A Rose for Emily Questions on Miss Emily

A Rose for Emily

The narrator in "A Rose for Emily" portrays a complex relationship with Emily, blending respect, curiosity, and pity. They represent the collective voice of the townspeople, offering a mix of...

17 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

In William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily," the primary conflict is between Miss Emily Grierson and society, reflecting her struggle to maintain her aristocratic status in a changing world. Her...

25 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

In "A Rose for Emily," Miss Emily refuses to pay taxes or get house numbers due to her desire to control her environment and resist change following her father's death. Her tax exemption was a...

4 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The mental illness that Miss Emily has could be schizophrenia. Readers must infer a diagnoses based on careful character analysis, as Miss Emily's mental illness is not explicitly identified in the...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

In William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily," the pervasive smell emanating from Emily Grierson's home serves as a critical narrative element, foreshadowing the revelation of Homer Barron's decomposing...

10 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The necrophilia in "A Rose for Emily" symbolizes Miss Emily's extreme resistance to change and her desperate attempt to exert control over her life. It reflects her inability to let go of loved ones...

3 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

After Miss Emily's death, the townspeople discover the decayed corpse of Homer Barron in a locked room in her house. This revelation confirms that Emily poisoned Homer with arsenic, likely due to his...

3 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The minister's wife contacts Miss Emily's relatives due to Emily's behavior, which the townspeople find scandalous and improper. Emily is seen publicly with Homer Barron, a Northerner, without a...

10 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The iron-gray hair on the second pillow reveals that Miss Emily has been sleeping beside Homer Barron's corpse for years, highlighting her dependency and desire to keep him forever. This detail...

7 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily needed arsenic to kill Homer Barron, whom she viewed as a threat to her reputation. Although she did not explicitly tell the druggist her reason, she was able to purchase the poison under...

3 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily, Blanche, and Maggie all represent women struggling against societal expectations and personal traumas. Miss Emily isolates herself and clings to the past, Blanche lives in a world of...

3 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The metaphor used to describe Miss Emily in the first paragraph of "A Rose for Emily" is "a fallen monument." This metaphor suggests she was once a revered figure representing the old South but had...

3 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

In "A Rose for Emily," "a sort of hereditary obligation upon the town" means that the town was responsible for covering Miss Emily's taxes. This arrangement was initiated by Colonel Sartoris, who...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily" employs a Southern Gothic style, using a third-person narrative to explore themes of isolation, death, and the decay of old Southern traditions. The story's...

8 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

In "A Rose for Emily," Miss Emily blurs reality and illusion by refusing to pay taxes, believing a fabricated story about her family's exemption. She also denies her father's death, keeping his body...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

The narrator means that Miss Emily was regarded as a cherished yet burdensome figure in the town due to her family's past prominence. Her family had a socially prominent position, and her father's...

3 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily gains weight and develops gray hair due to aging and depression, exacerbated by her isolation and loneliness. Her physical changes reflect her psychological state, as she is described in...

2 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Sympathy for Miss Emily in "A Rose for Emily" arises from her tragic life, marked by isolation and the controlling influence of her father. Her inability to adapt to change, coupled with societal...

4 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

In William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily," figurative language and Emily Grierson's changing appearance illustrate her transformation. Metaphors like "a fallen monument" and "a tradition, a duty, and...

3 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily intended the upstairs room in her mansion as a bridal suite for herself and Homer Barron. The room, furnished with rose-colored curtains, silver toiletry items, and a nightshirt, suggests...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily's father's portrait is on a gilt easel by the fireplace and is made from crayon. This detail is revealed when a group of aldermen visits her home to discuss her unpaid taxes. The home,...

2 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The "shadow" in "A Rose for Emily" symbolizes various aspects of Miss Emily's life, including death, decay, and secrets. It refers to the darkness surrounding her home and life, representing her...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily stops teaching china painting because the newer generation in the town does not feel obligated to send their daughters to her for lessons. Initially, the town's older generation supported...

2 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily's refusal to acknowledge her father's death foreshadows her later actions with Homer Baron. Her inability to let go of her father's body and denial of his death suggest her struggle with...

4 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

-Miss Emily is from a wealthy family. The rest of the people in town are poor or perhaps middle-class. Her family represents the aristocracy. All of Miss Emily's actions are reported through the...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily is seen as scandalous due to several actions: she refuses to bury her father's body, causing shock; her association with Homer Barron, a Northerner, and of lower social class, defies...

2 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The corpse found on Miss Emily's bed can only be that of Homer Baron, the northerner who comes to the town to oversee the building of some sidewalks and who courts her.

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

In "A Rose for Emily," the narrator and the town view Miss Emily as a reclusive and mysterious figure. Her eccentric behavior and isolation provoke curiosity and gossip among the townspeople, who see...

2 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Emily's tragedy in "A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner is rooted in her father's oppressive control, which left her isolated and unable to form lasting relationships. This background, combined...

4 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The phrase "a pallid hue" in the description of Miss Emily refers to her extremely pale, lifeless appearance, resembling a dead body submerged in water. In Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily," this imagery...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily is a story about the human heart in conflict with itself. The story is also about the conflict between the old and new South and how different eras of history can co-exist in one area.

4 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

In "A Rose for Emily," the plot structure and point of view are intricately connected. The non-linear timeline and the first-person plural perspective of the townspeople create a sense of mystery and...

4 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily did not know that Colonel Sartoris had been dead for ten years when she faced the Aldermen. Her detachment from the town and her refusal to acknowledge changes, like the New South, kept...

2 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The narrator's attitude toward Emily is generally respectful and sympathetic. He is somewhat detached and objective, but he does not condemn her.

4 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily stayed in her house for approximately 72 years. After her father's death, she lived in the house for about 42 years, during which time she rarely left. The narrative hints that she was...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

To prove Miss Emily didn't murder Homer, one must raise reasonable doubt rather than prove innocence, as the burden of proof lies with the prosecution. Doubts can be raised by questioning the...

4 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Adopting this stance, you would try to find evidence that Emily is a symbol of the post-Civil War South, and then you would explain how she can be considered a symbol in this way.

2 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily responds to the demand she pay taxes by saying she doesn't have to. She initially reacts to her father's death without grief. The narrator explains this as due to denial that he died....

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

The minister's visit to Emily's house in "A Rose for Emily" creates ambiguity because Faulkner does not reveal what occurs during the visit, only that the minister refuses to return. This suggests...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily is a very mysterious character in the story. She seems to be a kind and good lady but she has committed a horrible crime. The townspeople are not sure what to make of her and they really...

2 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily's actions that led townspeople to believe she was married included her public relationship with Homer Barron and her purchase of men's items, such as a monogrammed silver toilet set and a...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

Miss Emily's attitudes towards the three men in her life—her father, Colonel Sartoris, and Homer Barron—reflect her struggles with attachment and reality. She is strongly attached to her domineering...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

The three men in Emily's life are Homer Barron, the father, and Tobe. Her father was a symbol of her inability to let go from the past. He was always holding on to what he knew, to what he had. He...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

The Board of Alderman's complaint against Miss Emily in "A Rose for Emily" was about a foul odor emanating from her house. This issue arose two years after her father's death and shortly after her...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

While William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily" never explicitly states that Miss Emily killed Homer Barron, several clues suggest she did. Miss Emily purchases arsenic without providing a reason, and...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

The townspeople learn about Miss Emily's life through gossip, observations, and indirect interactions. They speculate based on what they see from the outside of her house, her rare appearances, and...

1 educator answer

A Rose for Emily

The larger issue represented in "A Rose for Emily" is the resistance to change. The story illustrates how the town of Jefferson and its inhabitants struggle with modernization and cling to old...

2 educator answers

A Rose for Emily

The mood of the protagonist in "A Rose for Emily" is complex and varies depending on perspective. If Miss Emily is seen as the protagonist, her mood is mysterious, proud, and bizarre. If the...

3 educator answers