The Siege and Fall of Troy Analysis
by Robert Graves

Start Your Free Trial


(Beacham's Guide to Literature for Young Adults)

Download The Siege and Fall of Troy Study Guide

Subscribe Now

In his epic poems, Homer tells of ancient Greek and Trojan heroes who fought a war in the thirteenth century B.C. Most scholars today believe that such a war was actually fought in the Bronze Age, but the details were already steeped in myth and legend when Homer transcribed the events. Achilles and the other Greek heroes reflect the culture of Mycenaean society, a patriarchal and bellicose world in which only kings and princes were important enough to be preserved for history. The gods that are portrayed are immortal, more powerful than humans but just as flawed with weaknesses and desires.

The terrible Trojan War is instigated by a quarrel between three goddesses, and is then needlessly prolonged because of the bickering of two heroes. Helen, whose beauty inflames the combatants, is one of many women in the tale who become pawns of the rich and powerful. Homer underscores the seeming futility of the war, while simultaneously glamorizing the exploits of its heroes. Some of the characters lead tragic lives, while others are blessed with a measure of happiness to leaven their sorrows. But pain and suffering are very much a part of the mortal life depicted by Homer.

Literary Qualities

(Beacham's Guide to Literature for Young Adults)

Although Graves retells the Iliad and the Odyssey, he chooses to ignore many of the conventions that govern those epics. In these epics, Homer had a narrowly focused view of his subjects. The Iliad, for example, is the story of the anger of Achilles, not that of the Trojan War. Readers must look elsewhere to learn about such things as the judgment of Paris, the Trojan horse, and Achilles' death. Graves worked from a large body of classical literature, assembling pieces of the legend and myth to suit the purposes of his story. Graves's stated purpose was "to make the whole story, from the foundation of Troy to the return of the victorious Greeks, into a single short book for boys and girls." The result is a fast-paced, comprehensive account, n in a succinct, direct style, with many characterizations that deviate from Homer's portrayals.

Graves had a sober story to tell, the story of "the long, calamitous Trojan War, which benefited nobody." This circumstance makes the isolated examples of selfless courage or affection that sometimes brighten the story all the more ennobling.

Social Sensitivity

(Beacham's Guide to Literature for Young Adults)

The characters in The Siege and Fall of Troy are similar in their human emotions and weaknesses to people today. The society in which they live, however, is very different. Homer, who lived about the eighth century B.C., wrote about the Mycenaean culture that preceded his era by more than five hundred years. This culture valued physical prowess, particularly in war, and had little regard for women, commoners, or slaves. Thus the story of the Trojan War is a tale of kings and princes, revered even though they often behave in a less than admirable fashion. Graves has done little to ennoble his mortal characters. In Homer's version, when Priam visits Achilles to beg for the body of his unburied son, Achilles is moved by Priam's resemblance to his own aged father and talks about the universal sorrow of life. In Graves's version, Achilles is not sympathetic; instead, he is preoccupied with his infatuation for Priam's daughter.

Graves's portrayal of the behavior of the gods is also largely unflattering. Homer's gods are not perfect but their actions, which parallel the actions of mortals, are often the occasion for irony and humor. Graves's gods, on the other hand, are capricious at best.

For Further Reference

(Beacham's Guide to Literature for Young Adults)

Beacham, Walton, ed. Research Guide to Biography and Criticism. Washington, DC: Beacham Publishing, 1985. Entry on Graves by Hallman B. Bryant surveys the published criticism of Graves's work.

Commire, Anne, ed. Something about the Author. Vol. 44. Detroit: Gale Research, 1986. Contains a bibliography of Graves's writings, chronological quotations illustrating important events in his life, and interesting family pictures and illustrations from his books.

Fitzgerald, Robert, trans. The Odyssey. New York: Anchor-Doubleday, 1962. Homer's poem in perhaps the most popular modern translation.

Graves, Robert, trans. The Anger of Achilles: Homer's "Iliad." Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1959. A translation of Homer's complete poem, favorably received but not widely used.

Good-bye to All That. New York: Doubleday, 1957. This is a revision of Graves's 1929 autobiography, with a new prologue and epilogue.

Lattimore, Richmond, trans. The "Iliad" of Homer. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1977. First published in 1951 and perhaps the most popular modern translation.

Seymour-Smith, Martin. Robert Graves: His Life and Work. London: Hutchinson, 1982. This biography is the fruit of a number of years Seymour-Smith spent working with Graves. It is lengthy and very readable.

Snipes, Katherine. Robert Graves. New York: Frederick Ungar, 1979. Snipes's book contains chapters on The White Goddess and on individual novels and includes a very useful, succinct biography; a chronology of important events in Graves's life; and a bibliography of his writings.