Critical Evaluation

(Essentials of European Literature)

AT THE SIGN OF THE REINE PEDAUQUE was the first of Anatole France’s many works to exhibit in full his peculiar talents. This tale is gusty in outline and overlaid with vast erudition in philosophy and in ancient history. In plot, the novel is reminiscent of TOM JONES, but the treatment is pure Gallic. France’s humor is always subtle and at times wicked. In the Abbe Jerome, he has created a memorable character, the fluent, scoundrelly cleric who becomes a sympathetic creation.

The novel’s discreet mocking of the occult and its refined and occasionally lusty intelligence appeal more to the brain than the senses. France’s careful artistry and pure style are the perfect vehicle for his peculiar combination of sensitivity and irony. He disliked Romanticism and condemned the crudity of the Realistic school of fiction, and, indeed, there is little of either the romantic or the realistic in this or his other novels. He scorned prose that claimed profundity in obscurity, stating that a good style is complex but does not appear so. Clarity and purity were fundamental qualities of his art, and nowhere do these virtues stand out more admirably than in AT THE SIGN OF THE REINE PEDAUQUE.

The narrative and dialogue are both crowded with epigrams and witticisms, sometimes to the point of almost paralyzing what little action there is in the book. Jacques tells his own story with a strangely sophisticated innocence. Every...

(The entire section is 446 words.)