Discussion Topic

Schindler's transformation and evolving values in "Schindler's List."

Summary:

Schindler's transformation in Schindler's List is marked by his shift from a profit-driven businessman to a humanitarian. Initially motivated by wealth, Schindler's values evolve as he witnesses the atrocities against Jews. His growing empathy leads him to risk his life and fortune to save over a thousand Jews, showcasing his profound moral and ethical change.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Schindler's values, opinions, and world view change throughout Schindler's List?

One could say that Schindler's moral journey involves gradually getting in touch with his basic humanity. As the film opens, he's just another wealthy German businessman, a loyal member of the Nazi Party. He's depicted as an incredibly selfish man, hobnobbing with the regime's corrupt functionaries as a means of obtaining lucrative work for his factories. Schindler is presented at the outset as only looking out for number one; the very idea of his risking his neck to save other people is simply unthinkable.

But over the course of the film, he begins to realize not just the full horrors of the Nazi regime, the true nature of its evil, but also the fact that he's lost touch with who he really is. Coming into regular contact with his Jewish workforce, members of a despised and persecuted minority, helps him to understand the fundamental unity of humankind beneath the superficial differences of race, culture, and religion. Through his daily interaction with Jews, Schindler's able to reject the grotesque caricature which the Nazis use to demonize them and justify their persecution and physical annihilation.

At the end of the film, when Schindler laments that he could've done more to save his Jewish workers, he's also expressing a nagging sense that his journey towards a fuller, more complete understanding of his fellow man has not yet run its course.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Schindler's values, opinions, and world view change throughout Schindler's List?

Schindler begins the film as a typical (albeit cunning) businessman seeking to profit from the war. In the opening scenes, he lavishes bribes on Nazi officials, cheats on his wife, and openly consorts with the SS. He obviously enjoys his wealth and newfound status as director.

Schindler initially sees the Jews as a source of cheap labor and nothing more. Partly because of his relationship with Itzhak Stern and partly because of the indiscriminate violence that he witnesses, he begins to change, using his privileged position as a factory owner to save as many Jewish lives as possible. He does this by bribing SS members to redirect Jewish workers from Auschwitz to his own factories, where they will be safe from death. In doing so, he sacrifices his newfound fortune. Ironically, because of his callous and amoral past actions, many of the Nazis with whom he has formed friendships (such as Amon Göth) are unable to see through his deceptions.

Compare the Schindler of the opening scenes, who is primarily preoccupied with making money, to the Schindler of the closing scenes, who is wracked with guilt at not having saved more lives (even though he has saved thousands). Schindler's famous and moving speech at the end of the film ("I could have done more") is a testament to his moral growth.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Schindler's values, opinions, and world view change throughout Schindler's List?

I believe the movie version of Oskar Schindler depicts him as a typical business man at the beginning, a manufacturer who sees the war as an opportunity for money-making. His life did not touch the lives of his workers. As the movie progresses, he is faced with one situation after another in which his morality is challenged, and gradually he understands he is connected with the people who are being systematically wiped out through torture and genocide. Pay particular attention to the one spot of color (the little girl's coat). How does he react? It's a symbol for how his "vision" is improving in terms of his fellow humans. Look for scenes where he is challenged and doesn't bend at first, but later sees a need for change.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Schindler evolve in the movie Schindler's List?

Screenwriter Steven Zaillian’s script for Schindler’s List tracks very deliberately and skillfully the transformation of its protagonist from amoral war profiteer to determined rescuer of the Polish Jews he has used in his factories, and director Steven Spielberg did an admirable job at adapting the underlying text and screenplay for the screen.

The real-life Oskar Schindler was an industrialist who sought to profit from Germany’s formidable war machine and did, in fact, successfully use his position with the occupying German authorities in Poland and Bohemia/Moravia to save over one thousand Jews from extermination camps.

In the film, adapted from author Thomas Keneally’s fictionalized biography of Schindler, the title character is introduced to viewers as a businessman of questionable success and repute going through the motions of adapting himself to appear more successful and important than he actually was. It is clear in the film’s opening sequences that Oskar Schindler is motivated primarily and overwhelmingly by visions of financial riches. Zaillian’s directions suggest just such an individual:

It's September, 1939. General Sigmund List's armored divisions, driving north from the Sudetenland, have taken Cracow, and now, in this club, drinking, socializing, conducting business, is a strange clientele: SS officers and Polish cops, gangsters and girls and entrepreneurs, thrown together by the circumstance of war. Oskar Schindler, drinking alone, slowly scans the room, the faces, stripping away all that's unimportant to him, settling only on details that are: the rank of this man, the higher rank of that one, money being slipped into a hand.

This emphasis in the early scenes in the film on Schindler's financial motivations are provided so that the contrast with the individual who will later become motivated solely by humanitarian concerns can be clearly illuminated. An early conversation with Emilie, his wife, provides one example into Schindler’s initial motivations:

In every business I tried, I can see now, it wasn't me that failed. Something was missing. Even if I'd known what it was, there's nothing I could have done about it because you can't create this thing. And it makes all the difference in the world between success and failure.

As the film progresses, Schindler’s interest in attaining wealth continues to be emphasized as he meticulously cultivates relationships with German officials who, he believes, can assist in attaining his goal. Given the use of Jewish laborers by the Germans, Schindler develops a close working relationship with Itzhak Stern, a bookish accountant who will figure prominently in the businessman’s evolution. In one discussion about business with Stern, Schindler states, “My father was fond of saying you need three things in life - a good doctor, a forgiving priest, and a clever accountant. The first two, I've never had much use for.”

Stern, of course, is a clever accountant. More than that, however, he is a humanitarian who will successfully manipulate his new boss in the direction of righteousness—a task greatly aided by the scale of barbarity practiced by the Germans against their Jewish victims. Schindler’s observations of the moral depravity of those for whom he has worked also contributes to his transformation from simple war profiteer to what the survivors of the Holocaust would call a “Righteous Gentile.”

Nowhere is this demonstrated more clearly than in the film’s final scenes in which Schindler begins to question his efforts at saving Jews from death, a scene sometimes mocked by critics for its mawkishness but that nevertheless exposes the full extent of this individual’s transformation:

Schindler: I could have got more out. I could have got more. I don't know. If I'd just...I could have got more.

Stern: Oskar, there are eleven hundred people who are alive because of you. Look at them.

Schindler: If I'd made more money...I threw away so much money. You have no idea. If I'd just...

Stern: There will be generations because of what you did.

Schindler: I didn't do enough!

Schindler’s List is the story of one individual’s moral transformation—a transformation that enabled the eventual birth of thousands of descendants of those he spared certain death. It was a transformation, the film shows, that came at considerable risk, given the nature of the beast with whom he was trying to manipulate for both financial and humanitarian gain.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Schindler evolve in the movie Schindler's List?

Oskar Schindler experienced a dramatic change of heart during his life, which is chronicled in the film Schindler's List. Schindler is one of the most influential men in the period of the Jewish Holocaust, as he is single-handedly credited with the rescue of thousands of Jews in danger of being sent to concentration camps.

At the beginning of the film, early in the real life story of Schindler, he was a very wealthy man whose sole aim in life was to profit more. He even joined and became a prominent member of the Nazi Party, because of the financial benefit to himself. Because he used cheap Jewish labor to staff his ventures, he soon became close to many Jewish people. As he learned of their eventual fates and grew fond of these people, he soon took steps to prevent their capture. He established a pipeline to get Jews from his factories away from dangerous areas and free from Nazi rule. He even began to use his own financial strength to secure goods and resources from the Black Market to keep the Jews he helped safe and well-fed.

His drastic change of heart helped save the lives of thousands of Jews, and his legacy lives on in the lives of many of those survivors who returned to their ancestral Israel, as is immortalized in the credits of the film.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Schindler evolve in the movie Schindler's List?

Oskar Schindler (1908-1974) was a native of Moravia (now part of the Czech Republic) and the primary focus of the Stephen Spielberg film Schindler's List. During the Nazi Holocaust during World War II, Schindler employed several thousand Jewish forced laborers in his factories, saving the lives of at least 1200 who would have otherwise been subject to extermination by German authorities.

Schindler's life changed dramatically during the war years. Beginning as a member of German intelligence, he was jailed by the Czechs in 1938. After his release, he joined the Nazi Party and profiteered greatly from the German invasion of Poland in 1939. He enjoyed a glamorous lifestyle, hobknobbing with German SS officials at upper echelon military parties. He became very wealthy by utilizing Jewish labor in his factories rather than paying normal wages to civilian workers. His astounding change began in 1943 when he witnessed the brutal murders of Jews during the roundup in the Krakow ghetto. He also saw many of his workers killed during their stay at the Polish concentration camp at Plaszow. He soon became attached to many of his Schindlerjuden ("Schindler's Jews") and found ways to protect as many of them as possible, usually by acquiring them special status "for business essential to the war effort." He soon resorted to gaining special exemptions and falsifying documents in an effort to protect his workers. He was arrested at least three times (once for kissing a Jewish girl), and he risked further punishment by selling Jewish property (marked for the Third Reich) on the black market to aid his workers. In one factory, he refused to allow his workers to make any functional munitions, falsifying records in order to cover his chicanery. He eventually spent his entire fortune bribing officials and purchasing black market items to aid his Schindlerjuden.

It was an amazing turnabout for the once money-hungry Schindler, whose post-war financial operations nearly all resulted in bankruptcy. According to his wish, he was buried in a Catholic cemetery on Mount Zion in Jerusalem--the only Nazi Party member so honored. Schindler rarely ever commented on his motives, but he was once quoted as saying,  

"I knew the people who worked for me... When you know people, you have to behave towards them like human beings."

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What influenced Schindler's transformation in "Schindler's List"?

Enotes writes that the author of "Schindler's List" actually does not make clear what motivated Oskar Schindler to undertake his heroic actions in saving his Jewish factory workers, but he does indicate that the liquidation of the Krakow ghetto was a turning point in the enigmatic character's life.  Schindler was a witness to the liquidation, and saw Jewish men, women, and children indiscriminately murdered in the streets.  After seeing the massacre, Schindler said,

"Beyond this day, no thinking person could fail to see what would happen.  I was now resolved to do everything in my power to defeat the system". 

Schindler, known first and foremost until this time as a pragmatic businessman, risked his life to save the Jewish workers in his employment, and eventually caused his own bankruptcy in setting up a nonproductive factory for the sole purpose of saving the Jews from certain death in Nazi death mills.  Despite the ambiguity surrounding an understanding of his motivations, there is no doubt that, by his actions, Oskar Schindler personally saved the lives of hundreds of Jews.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on