Where are Civil War references in "A Rose for Emily" and what role does the war play?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Just a quick note:  "A Rose for Emily" is obviously fiction.  When it was published has nothing to do with when Emily was born.  You can't equate the story's publication date with Emily's death.  And how long Faulkner was working on the story is irrelevant.  I can write a story about someone born in 1508, or 1203, or 2098.  The date I publish the story has nothing to do with my character's age.  There is no reason to assume that Faulkner wrote the story immediately after Emily dies, unless there is some external evidence that I don't know about.  You can figure out her chronology from the story if you want, but you can't figure it out by assuming the publication date has any chronological relation whatsoever with Emily's death. 

The Civil War mentions are important to the story because Faulkner is writing about the reconstruction stage of the American South following the war.  Notice that everyone is poor.  The war devastated the South.  It not only destroyed the South's economy, but most of the battles, etc., took place in the South.  The region was ravished by the war. 

Posted on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Actually, Miss Emily Grierson was probably born either before or during the American Civil War. ("A Rose for Emily" was first published in 1930, and Faulkner had apparently been working on it for several years. Since Miss Emily was around 70 years old, this would put her fictional birth between 1850-1860.) She would have been one of the last survivors of this epic conflict, so both she and the war serve as a reminder to the glory days of the South. Well into the 20th century, the War Between the States served as a dividing line between various social and ethnic beliefs. The beaten Southern states took many decades to recover from the economic and political restraints they were forced to endure during Reconstruction. Once they had earned an equal place in national politics, many Southern leaders--a number of whom were important members of the Confederate military and state governments--sought to build a New South that reflected an image of the CSA in its heyday. By the turn of the century, however, with most of these men dead or dying, the South was changing once again; the old ante-bellum ways were being disregarded for a more modern approach. Miss Emily remained a symbol of the old ways; the younger citizens of Jefferson considered her a relic of a time best forgotten. Her own peculiarities only gave more ammunition to those who sought an end to the old ways that were now considered decadent in the first decades of the 20th century.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I only see a couple of references (or at least direct references) to the Civil War in this story.  The first comes right at the beginning of the story when the narrator makes reference to the Union and Confederate dead in the cemetery.  The second refers to the old soldiers who come to pay their respects at Miss Emily's funeral.

I think that these mentions of the war are made to emphasize how Miss Emily is part of the ancient past.  She is associated with the Civil War, even though she herself was not old enough to have been the contemporary of the men who fought in it.  The references make her appear to be part of a completely different time than the society in which she actually lived.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Where do references to the Civil War occur in the story? How does the war play a part in the story?

The story "A Rose for Emily" and the title character Emily Grierson show the world of the South as it experienced a fundamental shift, from the days of slavery and aristocratic plantation owner families (of which the Griersons are one) that is coming to an end when Emily is born to the new, post-Civil War world, where antebellum chivalry is lost to the push for progress. The war comes up, explicitly and implicitly, when these conflicts between old and new and tradition and progress come to the surface.

Emily Grierson experiences the changes that the Civil War and its outcome makes on the South and her hometown of Jefferson. Cast as an aging Southern belle domineered by a controlling father, Emily has few chances to break the mold of tradition, and she doesn't until her affair with Homer Barron in her thirties. When that fails to lead to the appropriate marriage and fulfillment of her traditional role, she clings to the other antebellum option for unmarried ladies: that of a haughty, mysterious spinster.

It is note-worthy that when Emily chooses to follow her own heart and pursue a man sexually, she chooses Homer Barron. First, he is a Northerner, and so emblematic of the changes caused by the war. Second, he's in town for a sidewalk construction project, making him an example of the sweeping changes of the North coming in to change the nature of the South. That Emily chooses him suggests an even deeper rebellion against the traditional Southern ways and ties in to the conflicts set up by the Civil War.

Another way the war sets up a conflict between the old ways and new is in the townspeople's interactions with Emily. Men like Colonel Sartoris and Judge Stevens still subscribe to Southern chivalry and they see Emily as a damsel in distress, a woman who must be protected, and so they remit her taxes and refuse to confront her about the smell coming from her house, respectively. As time goes on, however, and the post-war changes continue, new aldermen, who don't follow the same rules of chivalry, come to try to collect Miss Emily's taxes. This event shows the conflict of the new South, where progress is king, and the old. 

 

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on