Themes: Christian Themes
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, while overtly an exciting and humorous romance, is at heart a deeply religious work. Through the series of tests and games in the poem, the poet demonstrates Gawain’s growth as a human being. Like most humans, Gawain does not understand the real purpose of the tests to which he is subjected until after they are over. It is only in retrospect that he can understand that it is not his honor that is being tested, but his humility; not his lovemaking, but his truthfulness; and not his courage, but his faith in God.
The poem is both subtle and sophisticated as it presents the difficult choices that confront Gawain: he must choose, over and over, among the codes of chivalry, courtesy, and Christianity, codes that are often in conflict with each other. When he leaps to chop off the Green Knight’s head, he believes that he is demonstrating chivalric courage; what he demonstrates is rashness and a lack of Christian charity. When he allows Lady Bertilak into his bed, he believes that he is honoring the code of courtesy; he violates, however, the chivalric response to the hospitality of his host. When he accepts the green girdle, he believes he is saving his own life; but the gift marks his fear of death and his lack of faith. Finally, when he does not give the green girdle to Bertilak at the end of the day, he breaks his promise.
The story reveals the sinful nature of even the most perfect of knights. Gawain suffers from the sins of pride, lack of faith, and dishonesty. His confession to the Green Knight of his wrongdoings allows him ultimately to be redeemed by the Green Knight’s forgiveness. His return to Camelot is marked by his sincere contrition and repentance.
The heart of the poem, ultimately, is the notion of truth. In Middle English, the word “trouthe” had many more nuances of meaning than simply truth as opposed to falsehood. It also connoted a sacred promise and faithfulness. In modern English, this sense continues in the word “troth” as used in a traditional wedding ceremony or in words such as “betroth” and “betrothal.” Gawain’s real failure is not a failure of nerve but rather a failure to keep trouthe. Although he is the Knight of the Virgin Mary, he fails to keep trouthe with her, preferring to trust Lady Bertilak’s magic. In addition, his failure to act honorably in keeping his bargain reveals a failure of trouthe with both King Arthur and Lord Bertilak. Yet, in the court’s embrace of Gawain, the end of the story offers hope and redemption for all of flawed humanity.
Expert Q&A
Analysis of the five virtues of the Pentangle in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and their embodiment in Sir Gawain's character
The five virtues of the Pentangle in "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight" are generosity, fellowship, purity, courtesy, and compassion. Sir Gawain embodies these virtues through his actions and decisions, striving to uphold his knightly honor. His commitment to these principles is tested throughout the poem, showcasing his moral integrity and the challenges of maintaining such ideals.
How does "In serving each other we become free" relate to Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and other medieval literature?
The quote "In serving each other we become free" relates to medieval literature through the chivalric code exemplified by works like Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. This code emphasized loyalty, valor, and service to others, reflecting the knights' duty to protect and serve their community. Although the quote itself isn't from these texts, it aligns with their themes of nobility and justice.
Sir Gawain's temptations in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight
In Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, Sir Gawain faces temptations that test his chivalry and virtue. These include the seductive advances of Lady Bertilak, the temptation to keep the magical green girdle that promises to save his life, and the challenge of maintaining his honor while facing the Green Knight's deadly blow.
Where does Gawain exhibit chastity in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight?
In Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, what do the three kisses mean to Gawain?
In "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight," the three kisses Lady Bertilak gives to Gawain symbolize a test of his chivalry and moral integrity. Gawain, bound by his knightly code, must balance politeness with resistance to temptation, reflecting his dedication to his oath and faith. The kisses parallel the three temptations of Christ, illustrating Gawain's struggle to uphold his honor and the expectations of both his host and the Church.
Why does the Green Knight forgive Gawain?
The Green Knight forgives Gawain for not returning the green girdle to his host, because he only kept the girdle out of fear for his own life and a desire not to die. Sir Gawain was not being willfully wicked or cunning but, rather, simply trying to preserve his own life.
Does Sir Gawain keep his promises in "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight"?
In "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight," Sir Gawain keeps his promise to the Green Knight by seeking him out at the Green Castle a year after their initial encounter, demonstrating his commitment to honor. Despite the daunting nature of the agreement, Gawain's adherence to the chivalric code of loyalty, bravery, and honor compels him to fulfill his promise, reflecting the values of King Arthur's knights.
What is your opinion on the Green Knight's statement to Gawain about a man who's true to his word?
"A man who's true to his word, / there's nothing he needs to fear."
The idea that being true to one's word means that you have nothing to fear has indisputable merits. As Sir Gawain discovered, he would have gotten out of his predicament scot-free had he just honored his obligation to Lord Bertilak.
How can Sir Gawain and the Green Knight be viewed as a moral allegory?
The poem can be viewed as a moral allegory where Sir Gawain's journey symbolizes human experiences and moral tests. The color green represents life and hope, while Gawain's wilderness journey signifies loneliness and despair. Gawain's trials, such as maintaining his honor and integrity against various temptations, symbolize moral choices. His flinch during the Green Knight's final test reflects human fallibility, and the garter serves as a reminder of the moral duties inherent in knighthood.
What is the Virgin Mary's role in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight?
In "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight," the Virgin Mary symbolizes Sir Gawain's religious faith and moral compass. Gawain prays to Mary when lost, indicating his reliance on her guidance. His shield features her image, representing his virtues and Christian devotion. However, Gawain's choice to use the girdle instead of praying to Mary highlights his human frailty and sin, demonstrating a lapse in faith during his trials.
Does Sir Gawain exemplify the ideal Christian knight in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight?
Why are the pentangle and Mary's face painted on a shield in "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight"?
In Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, what flaws do Gawain and the court show before the Green Knight's arrival?
Before the Green Knight's arrival, King Arthur and his court exhibit immaturity and self-indulgence. They prioritize partying over humility and Christian devotion, treating Christmas as a time for indulgence rather than reverence. The court is associated with luxury, and Arthur is characterized by pride and boyishness. Guenevere's depiction as flawless is ironic, given her later reputation. These flaws highlight their need for the Green Knight's lessons in humility and maturity.
What are your thoughts on the Green Knight and his wife's deception towards Gawain in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight?
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
