What are the themes of the poem "The Second Coming"?
"The Second Coming" by Yeats presents a second coming of a different kind; different from the second coming Christian tradition presents.
The poem presents social upheaval and nightmarish violence. The falcon cannot hear the falcon, and thus cannot be controlled: chaos results. Those who could do something about the discord "lack conviction," while the worst are filled with "passionate intensity." An ambiguous, sphinx-like creature with a "gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,/Is moving its slow thighs" toward Bethlehem (metaphorically) to be born. The "rough beast" is coming. Nightmarish violence is coming: not the second coming of Christ that tradition expects.
Human history is about to take a turn for the worse.
Yeats is responding to upheaval and violence in the world, and particularly in the Russian revolution. The 20th century is on the verge of something terrible, the poem suggests. And of course, Yeats was correct. Human beings...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
were never so good at killing other human beings as they were in the 20th-century.
In order to discuss the important themes in the poem "The Second Coming" by Irish Poet William Butler Yeats, you will need to conduct some research in several areas, doing some background reading. Start with Yeats' biography - there you will see background to do with the history of Ireland, his early lyrical poetry, his later more cynical modernist poetry and his religious influences. Then look at the idea of Nativity - particularly with reference to Christianity in the Bible and the idea of the arrival and later further revelations of the Messiah. Look also at the bloody struggle for Irish independence and the portents for war in the whole world at the time. That should be more than enough detail!
Which word in "The Second Coming" is most significant to the poem's theme or argument?
From one perspective, the word "gyre" is the most significant word in William Butler Yeats's poem "Second Coming." If one chooses to interpret the poem based on the poet's deliberate choice of words, then gyre is the most loaded term in the work. Yeats created, with the help of his wife's automatic writing that passed on ideas from supposedly ethereal "teachers," a complicated philosophy/religion by which he interpreted history. Gyres were central to this philosophy. Although many who are acquainted with Christianity are tempted to equate the "second coming" of the poem with the second coming of Jesus Christ, that is not at all what this poem is about. Instead, in Yeats's view, the 2,000-year gyre (era) that began at the birth of Christ was reaching its widest point—its end point—and would soon spin off a new 2,000-year gyre. The next period of history would be characterized by a "rough beast" as mentioned in the final question of the poem.
However, if one chooses to pass over the complexities of Yeats's theories of gyres and interpret the poem based on the imagery and wording that one can understand without any esoteric knowledge, then "pitiless" presents itself as the most important single word. The imagery of the coming age is a sphinx-like creature with a "pitiless" gaze. This image, and the idea of an age bereft of pity, or compassion, represents the modernist rejection of a benevolent God in favor of a malevolent Fate. Yeats was far from alone in his understanding of a force that arranges world and personal affairs not out of love, like the Christian and Jewish God, but out of randomness at best and malice at worst. For example, Thomas Harding's poem "The Convergence of the Twain" speaks of the Immanent Will—a malicious Fate—that planned the "welding" of the Titanic and the iceberg.
The word pitiless, then, aptly represents Yeats's argument that the coming era would be best understood as orchestrated not by a loving God for the good of his creation, but by an uncaring force that would unleash undreamed-of terrors on the upcoming generation.
References