Saint Maybe

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Anne Tyler's novel, St. Maybe, portrays the transformation of the seemingly ideal Bedloe family into an ordinary one grappling with extraordinary troubles. The narrative intricately explores themes of familial responsibility, guilt, and redemption, set in the backdrop of Tyler's familiar Baltimore. Ian Bedloe, the youngest son, emerges as the novel’s central figure, embarking on a transformative journey that highlights the novel’s intricate exploration of the costs and rewards of taking responsibility for others.

The Bedloe Family: An Ideal Turned Ordinary

The novel opens with the Bedloe family, initially depicted as quintessentially "apple-pie," complete with amiable parents Doug and Bee, three good-looking children, and an assortment of pets. The narrative spans the life of Ian Bedloe from age seventeen to forty-two, during which the family is dramatically altered by tragedy. The pivotal event is the sudden death of Ian's elder brother Danny and Danny's wife, Lucy, which leaves their three children orphaned and under the care of the remaining Bedloes.

A Tragic Beginning

The story begins with Danny Bedloe's impulsive marriage to Lucy Dean, who brings two children from a previous marriage into the family. Barely seven months into their union, Lucy delivers a third child. Tragedy strikes when Danny dies in a car accident and Lucy passes away from a potential overdose, leaving their children Agatha, Thomas, and the infant Daphne without parents. Ian, overwhelmed with guilt and believing himself responsible for his brother's death, abandons his college education to help raise the children.

Ian's Guilt and Redemption

Ian's decision to care for his brother's children is driven by a complex mix of guilt and a yearning for redemption. His sense of culpability stems from telling Danny about unfounded suspicions of Lucy's infidelity, which Ian believes led to Danny's fatal crash. Seeking forgiveness, Ian is drawn to the Church of the Second Chance, where he learns forgiveness must be earned through acts of penance. Taking responsibility for the children becomes Ian’s personal atonement.

The Church of the Second Chance

The Church of the Second Chance plays a significant role in Ian’s life, offering a path to redemption and a new purpose. Here, he adopts a lifestyle of discipline and restraint, abstaining from indulgences and faithfully participating in church activities. Though his parents disapprove of his new devotion and his girlfriend distances herself, Ian remains steadfast, believing this path will lead to the forgiveness he craves.

Parenthood as Religious Discipline

In Tyler’s narrative, parenthood and religion are parallel disciplines characterized by daily endurance rather than ecstatic revelations. Ian's commitment to the Church of the Second Chance mirrors his dedication to the children, reflecting Tyler's theme of ordinary devotion over extraordinary experiences. This perspective transforms Ian's role as a surrogate parent into a vocation, an act of ongoing penance and genuine care for the children.

Portraying Vulnerable Children

Tyler’s portrayal of the Bedloe children, particularly Agatha, is vivid and unsentimental, highlighting their vulnerability. Agatha, just seven years old, becomes a surrogate caregiver for her siblings in the wake of their mother's despair and negligence. Tyler's keen observations of children's behaviors reveal their need for structure and security amidst the chaos and tragedy of their circumstances.

Ian’s Impact and the Influence of the Church

Ian’s role in the children’s lives becomes a central focus, with particular attention to the impact of his religious discipline on Daphne. His niece is notably affected by the Church’s sense of care, and as an adult, she remains closely connected to Ian. This bond signifies the lasting influence of Ian's commitment and the church’s teachings on their family dynamic.

A Rich Tapestry of Characters

While Ian is...

(This entire section contains 905 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

the novel’s focal point, Tyler populatesSt. Maybe with a cast of compelling characters, including his resilient mother Bee and the spirited Daphne. Bee, despite her arthritis, is an optimistic presence, reinterpreting family difficulties with a humorous slant. Her death leaves a void in the family, illustrating her pivotal role. Daphne, born on Ian's birthday, shares an intense bond with him, reflecting the novel’s exploration of familial love and dependency.

The Complexity of Family Life

Anne Tyler’s distinctive vision of family life unravels through the mysterious events and relationships within the Bedloe family. Themes like Danny's suicide, Lucy’s overdose, and Daphne’s parentage underscore the inherent ambiguity and complexity in family dynamics. Tyler reveals that despite best efforts, parents can inadvertently fail their children, and children’s dependency can be both an emotional burden and a source of profound joy.

Enduring Domesticity

Tyler’s narrative celebrates the resilience found in everyday life—the mundane routines that shape family bonds. Through activities like meal preparation, laundry, and school pick-ups, Tyler paints a picture of domestic life where responsibility for others, though challenging, is deeply rewarding. In St. Maybe, readers are invited to marvel at the unpredictable nature of familial intimacy and the profound impact of seemingly chance encounters on our lives.

Bibliography

  • Carson, Barbara Harrell. “Complicate, Complicate: Anne Tyler’s Moral Imperative,” Southern Quarterly 31, no. 1 (Fall, 1992): 24-35.
  • Gullette, Margaret M. Safe at Last in the Middle Years:The Invention of the Midlife Progress Novel. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1988.
  • Petry, Alice Hall, ed. Critical Essays on Anne Tyler. New York: G. K. Hall, 1992.
  • Stephens, C. Ralph, ed. The Fiction of Anne Tyler. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi, 1990.
  • Voelker, Joseph C. Art and the Accidental in Anne Tyler. Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 1989.

Style and Technique

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Narrative Perspective

The novel employs a third-person narrative that primarily delves into the psyche of Ian, yet this perspective is not solely his to command. The narrator skillfully redirects the lens to other characters, illustrating the story’s broader scope. For instance, following Danny’s tragic demise, the narrative shifts to Agatha, a young girl grappling with her mother’s decline, thereby capturing the tumultuous transformation of her life. This shift in perspective not only highlights Agatha's inner turmoil but also enriches the narrative by providing a fresh viewpoint. Such transitions ensure that while Ian remains central, the lives and thoughts of other characters are vividly depicted.

Character Development Through Shifts

These perspective shifts are crucial in illustrating character growth and evolving relationships. When the narrative turns to Daphne’s thoughts, it captures the palpable distance that has grown between her and Ian. This separation underscores Ian's need for a renewed purpose, ultimately steering him towards a significant relationship with Rita. By occasionally moving away from Ian’s perspective, the narrative allows readers to witness the multifaceted nature of familial dynamics and personal growth. Each character's journey becomes a pivotal strand in the tapestry of the story.

Thematic Depth

The author’s choice to alternate perspectives serves more than just character development; it enriches the thematic depth of the novel. By allowing readers to inhabit the minds of Agatha, Daphne, and others, the novel explores themes of loss, resilience, and the search for belonging. These themes resonate through the characters' experiences, inviting readers to ponder the complexities of familial bonds and personal redemption. The shifts in focus not only advance the plot but also invite a deeper understanding of the themes woven into the narrative fabric.

Building Anticipation and Emotional Resonance

Shifting perspectives also play a significant role in building anticipation and increasing emotional resonance. By exploring diverse points of view, the novel crafts a rich emotional landscape that engages readers on multiple levels. The transition to Ian's evolving relationship with Rita, for example, is subtly prepared by the earlier shifts in perspective, creating a sense of anticipation and emotional investment in Ian's personal journey. This technique ensures that readers remain deeply connected to the characters’ experiences and the unfolding drama.

Conclusion

In essence, the novel’s skillful manipulation of perspective not only enriches the storyline but also enhances the emotional and thematic layers of the narrative. By deftly moving between characters’ thoughts and experiences, the author crafts a compelling tale that resonates with readers, offering a profound exploration of human experience and the intricacies of personal growth and relationships.

Historical Context

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Anne Tyler’s Saint Maybe offers a nuanced exploration of family dynamics and spiritual introspection against a backdrop of societal challenges, such as suicide, drug abuse, and single parenthood. The novel centers on Ian Bedloe, whose life is profoundly affected by the tragic choices of his brother, Danny. Consumed by suspicion of his wife's infidelity and doubts about the paternity of their child, Danny tragically ends his life. This act of desperation leaves his wife, Lucy, overwhelmed by the demands of raising their three children alone. Lacking both job skills and stable income, Lucy eventually succumbs to an accidental overdose, orphaning her children.

In the aftermath of this tragedy, Ian takes on the unexpected role of caregiver to his niece and nephews: Agatha, Thomas, and Daphne. Despite some support from his parents, Ian shoulders the majority of the responsibility, navigating the relentless challenges of single parenthood. His journey is not just about providing for these children but also learning to nurture and love them through all stages of their lives. Particularly challenging are the teenage years of Daphne, whose rebellious nature requires Ian to adapt his life to ensure her safety and well-being.

Tyler’s narrative in Saint Maybe is emblematic of her broader literary exploration of family obligations versus personal desires—a theme she revisits across her novels. Ian's story reflects a central question Tyler poses: What is one’s obligation to family, and what is one’s obligation to oneself? This tension between domesticity and personal freedom is a recurring motif in Tyler's work, paralleled by characters such as Elizabeth Abbott in The Clock Winder and Sarah Leary in The Accidental Tourist, who navigate familial duties and personal independence.

In Ian, Tyler examines the struggle between the allure of personal freedom and the demands of domestic responsibility. At forty-one, Ian seeks independence by marrying the youthful and bold Rita, yet finds himself once again entwined in family life. Through Ian’s experiences, Tyler explores broader themes: the complexities of family life, the necessity of balancing androgynous traits, the impact of unforeseen events, and the tension between isolation and community.

Tyler's ability to craft vivid characters and their intricate predicaments with compassion and realism places her firmly within the female literary tradition. Saint Maybe not only delves into Ian's spiritual journey but also offers a poignant reflection on the intersection of personal redemption and societal challenges. The narrative underscores how the path to redemption is often interwoven with social realities that demand resilience and empathy. In doing so, Tyler creates an enduring tale that resonates with the complexities of modern family life and personal transformation.

Previous

Critical Essays

Next

Teaching Guide

Loading...