Themes: The Need for Human Community

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The novel juxtaposes two extremes of human life: isolation and community. Marner spends fifteen years in self-imposed seclusion, depriving himself of life's richness. Ultimately, he finds redemption when circumstances guide him back into human society.

During his years of solitude in Raveloe, disconnected from life's true essence, Marner makes the mistake of treating inanimate objects as if they were alive. His attachment to his gold is so intense that it satisfies his senses of touch and sight: “It was pleasant to feel them [the guineas] in his palm”; he delights in looking at their “bright faces”; they offer him “companionship,” and as he “bathed his hands” in them, he “felt their rounded outline between his thumb and fingers.” He even starts to imagine that the gold is aware of him, similar to how he perceives his loom. Marner’s life, dominated by endless, monotonous, repetitive tasks, mirrors the motions of the loom. His constant hunching over the loom has physically altered him, making him oddly suited to it, resembling a “handle or a crooked tube” that has no independent existence apart from the machine. In his connection with the machine, Marner has lost his link with nature. He completely forgets his earlier interest in herbs and his skill in using them for healing. When he travels through the lanes for work, his mind is solely focused on his money and his loom. The natural world around him goes unnoticed. As a miser, he has imbued lifeless objects with a false sense of life and forgotten the essence of real life. His own existence has diminished to “a mere pulsation of desire and satisfaction that had no relation to any other being.”

The loss of his money turns out to be a hidden blessing for Marner because it breaks his attachment to lifeless objects. It also reveals that the human spirit within him is not entirely extinguished. He vaguely senses that if any help is to come, it must come from outside. This is why, when the villagers show him more sympathy, “there was a slight stirring of expectation at the sight of his fellow-men, a faint consciousness of dependence on their goodwill.” This faint glimmer of hope is symbolized by the fact that at Christmas, Marner, though still grieving, does not try to close the shutters or lock the door of his cottage. Furthermore, he develops a habit of opening his door and looking out from time to time. He does this not out of a conscious desire for companionship, but because he harbors an irrational hope that his money will somehow be returned. However, it is this habit of leaving his door open that allows the child to enter his life. It signifies the beginning of his journey from isolation back to community.

Eppie's arrival has an immediate effect on Marner. When he first sees the child, he imagines she could be his little sister returning in a dream. He remembers carrying his sister in his arms for a year until she passed away. This memory, from a tender period of his childhood that he had locked away, sparks Silas's journey to reconnect with his past. This journey continues as he shares the details of his early life with Dolly Winthrop. Through this sharing, his fragmented psyche starts to mend. With Eppie drawing his thoughts away from their endless loop to a more outward focus, Marner finally becomes ready to integrate into the community life of Raveloe.

While Marner is the epitome of isolation, Raveloe is portrayed as a model of community. Raveloe has two main communal centers: the Squire’s Red House, known for its generosity in providing food to the poor and hosting the New Year’s Eve dance, and the Rainbow Inn, where villagers gather around the hearth to share stories. The residents of Raveloe, though imperfect, are generally easygoing and refrain from moral judgment. Despite a strict class division, there is no envy from the poor towards the rich. It is a community where everyone knows their place, and cooperation and tolerance prevail. This is clearly demonstrated when the men at the Rainbow immediately assist Marner, whom they consider somewhat peculiar, after he tells them he has been robbed. The villagers understand their mutual dependence, and once Marner realizes this as well, he is prepared to participate in the broader community rather than trying to be self-sufficient.

Expert Q&A

Is Silas Marner's love of money in Silas Marner due to greed or loneliness?

Silas Marner's love of money is primarily driven by loneliness rather than greed. After a traumatic betrayal in Lantern Yard, where he lost his reputation and fiancée, Silas becomes isolated. His compulsive hoarding of gold in Raveloe is a means to regain control and compensate for his emotional losses, rather than an indication of financial ambition. Ultimately, money serves as a substitute for the human connection he lacks, illustrating his need for companionship.

In Silas Marner, what is Dolly Winthrop's role and how is she presented?

Dolly Winthrop plays a crucial role in "Silas Marner" as a nurturing and supportive figure who complements Silas's life. She offers him companionship, advice, and practical help, embodying the ideal of a "Christian" and "Good Samaritan." Described as pious, calm, and motherly, Dolly is a beacon of support and moral guidance in the community. Her character reflects the rural values of Raveloe, emphasizing altruism and community care.

What immediate change does the child bring in Silas in Silas Marner?

The immediate change in Silas upon meeting the child, Eppie, is a profound emotional awakening. Initially mistaking her golden hair for his lost gold, Silas experiences a rush of memories and emotions from his past, particularly recalling his little sister and his life in Lantern Yard. Eppie's arrival prompts him to reconnect with his past and opens him to form genuine bonds with the villagers, restoring his capacity for love and hope.

The changing perception of Silas Marner in the community

Silas Marner's perception in the community evolves from being an isolated and mistrusted outsider to a respected and integral member. Initially, his reclusive nature and mysterious past make villagers wary. However, after he adopts Eppie and shows kindness and dedication, the community's attitude shifts, recognizing his true character and valuing his contributions.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: Moral Order

Next

Themes: Class System

Loading...