illustration of a scarlet ibis cradling a boy's body

The Scarlet Ibis

by James Hurst

Start Free Trial

Themes: Conflict between Love and Pride

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

"The Scarlet Ibis" explores the conflict between love and pride within Brother's relationship with his disabled sibling, Doodle. Brother genuinely cares for and appreciates Doodle, as shown in moments when they dream of living in Old Woman Swamp, and Brother is touched by the vivid images Doodle conjures.

Love is characterized by acceptance and compassion. Yet, Brother's affection for Doodle is tainted by two common human shortcomings: pride and the cruelty it can foster. Brother feels embarrassed and ashamed of Doodle's disabilities, which challenge his sense of pride. Driven to make Doodle fit societal expectations, Brother insists he accomplish tasks that Doodle himself doesn't feel the need to complete. Teaching Doodle to walk is Brother's first achievement. When their family praises him, he weeps with shame, realizing his motivations stemmed from pride, "whose slave [he] was." Brother's pride overshadows his love once more as he continues to urge Doodle to engage in more demanding activities, despite Doodle's clearly declining health. Tragically, Doodle's heart succumbs to the strain, a victim of Brother's relentless expectations. Brother later reflects, "I did not know then that pride is a wonderful, terrible thing, a seed that bears two vines, life and death." Here, "life" represents the undeniable progress Doodle makes through Brother's rigorous training, while "death" symbolizes the tragic fate of the fragile boy.

Expert Q&A

In "The Scarlet Ibis," what is meant by "Within me there is a knot of cruelty borne by the stream of love"?

In "The Scarlet Ibis," "Within me there is a knot of cruelty borne by the stream of love" means that Brother's love for Doodle is tainted by his pride and cruelty. Brother's desire to make Doodle "normal" leads him to push Doodle beyond his physical limits, driven by embarrassment and pride rather than pure love, despite his deep affection for Doodle.

What is the meaning of Hurst's sentence about cruelty borne by love in relation to Doodle?

"There is within me (and with sadness I have watched it in others) a knot of cruelty borne by the stream of love, much as our blood sometimes bears the seed of our destruction, and at times I was mean to Doodle."

The sentence reflects Brother's complex feelings of love mixed with cruelty towards Doodle. As an older narrator, Brother looks back on his actions, acknowledging that love can carry elements of cruelty, much like how blood can harbor destruction. This duality is common in sibling relationships, where deep love coexists with teasing or meanness. Brother's reflection is tinged with regret, as he wishes he had not been cruel to Doodle, especially after his sibling's death.

Why does the narrator teach Doodle to walk and why does he cry when congratulated?

The narrator teaches Doodle to walk out of fear of embarrassment when Doodle starts school. He cries when congratulated because his motivation was selfish pride, not brotherly love. The narrator's pride and cruelty are highlighted throughout the story, culminating in Doodle's tragic death. This realization of his flawed motives causes the narrator deep shame and regret.

In "The Scarlet Ibis," what does the narrator allude to by saying, "It was too late, for we had both wandered too far into a net of expectations and had left no crumbs behind"?

The narrator in "The Scarlet Ibis" alludes to the fairy tale "Hansel and Gretel" by saying "It was too late, for we had both wandered too far into a net of expectations and had left no crumbs behind." This means the brothers are trapped in their expectations, much like Hansel and Gretel were lost in the woods without a trail to find their way back, symbolizing their inability to revert to a simpler, accepting relationship.

Is the narrator, Brother, responsible for Doodle's death, considering he left him tired and neglected?

Brother is partially responsible for Doodle's death due to his actions. He pressured Doodle to row against the tide and run, knowing Doodle was weak and tired, motivated by his own embarrassment. Although Doodle's death was ultimately due to a heart condition, Brother's impatience and the physical strain he imposed likely contributed to the fatal heart attack. Brother may not be directly guilty, but his actions played a significant role in the events leading to Doodle's death.

In "The Scarlet Ibis," how does pride serve as both a positive and negative element?

In "The Scarlet Ibis," pride is a dual force. It negatively influences Brother to feel ashamed of Doodle's disabilities, initially motivating him to consider harming Doodle. However, pride also drives Brother to teach Doodle to walk, leading to shared achievements and growth. Positive pride inspires them to work hard and accomplish goals, yet selfish pride ultimately leads to Doodle's tragic death, illustrating its destructive potential when misguided.

What does "The Scarlet Ibis" suggest about the relationship between love and cruelty?

In James Hurst's story "The Scarlet Ibis," the narrator may be saying that his love for his brother, Doodle, was limited at best, and that his cruelty often overwhelmed the love he may have had for Doodle. He was motivated to help his brother mostly out of embarrassment and pride.

How does the ibis' symbolism support the theme of harmful selfish pride?

The ibis symbolizes harmful selfish pride by paralleling Brother's treatment of Doodle. Brother's pride drives him to push Doodle beyond his limits, just as the fragile ibis cannot survive in an unsuitable environment. Although Brother's desire to make Doodle "normal" stems from pride, it ultimately leads to Doodle's death. The ibis, like Doodle, is delicate and unable to endure, underscoring how Brother's pride causes more harm than good.

How does Brother's relationship with Doodle illustrate the complexity and paradox of love?

Brother's relationship with Doodle illustrates the complexity and paradox of love through his conflicting emotions. Brother loves Doodle but is embarrassed by his disabilities, driving him to push Doodle to overcome them for selfish reasons. This paradox is evident when Brother feels guilty for teaching Doodle to walk out of pride, not love. Ultimately, Brother's grief at Doodle's death highlights how he took his brother for granted, emphasizing love's contradictory nature.

What does James Hurst imply by having the scarlet ibis die in front of Doodle?

The scarlet ibis is the symbol of the child. Its journey to the family in a storm symbolizes his journey from life to death. The tree in which it died foreshadows Doodle’s death under that same tree.
Show another question (8 questions hidden)

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: All Themes

Next

Themes: The Desire to Make Over Others in One's Own Image

Loading...