with a definite lack of respect, and he wonders if they have the same enthusiasm for school that he had growing up.
Describe Mr. Braithwaite's first day of school in To Sir, With Love.
Mr. Braithwaite's first day of school reflects the difficulty in the journey of teaching and learning. In many ways, it is typical of most first year teachers' first days. There is little in way of control of the students, Braithwaite lacks confidence and a sense of direction with the students. He fails to get through to them in terms of casting any impression of strength and coherency with them. For their part, the students are unruly, demonstrating that their own relationships and their loves are more important than Braithwaite's desire to teach them. On another level, Braithwaite's first day reflects his overall fear and concern with whether or not he has made the right choice in being a teacher, in the first place. There is much in way of hesitation and fear present in everything about Braithwaite, and this comes out in his first day. At the same way, Braithwaite struggles to find anyone in way of professional relationships that can validate that he made the right choice and decision to enter teaching. Braithwaite's first day is a collection of events that make it a "perfect storm" of challenge and uncertainty in both he, his choice to become a teacher, the students, and the professional community around him.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.