A. S. Byatt Criticism
Criticism surrounding the works of A. S. Byatt, an influential figure in contemporary English literature, reflects the intricate and multifaceted nature of her novels. Her debut novel, Shadow of a Sun, is frequently praised for its profound portrayal of emotional complexity and nuanced character development, as explored in the article Living with a Genius. This work serves as an exemplar of Byatt's recurring examination of the themes of genius and emotional intricacy, which permeates much of her oeuvre.
While Shadow of a Sun garners acclaim for its detailed character portrayal, some critics, such as those contributing to Reader's Report, point to a tendency towards verbosity, occasionally overshadowing the dynamism of character interactions. This critique highlights Byatt's stylistic choice of in-depth exposition, which, while enriching the text's intellectual depth, may challenge readers seeking more action-driven narratives.
Byatt's broader body of work continues to engage with these themes, inviting readers to ponder the intersections of intellectualism and emotionality, a hallmark of her writing style. Her novels invite readers into a world where the psychological and the intellectual are intricately interwoven, showcasing her profound empathy for her characters and her commitment to exploring the depths of human experience.
Contents
- Principal Works
-
Byatt, A. S.
-
The Mantle of Jehovah
(summary)
In the following review, Spufford praises A. S. Byatt's writing for its potent portrayal of intense emotions and the theme of loss, while highlighting the author's ability to juxtapose the fragility of human experience with cultural elements in her novels and stories.
-
The Hunger of the Imagination in A. S. Byatt's The Game
(summary)
In the following essay, Campbell traces Byatt's use of the imagination as both the subject and the form of her novel The Game.
-
‘The Somehow May Be Thishow’: Fact, Fiction, and Intertextuality in Antonia Byatt's ‘Precipice-Encurled’
(summary)
In the following essay, Campbell discusses Byatt's mixing of fact and fiction in the short story “Precipice-Encurled,” and asserts that the story demonstrates the impossibility of capturing reality in art.
-
Affinities and Affections
(summary)
In the following review, Doris Grumbach argues that A. S. Byatt's collection Passions of the Mind offers little commendable content, critiquing Byatt's essays on literary figures for their lack of insight and coherence, and highlighting the collection’s tendency toward fragmented and unresolved analysis.
-
Passions of the Mind
(summary)
In the following review, Merle Rubin critiques A. S. Byatt's Passions of the Mind, asserting that while Byatt is an insightful guide to writers she admires, her literary criticism lacks the brilliance of renowned critics like Simone de Beauvoir or Mary McCarthy, and she occasionally gets mired in theoretical controversies.
-
When Will He Suspect?
(summary)
In the following essay, John Barrell argues that while A. S. Byatt's "Angels and Insects" admirably captures Victorian style and themes, the effort is ultimately futile as it highlights the disconnect between Victorian ideas and contemporary relevance, with the novellas' intricate construction leaving little room for reader discovery beyond the intended narrative.
-
Metamorphoses
(summary)
In the following review, Tess Lewis lauds Byatt's Angels and Insects as a spiritual heir to the Victorian era, highlighting how Byatt vividly brings to life the era's intellectual and spiritual tensions through her intricate and evocative storytelling.
-
Aesthetic among the Pinks
(summary)
In the following review, Dyer critiques A. S. Byatt's The Matisse Stories, arguing that the stories, while superficially pleasant, suffer from a parochial authorial viewpoint and lack the vividness and depth necessary to truly capture the essence of Matisse's art, resulting in a prose that is simultaneously exquisite and bland.
-
A. S. Byatt's Self-Mirroring Art
(summary)
In the following essay, Julian Gitzen examines A. S. Byatt's integration of literary and artistic theory in her fiction, particularly in "Possession," highlighting her self-reflexive narrative style, exploration of the relationship between art and reality, and her portrayal of characters whose lives mirror or reenact works of art.
-
Obeying the Genie
(summary)
In the following review, Alev Adil explores A. S. Byatt's collection The Djinn in the Nightingale's Eye, highlighting its rich, baroque language and modern critique of narrative determinism, while arguing that the stories, though intellectually stimulating, deviate from traditional fairy-tale sensuality to examine the constraints and potential for choice within women's narratives.
-
A Novelist with a Civilized, Artistic Eye
(summary)
In the following review, Rubin offers a positive assessment of Byatt's The Matisse Stories, highlighting the book’s artistic sophistication and thematic connections to Matisse's paintings, and praising Byatt's nuanced depiction of the intersection between art, life, and personal identity in the three novellas.
-
Her Shaping Spirit of Imagination
(summary)
In the following review, Hensher praises Byatt's Babel Tower for its exceptional gravity and charm, highlighting its exploration of 1960s social and sexual freedoms through the lens of Blake's and Sade's philosophies, and commending the novel's intricate thematic interweaving, vivid characterizations, and the technical skill displayed in its narrative structure.
-
Tongues of Fire
(summary)
In the following essay, Tharoor argues that A. S. Byatt's Babel Tower presents a rich and intellectually stimulating narrative that suffers from an excess of characters and plotlines, leading to a sense of dissatisfaction despite the novel's literary sophistication and insightful exploration of literature and language.
-
‘What's Love Got to Do with It?’ Postmodernism and Possession
(summary)
In the following essay, Buxton analyzes Byatt's Possession in terms of its relationship to postmodernism.
-
En Route to the Catastrophe
(summary)
In the following essay, Coetzee examines Byatt's "Babel Tower," exploring themes of marital cruelty, the cultural shifts of the 1960s, and the protagonist Frederica's journey towards intellectual and personal independence, intertwined with Byatt's critique of literary and philosophical traditions, notably the influence of Lawrence and poststructuralist criticism.
-
Gail Pool （review date July 1996）
(summary)
In the following review, Gail Pool questions the excessive length of Byatt's Babel Tower, yet praises it as an intelligent, often humorous novel that effectively explores the education and experiences of contemporary women through its complex narrative and thematic exploration of freedom and language.
-
The Redemptive Past in the Neo-Victorian Novel
(summary)
In the following essay, Shiller uses Fredric Jameson's critique of postmodernism to analyze the relationship between Byatt's Possession, Peter Akroyd's Chatterton, and the historical novel, in particular the neo-Victorian novel.
-
Thinking of England
(summary)
In the following review, Miller examines A. S. Byatt’s anthology, The Oxford Book of English Short Stories, highlighting her stringent criteria for "Englishness" and noting the collection's rich array of themes, including humor, fantasy, and pragmatism, while emphasizing its personal, rather than representative, nature.
-
Tricks of the Light
(summary)
In the following review, Grant praises the stories in Byatt's Elementals, highlighting their seamless blend of reality and fantasy, the vividness of their descriptive detail, and the author's ability to craft compelling narratives within a concise format, thus enhancing their memorability and impact.
-
The Mantle of Jehovah
(summary)
-
Byatt, A(ntonia) S(usan)
-
Living with a Genius
(summary)
In the following essay, the critic evaluates A. S. Byatt's debut novel, Shadow of a Sun, noting her adept portrayal of complex emotional landscapes and critique of her detailed yet sometimes protracted narrative style, while acknowledging her deep empathy for her characters and the novel's exploration of genius.
-
Reader's Report
(summary)
In the following essay, Martin Levin critiques A. S. Byatt's Shadow of a Sun for its verbose character descriptions and lack of dynamic character interactions, ultimately arguing that the novel relies too heavily on exposition over genuine character development.
-
Child's Play
(summary)
In the following essay, the critic examines A. S. Byatt's novel The Game, arguing that while it is intellectually crafted and offers insightful commentary, its characters lack the depth to support the heavy philosophical themes, resulting in a work that appears artificial and constrained by its own intricate design.
-
Reader's Report
(summary)
In the following essay, Martin Levin argues that A. S. Byatt's novel "The Game" is notable for its subtle blend of character traits and beliefs with dynamic action, successfully integrating philosophical depth with emotional engagement to create a cumulatively exciting narrative.
-
On from Murdoch
(summary)
In the following essay, Malcolm Bradbury analyzes A. S. Byatt's novel "The Game," highlighting its exploration of romantic sensibility through the interplay between reality and imagination, and the complex character dynamics that exemplify Byatt's nuanced portrayal of emotional and creative struggles.
-
Force Fields
(summary)
In the following essay, Iris Murdoch praises A. S. Byatt's The Virgin in the Garden for its intellectual depth, detailed character development, and the effective integration of literary and visual arts, while acknowledging minor criticisms regarding literary allusions and character clarity as insignificant compared to the novel's overall achievements.
-
Growing Up in 1953
(summary)
In the following essay, Michael Irwin critiques A. S. Byatt's novel The Virgin in the Garden for its intellectual overcommitment and narrative execution, arguing that the novel's characters and themes are heavily driven by academic ideas rather than organic storytelling, resulting in a bookish and sometimes tedious prose style.
-
Lee Langley: Ambition and the Novelist
(summary)
In the following essay, Paul Levy argues that A. S. Byatt's The Virgin in the Garden exemplifies ambitious literary realism in the European tradition, showcasing intricate character development and thematic integration, though he notes some narrative uncertainty regarding the character Frederica's conclusion.
-
England in the 50's
(summary)
In the following essay, Rosemary Dinnage critiques A. S. Byatt's "The Virgin in the Garden" for its intellectual and traditional storytelling, noting its richly drawn characters and overuse of Elizabethan literary references that detract from its narrative appeal.
-
Writers & Writing: The Art of Living
(summary)
In the following essay, Daphne Merkin argues that A. S. Byatt's novel The Virgin in the Garden is a meticulously crafted work deeply rooted in the English literary tradition, characterized by its intellectual depth and cultural references, yet occasionally criticized for its overly academic tone and lack of spontaneity.
-
The Illusion of Allusions
(summary)
In the following essay, Louise Bernikow examines A. S. Byatt's novel The Virgin in the Garden, highlighting its exploration of themes such as female strength, virginity, and nostalgia for the 1950s, while also critiquing its intellectual complexity and the ironic juxtaposition of past and present societal values.
-
Living with a Genius
(summary)
- Further Reading