Discussion Topic

The surprising resolution and final revelation in "A Rose for Emily"

Summary:

The surprising resolution and final revelation in "A Rose for Emily" is that Emily Grierson has kept the corpse of her deceased lover, Homer Barron, in her house for many years. This macabre discovery is made after her death, revealing her inability to let go and her extreme measures to avoid loneliness.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In "A Rose For Emily," was the ending surprising or were you expecting it? Why?

I have read this story several times over the years, and of course I am no longer surprised by the ending. However, I believe I was surprised and that every reader must be surprised by Faulkner's skillful plotting. He makes it quite clear to the reader that Emily Grierson intends...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

to murderHomer Barron by creating a scene in which she goes into a drugstore to buy arsenic. The perceptive reader naturally suspects that she intends to use it on her lover, but a really perceptive reader might suspect that Faulkner has a hidden purpose for planting such a conspicuous clue.

The druggist sells Emily arsenic while her two female cousins from Alabama are visiting her. Emily just stares at him when he tells her that the law requires her to tell him why she is buying it. He backs down without an answer and writes ‘‘for rats’’ on the box. (eNotes Study Guide)

Then the anonymous narrator describes a strange smell coming from the house. It is so offensive that people complain to the authorities, but nothing is done and eventually the smell goes away. Here again the perceptive reader assumes the smell was caused by a decaying corpse, which it was.

But what the reader is not prepared for, because Faulkner has been planting misleading clues, is the discovery that this dignified, aristocratic old lady has been sleeping with the rotting corpse of Homer Barron ever sincce she murdered him years earlier. That is the real surprise ending. It is created mainly by the discovery of one of Emily Grierson's gray hairs on the other pillow. The reader realizes that she was completely insane and can imagine her sleeping beside the corpse and finally beside the skeleton every night.

And on the bed was “the man himself,” with a “profound and fleshless grin.” Although never mentioned by name, the fleshless skeleton, in the position of an endless embrace, is that of Homer Barron. Next to his head is a second pillow, with the “indentation of another head,” and on it is a “long strand of iron-gray hair.” (eNotes Study Guide)

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is the conflict resolved at the end of "A Rose for Emily"?

The conflict that contributes to the tension in William Faulkner's story "A Rose for Emily" is the enigma surrounding the life of Miss Emily as an eccentric and antiquated character within a place which is changing towards the future.

This enigma permeates the story, and colors the character of Emily in a diversity of shades: scary, strange, mysterious, sad, melancholic, lonely, haughty, and stubborn. Although nobody really knows Emily personally, the townsfolk narrator offers all of these descriptors as the observations that the people from Jefferson have bestowed upon Emily based merely on either hearsay, or on the rare instances when they are able to take a glimpse of this interesting woman.

Along the narrative we realize that Emily's life has not lacked obstacles: her father dominated her, and his death crippled her mentally. She is also limited by the fact that she once belonged to a good, aristocratic background only to have fallen from grace with the passing of time. Moreover, Emily is unable to change. If anything, the biggest obstacle that Emily has in life, is herself.

However, happy tidings did go her way with the entrance of Homer Barron into her life. As the narrator says, the people actually felt shocked but happy to know that Miss Emily has found a companion. A man whom nobody liked, Homer was still seen as company for an otherwise lonely woman.

Yet, the enigma of Emily comes to a boiling point when a strange smell begins to emanate from her home. After the town's aldermen just went and took care of it, it is said that Emily rarely ever left her home again. In the end, the narrator explains, Emily's death resulted in the first time that the people could actually enter her home. There, they saw that in one of the bedrooms the corpse of Homer Barron had been laying dead for years and that Emily had been sharing the bed with such a corpse. Hence, it is this discovery that ends the enigma that constitutes the conflict and point of tension of the story.

Last Updated on