Editor's Choice
To what extent was the Civil War a struggle between two opposing economic systems?
Quick answer:
The Civil War was fundamentally a conflict between two opposing economic systems. The South's economy relied on slavery and raw material production, whereas the North's economy was driven by industrialization and consumer goods. The North's evolving market revolution contrasted sharply with the South's traditional plantation system. This economic divergence led to competing regional interests, with the South perceiving threats to its slavery-dependent economy, prompting tensions that contributed significantly to the war's outbreak.
Many historians view the Civil War as a contest between two very different economic systems. While there were also social factors involved in the conflict, it can be argued that even these had their roots in the differing economies of the northern and southern United States.
Prior to the war, the economy of the South was mostly built on the production of raw materials destined for the commodities markets in the North and in Europe. The acquisition of these materials depended upon the physical labor of slaves. There were very few factories in the South, and little food was produced for local consumption.
The North, on the other hand, had an economy built on the production of consumer products. This was due to the many factories throughout the North. Many of these products were dependent on raw materials produced in the South. Also, more than enough food was farmed for both local consumption and export. The country's banking and financial centers were also located in northern cities.
Furthermore, the North's economy was drastically changing throughout the nineteenth century. The market revolution and advances in industrial production meant that the North developed a dynamic economy that was significantly expanding. The South, however, continued to base its economy on the older plantation system. Southerners frequently saw the changes in the North as a threat to their older, more established economic system.
Because of the two very different economies and sources of labor, the two regions developed competing interests. The South's economy was built on slave labor, while the North's economy operated and succeeded without it. When the southern states saw that the institution of slavery was under attack, they felt that their entire economy and way of life was endangered.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.