Saint Maybe delves into the complexities of family dynamics, much like other novels by Tyler. It also transitions from illness to wellness, confinement to liberation, and disarray to unity, similar to her other works.

In this novel, Tyler takes a fresh approach by addressing themes of sin and redemption through a religious lens for the first time, and she portrays a religious character with empathy. Although characters in her other books may engage in acts considered sinful, such as child abuse, they rarely express remorse or seek forgiveness. Often, the narrative centers on how the victims must navigate life despite their circumstances and avoid adopting a victim mentality. However, in this story, the spotlight is on the individual whose careless words cause chaos. This character must not only build a life for himself but also atone for his mistakes. Given that the themes of sin and redemption are new territory for Tyler, they offer rich material for analysis. One can explore how Tyler addresses these themes, the importance of the religious context, and how this novel's perspective aligns with or differs from her other works.

1. How is forgiveness defined in this novel? Does Ian attain it?

2. How does recalling past events impact the story? For instance, when Ian is about to bring Joshua downstairs, he recalls Danny introducing Daphne to the family.

3. Aside from raising the children as a form of reparation, in what other ways does Ian's sin influence his life choices?

4. How does this novel celebrate the lasting nature of family bonds?

5. What family conflicts are acknowledged in the novel?

6. Analyze the female characters in this novel.

7. In what ways is this novel a coming-of-age story for Ian?

8. How might this novel exemplify the idea that one must lose their life to truly save it?

9. What role do the dreams described in the novel play?