Download PDF Print Page Citation Share Link

Last Updated on January 28, 2020, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 878

Materialism and Moral Corruption

The unnamed narrator frequently professes his disdain for the trappings of materialism. He claims not to like wealthy people and their displays of ostentation. At other times, however, he reveals his envy for such possessions and wistfully expresses his desire to compete more effectively in the endless one-upmanship. The dislike stems from his feelings of inadequacy, for which he blames the rich. His ambivalence largely evaporates when he wins the lottery: “Note to future generations: Happiness possible.” He quickly gives in to greed and commits to spending huge amounts on a lavish tableau vivant lawn display, which he rationalizes as a gift for his daughter. He imagines he has achieved some measure of success: “you feel different about self, as if at last you are in step with peers.”

Illustration of PDF document

Download The Semplica Girl Diaries Study Guide

Subscribe Now

While the money influences his moral decline, the reader can infer that the idea of luck fueled his ambition. Earnings from legitimate hard work should not be thrown away on frivolity. The serendipity of the lottery winnings arriving just as he is planning his daughter’s party, however, seems to justify his wasteful and unscrupulous behavior.

The narrator initially expresses no qualms about the negative effects of any element of the young women’s treatment. By objectifying them and concerning himself with the outward appearance of the display, he tries to distance himself from them. The neutralization of shared humanity required for anyone to endorse this type of treatment seems not to trouble him, although in the end he questions the values behind the Semplica Girls’ treatment, which might suggest he had retained but suppressed some moral qualms. The reader doubts his sincerity, however, because these statements are made only after they escape, aided by his own daughter. He seems to blame the women for his emotions, as he wonders why they would “ruin” things by leaving what he wants to believe was a good situation.

Sacrifice versus Exploitation

The author raises a number of challenging questions about people’s mistreatment of those they label as “Other.” The young women who participate in the living displays have apparently agreed to do so of their own free will, according to the diarist. One of the story’s prominent ideas is that humans voluntarily make temporary sacrifices that will lead to future benefits for themselves, or to help their families, other loved ones, or larger communities. But we are left to wonder if the Semplica Girls are actually doing this. After they leave, an investigating policeman laughs that the narrator would wonder why: “First cop: Smelling that American dream, baby.”

The story’s structure prevents the reader from hearing directly from the women themselves. The narrator describes the Semplica Girls as “smiling” and wants to reassure his daughter Eva that “they are not sad but actually happy, given what their prior conditions were like.” As he imagines the women’s reasons for traveling to a distant, foreign country, the narrator wonders if they would ever return to their “home + family.” He also imputes materialistic motives similar to his own, commenting that they had desired a “big bag of gifts” to bestow on their relatives.

The other type of interpretation is an emphasis on exploitation and coercion. This seems part of a larger critique of capitalism as an ostensibly open market, where anything is for sale. The story contains clear analogies to several US historical issues, including slavery, the display of...

(The entire section contains 878 words.)

Unlock This Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this The Semplica Girl Diaries study guide. You'll get access to all of the The Semplica Girl Diaries content, as well as access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

  • Summary
  • Themes
  • Characters
Start your 48-Hour Free Trial