Roman Empire

Start Free Trial

What factors led to the fall of the Western Roman Empire?

Quick answer:

Several factors contributed to the fall of the Western Roman Empire, including the socioeconomic and political instability of the empire, the Germanic invasion and the invasion of other so-called "barbarian" tribes, the rapid rise of the Eastern Roman Empire, and more.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

One of the main reasons why the Western Roman Empire collapsed was the invasion and the attacks of the "barbarian" tribes. The Roman Empire and the Germanic tribes had clashed multiple times in the past; however, with the start of the fifth century, things took a turn for the worse for the Romans, as they finally fell under the power and influence of the Goths, the Vandals, and several other Germanic tribes. In 467, the Germanic soldier and statesmen Odoacer took the throne from the Roman emperor Romulus Augustulus and became the first king of Italy. The year of 467 is considered to be the year when the Western Roman Empire officially met its demise.

Another reason was the weak and unstable social and political climate. The inflation and the high unemployment rate, which came as consequences of the constant lost wars and pointless investments in the military forces, as well as the incompetent leadership, caused a lot of problems both for the working class and the wealthy class. Soon enough, the Empire lost the ability to control its economy and its government.

As the Western Roman Empire weakened, the Eastern Roman Empire was gradually rising to power. Byzantium or Constantinople was slowly becoming the biggest and wealthiest city in the Empire and it was constantly protected from outside invaders and attackers, while Rome was neglected. Motivated by the weakened state of Italy, the Germanic tribes transferred all of their energy into conquering the Western Roman Empire.

Finally, some historians believe that Christianity might have actually contributed to the collapse of the Empire, as it contradicted the old Roman traditions and the Church started to gain more sociopolitical power.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What caused the fall of the Roman Empire?

Many theories have been advanced for the cause of the fall of the Roman Empire. Gibbon, in his famous Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, argued that Christianity was the essential cause of its collapse. Other theories include lead in drinking vessels, barbarian invasions, and the instability of a quasi-hereditary monarchy with ill-defined rules of succession.

More modern scholarship, though, takes a rather different perspective. Rather than accept the sixth century fall of the city of Rome to the barbarians as the end of the empire, scholars point out that what happened was actually a shift of power eastwards from Rome to Constantinople, caused by these weaknesses and barbarian invasions, and the Eastern Roman, or Byzantine, Empire flourished until the fall of Coinstantnople in 1453.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What caused the fall of the Roman Empire?

Ah, this question has beset historians for centuries! Theories about what brought the Fall of the Roman Empire include excessive military spending, lead poisoning, and just about everything in between. The present consensus, based upon historical and archaeological evidence, is that there was no singular cause of the Fall, but a number of factors which served to compound one another. 

Perhaps the biggest reason contributing to the Fall of Rome was how widespread the Empire grew to be. At its fullest extent, the Roman Empire included the coast of North Africa, all of Southern and Western Europe, and even territory in the Arabian Peninsula. In all of these territories, soldiers and officials were sent from the central Roman territory to act as overseers and enforcers of the Roman law. Over such a wide expense of territory, it was incredibly difficult to govern such various locations with differing troubles like crop failure, crime, or invaders from outside the Empire. Imagine trying to hop on one foot, tap dance with the other, use one and to eat spaghetti, and the other to juggle- it's just too much going on out of concert! In short, Rome could not effectively manage the great expanses of territory they had acquired so quickly, and the empire crumbled under poor administration. 

In addition to the "too much to govern, not enough government" problem, the Roman Empire had to deal with repeated invasions by Germanic tribes from the North. With inadequate numbers of Roman soldiers to fight or officials to negotiate, territory in the North and West of the Empire quickly fell to the Goths, the Huns, the Alans, and others. Some of these tribes were so successful that they made it all the way to Italy, and in 476, the Germanic king Odoacer deposed the last Emperor of Rome. Though Rome had been weakening for some time, the overthrow of Emperor Romulus meant that the West was irreparably torn apart.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on