Themes: Retribution

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The wrongness of seeking revenge is central to the story. Chillingworth’s crime, in covertly avenging himself against Dimmesdale, is worse than what the “guilty” couple have done. Of all the charactersChillingworth is the least human and the most symbolic, representing either evil personified or simply an abstraction of the hostile forces mankind must contend with. But he is more immediately a microcosm of the Puritan community as a whole. Their punishment of Hester, in forcing her to wear the scarlet letter, is arguably an emblem of the ultimate sin of intolerance and lack of forgiveness. That all of this is done in the name of religion isn’t surprising to anyone familiar with history, perhaps so much so that Hawthorne does not even need to stress the irony of the most avowedly Christian of all societies carrying out such a condemnation. But the overall message is that vengeance, for any purpose, is at least as immoral as the wrong that is supposedly being avenged.

Expert Q&A

Why does Chillingworth seek revenge on Dimmesdale in The Scarlet Letter?

Chillingworth seeks revenge on Dimmesdale because he believes Dimmesdale has wronged both him and Hester. Although Chillingworth claims he will not harm Dimmesdale or interfere with divine retribution, his words and actions suggest otherwise. Chillingworth feels wronged and wants to make Dimmesdale suffer, even if he does not intend to physically harm him or expose him to the authorities.

According to Hawthorne, by punishing Hester with the scarlet letter, what is the Puritan community doing?

The townspeople are clearly not reasonable, and they show no mercy. They are, however, self-righteous in their "purity."

Why is Chillingworth considered the greatest sinner for violating the human heart?

Chillingworth becomes the worst sinner due to his intent to harm another human being, whereas Dimmesdale's sin was committed in a moment of weakness that he cannot overcome with the strength of his own will.

What is Chillingworth's role in The Scarlet Letter? Is he merely a punisher of Arthur Dimmesdale?

Chillingworth has a role of a victim, punisher, and tool to punish Dimmesdale. Chillingworth feels that he is the "punishment for sin" and that he must correct the wrongs that have been done in his life. He also takes a part of the blame for the sin, spelling things out a bit when he visits Hester in the jail cell. He left to pursue enlightenment outside of the colony and did not contact Hester at all. Also, he refers to their life before he left as not perfect, he was scholarly, she was his maid. This could be the reason why Hawthorne focuses on the Dimmesdale/Chillingworth connection

Chillingworth's relationship with Hester and motivations for vengeance

In The Scarlet Letter, Chillingworth refrains from seeking vengeance against Hester because he believes her public shame and the scarlet letter are sufficient punishment. He acknowledges his own fault in their marriage, recognizing that his age and deformity made him an unsuitable partner for Hester. Instead, Chillingworth's vengeance is directed towards Hester's unnamed lover, whom he believes has wronged them both. His obsession with revenge ultimately transforms him into a malevolent figure, as observed by Hester.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: Free Will

Next

Themes: Hypocrisy

Loading...