Student Question
How does Hawthorne contrast the organic and mechanical in The Scarlet Letter?
Quick answer:
Hawthorne contrasts the organic and mechanical in The Scarlet Letter by showing how nature enhances and softens the harshness of human-made structures. In chapter 7, Governor Bellingham’s decaying mansion is brightened by natural light, while the prison is juxtaposed with a resilient rose bush. The organic world offers Hester and Pearl refuge and acceptance, unlike the mechanical world that ostracizes them.
Hawthorne presents the organic-mechanical contrast in the novel The Scarlet Letter by pairing nature with manmade things to expose how nature assists the human realm and is generally more hospitable.
An example of the organic-mechanical contrast appears in chapter 7 when Hester and Pearl visit Governor Bellingham’s mansion. The mansion, made by humans, is mechanical and, on its own, not very agreeable. It’s “crumbling to decay.” Yet the intrusion of nature gives it a “brilliancy.” Nathaniel Hawthorne describes how the “fragments of broken glass” work with the sunshine to create sparkles. Thus, Hawthorne presents the organic as coming to the aid of the mechanical. Without nature, the human-made world would be sad. Even the harsh mechanical prison is contrasted with a plucky, organic rose bush.
For Hester and Pearl, the mechanical world is thoroughly distressing, since human society stigmatizes and shuns them. The mechanical world contrasts with the organic world since the latter gives Hester and Pearl a welcoming home instead of lopsided opprobrium. “The truth seems to be, however, that the mother-forest, and these wild things which it nourished, all recognized a kindred wildness in the human child,” says the narrator, connecting Hester (the mother), Pearl (the human child), and the organic environment.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.