Conduct research to learn more about the experiences of African Americans in the post-Civil War South. Do you believe an African American had any chance of receiving a fair trial during that period?

Imagine that Tom had survived and he and Polly were able to meet the following day. What conversation do you think would occur between the sheriff’s children?

What is your moral perspective on the sheriff’s actions throughout the story and his life, particularly regarding his treatment of his illegitimate son and the boy's mother, his efforts to disperse the mob, and his final decision on how to assist Tom?

The majority of the sheriff’s decisions are guided by his sense of duty. To which cause do you believe he feels a greater obligation: aiding Tom or maintaining his official position? Do the sheriff’s previous actions—especially those from his time as a slaveholder—reflect his sense of duty?

Revisit the section on Point of View in the story. Do you think this narrative perspective enhances or detracts from the storytelling? Explain your reasoning.

Do you consider Tom to be a realistic character? Provide your explanation.