The seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries were a time of profound transformation across Europe and its colonies. From religious reforms and political upheaval to colonial expansion and economic revolution, these years laid the groundwork for modern civilization. Understanding the historical context of this era reveals the complex interplay between power, religion, and commerce that shaped the world, as captured through the lens of literature like Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe.

Religious Dissent and Tolerance

The term "Dissenters," or Nonconformists, describes Protestant groups such as Quakers, Congregationalists, Presbyterians, and Baptists, who rejected the Church of England's authority. Under the 1662 Act of Uniformity, ministers were required to use the Book of Common Prayer, and those who defied this were penalized by the subsequent Five Mile Act, which restricted them from coming within five miles of their parish. This oppressive climate was slightly eased when William and Mary ascended to the throne in 1688. Their Toleration Act of 1689 allowed Dissenters to license their meeting houses, contingent on oaths of allegiance under the Test Act, representing a shift toward religious tolerance in England.

The Restoration and Its Aftermath

Oliver Cromwell’s rule from 1653 brought a Puritanical government, which, despite benefiting the middle class and merchants, was marred by high taxes and authoritarian governance. Upon Cromwell's death in 1658, his son Richard's inadequate leadership led to a near civil war, paving the way for the Restoration of the monarchy in 1660. Charles II's return marked the reestablishment of the Church of England through the Clarendon Code, mandating oaths of allegiance and prohibiting armed resistance against the king.

Colonial Expansion and Global Power Shifts

The latter half of the seventeenth century saw significant shifts in global power. Spain's naval defeats and Portugal's inability to fend off Dutch aggression led to their decline, while France and England emerged as dominant global forces. England's colonies, such as Jamestown and Plymouth, flourished, with additional territories like the Carolinas and Pennsylvania being established. These burgeoning colonies fostered economic growth and expanded England’s influence in the New World.

The Glorious Revolution

Following Charles II, James II's reign began in 1685 with controversial policies, notably freeing Catholics and Dissenters, which alarmed the nobility. The failed rebellion by the Earl of Argyll and the Duke of Monmouth left James secure until he had an heir, prompting fears of a Catholic dynasty. Noblemen and merchants invited William of Orange and his wife Mary to intervene, leading to the Glorious Revolution of 1688. William III’s successful, peaceful invasion forced James II to flee, marking a shift toward constitutional monarchy and Protestant ascendancy.

William III's subsequent military actions against France and internal reforms, including the creation of the Bank of England in 1694, underpinned a commercial and financial revolution. This laid the foundations for Britain’s eventual dominance in global commerce.

England in Transition

By 1719, England had evolved into a more stable and tolerant society, reducing emigration to America. The economy was robust, with high wages and low unemployment, as noted by Defoe. Despite market threats from the textile trade competition and the South Sea Bubble financial crisis of 1721, England's economy emerged resilient. Unlike the French Mississippi Scheme, the South Sea Bubble did not dampen English enthusiasm for financial speculation, fueling resources for the imminent Industrial Revolution.

Literary Reflections of Societal Attitudes

Daniel Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe provides a vivid reflection of seventeenth-century attitudes toward race and religion, depicting the era's social hierarchies and colonial mentalities. Crusoe's interactions with characters like Xury and Friday reveal his ingrained belief in white superiority, a common sentiment of his time. Simultaneously, the narrative underscores Crusoe's religiosity, a marker of his societal milieu, through persistent Christian devotion and introspection. Defoe’s work invites readers, especially young adults, to explore the evolution of racial and religious ideologies since that period.

The story begins in mid-seventeenth-century York, offering a brief glimpse into Robinson Crusoe’s early life. It then transitions to the Moorish port of Sallee, where Crusoe is captured by pirates and imprisoned. After his escape, he relocates to Brazil and becomes a planter. From his Brazilian plantation, Crusoe embarks on a voyage to Africa, which ends in a shipwreck. As the sole survivor, he spends the next twenty-eight years on a deserted island.

Crusoe’s new home, a small hilly island off the South American coast, is inhabited only by wild animals and birds. Unfamiliar with much of the island’s lush vegetation, Crusoe discovers sugarcane, tobacco plants, melon and grape vines, and citrus trees. During an expedition to the far side of the island, he spots a nearby landmass that he cannot identify. In stark contrast to the bustling city where Crusoe was born and raised, the island is an unspoiled paradise, a true example of untamed nature.

Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe is often hailed as a pioneering achievement in English prose fiction. Its narrative techniques, blending realism and fiction, along with its spiritual undertones, have captivated readers for generations. This article explores the various narrative strategies and thematic layers that contribute to the enduring appeal of this literary classic.

Narrative Devices and Realism

At the heart of Robinson Crusoe lies a compelling blend of fiction and perceived truth. Defoe crafts his narrative to resemble a true story by adopting the guise of an editor, which adds a layer of authenticity. The first-person narration weaves a tale that feels lived, with meticulous details, accurate descriptions, and references to real locations and dates. This method creates what literary scholars term 'verisimilitude,' a sense that the story could indeed be real.

The story's structure as a fictional autobiography allows the reader to delve into Crusoe's psyche as an old man reflecting on his past. The integration of an incomplete diary within the novel bolsters this sense of realism. As readers, we're given the impression that Crusoe's experiences are not just creations of imagination but reflections of genuine human endeavor and survival.

Spiritual Undertones

Beneath its surface adventure, Robinson Crusoe resonates deeply as a spiritual or religious fable. Defoe, nearly a Dissenter minister, infuses the narrative with religious overtones. Crusoe's journey is framed as a testament to "the wisdom of Providence in all the variety of our circumstance," echoing the tradition of spiritual instruction literature.

"justify and honour the wisdom of Providence in all the variety of our circumstance."

The novel mirrors several forms of spiritual fables. Crusoe maintains a diary akin to a spiritual biography, recording his quest for salvation, a practice reminiscent of John Bunyan's Grace Abounding. It also aligns with the guide tradition, where Crusoe's trials showcase both human vulnerabilities and divine solutions.

Furthermore, the theme of divine intervention, or Providence, runs throughout the tale as Crusoe continuously questions the role of God in his fate. Lastly, the narrative echoes the pilgrim allegory, where the protagonist embarks on a journey away from home, only to find his way back to God, reminiscent of parables like the Prodigal Son.

Time and Structure

Defoe's attention to time in Robinson Crusoe is a critical element that underscores the novel's structure. The narrative unfolds in chronological order, with detailed accounts marking the passage of time. Though exhaustive, these descriptions reflect the era's preoccupation with temporality and serve as a framework for Crusoe's spiritual and physical metamorphosis.

The use of time not only anchors the story in reality but also reinforces the themes of patience and perseverance, as Crusoe adapts to his new life, meticulously recording each day's events.

Nature and Imagery

Defoe's command of imagery in Robinson Crusoe is evident in his use of everyday life and nature to ground the story in realism. The similes and metaphors, often drawn from nature, echo the plain language of biblical proverbs and emphasize Crusoe's middle-class background.

This imagery serves to highlight human ingenuity, one of Defoe's favored themes, showcasing Crusoe's capacity to adapt and survive. The vivid descriptions not only bring Crusoe's world to life but also invite the reader to step into his shoes, experiencing the adventure alongside him.

Allegorical Interpretations

The allegorical dimensions of Robinson Crusoe have intrigued scholars, suggesting parallels between Crusoe's experiences and Defoe's own life. Defoe's writings, including his meditations and autobiographical pieces, hint at an underlying personal narrative within Crusoe's tale. Some critics propose that Crusoe's solitude and resilience reflect Defoe's personal trials and introspections.

While no definitive connections have been established, the allegorical reading of the novel enriches its complexity. Whether deliberate or not, Crusoe's adventures can be seen as a metaphor for Defoe's thoughts on solitude, perseverance, and the human condition.

In sum, Robinson Crusoe stands as a monumental work that melds realism with spiritual allegory, offering readers a multi-layered narrative that continues to resonate across centuries, providing both adventure and contemplation in equal measure.

Robinson Crusoe, told from a first-person perspective, centers around the titular character. The other significant character, Friday, appears after two-thirds of the narrative has unfolded.

Crusoe possesses an inherently adventurous spirit. Defying his father’s “serious and excellent counsel,” he pursues a seafaring career to satisfy his “wandering inclination.” Even later in life, after returning to England, marrying, having three children, and becoming a widower, Crusoe once again ventures to sea, embarking on a lengthy voyage to China.

I learned to look more upon the bright side of my condition, and less upon the dark side.

Robinson Crusoe’s character is a study in contradictions. He oscillates between being a fervent capitalist and a reflective Christian; an adventurer drawn to exploration and a refined Englishman who creates a comfortable home for himself; a proponent of human dignity and a slave trader. Defoe presents these contradictions as typical traits of a middle-class English Protestant tradesman of the era.

Conversely, Friday, a native from a nearby island, is portrayed as a savage—a reformed cannibal. Crusoe views Friday as his “faithful, loving, sincere servant”; notably, the first English word Crusoe teaches Friday is “Master.”

Many significant themes in Robinson Crusoe are embodied in the title character and his relationship with Friday. Through the tale of Crusoe’s stay on the island, Defoe extensively comments on various social and philosophical ideas. The novel serves as an allegory for a journey from spiritual estrangement to redemption, with Crusoe’s life transitioning from rebellion to punishment, conversion, and ultimately deliverance. However, Robinson Crusoe is also an economic document, emphasizing the taming of an untamed environment, depicting Crusoe as a meticulous recorder of his projects and crops, and illustrating the colonial mindset in Crusoe’s education of Friday. Furthermore, Crusoe’s journal includes numerous passages where he contemplates time, labor, and the accumulation of material wealth.

1600s: Religion is a central aspect of life. Numerous European nations—such as England, Spain, the Netherlands, and Portugal—persecute religious reformers and dissenters. Consequently, many religious radicals migrate to the New World to freely practice their faith.

Early 1700s: Religious zeal diminishes. The philosophes in France attempt to eliminate religion from their society, but with limited success.

Today: While not universal, religious tolerance is generally accepted. A significant portion of the global population still adheres to some form of organized religion.

1600s: Nations such as England, France, and Spain aim to remain dominant imperial powers. Sustaining colonial control and developing a powerful military is very costly.

Early 1700s: Innovations in banking in Amsterdam and the establishment of the Bank of England lay the groundwork for modern national finance, introducing the concept of national debt.

Today: In impoverished countries, national debt hinders their ability to compete with wealthier nations. In affluent countries, national debts cause considerable concern, yet they are crucial to the global financial system.

1600s: Trade primarily involves raw materials, luxury items, or costly manufactured products. Occupational specialization is increasing in European economies. For instance, a farmer might start concentrating on dairy production.

Early 1700s: Manufactured goods become more abundant and affordable. The average person can now purchase bread, candles, and cloth from specialized vendors.

Today: The economies of most Western countries have transitioned from manufacturing to technology.

• Robinson Crusoe (1916): Silent black-and-white film starring Robert Paton Gibbs.
• Robinson Crusoe (1917): Silent film featuring a female Crusoe.
• Rabbitson Crusoe (1956): Animated adaptation featuring a rodent Crusoe.
• Robinson Crusoe TV Series (1965): Adaptation of Defoe's novel.
• Robinson Crusoe TV Movie (1974): Adaptation produced in the United Kingdom.
• Robinson Crusoe (1996): Film produced by USA Pictures, directed by Rod Hardy and George Miller, starring Pierce Brosnan as Robinson Crusoe.
• Robinson Crusoe (1927): British silent film adaptation.
• Robinson Crusoe of Mystery Island (1936): Film adaptation exploring variations of the Crusoe story.
• The Adventures of Robinson Crusoe (1954): Directed by Luis Buñuel, filmed in Mexico; known as the most straightforward adaptation.
• Robinson Crusoe on Mars (1964): Film adaptation that presents a unique interpretation of the Crusoe story.
• Robinson Crusoe and the Tiger (1972): Film adaptation from the perspective of a tiger.
• Three animated film versions of Robinson Crusoe have been produced, further expanding on the story's legacy.

• Joyce Appleby, Capitalism and a New Social Order. The Republican Vision of the 1790s, New York University Press, 1984.
• James Beattie, “On Fable and Romance,” in his Dissertations Moral and Critical, W. Strahan, 1783.
• Theophilus Cibber, “De Foe,” in The Lives of the Poets of Great Britain and Ireland, Vol. IV by Mr. Cibber and Other Hands, R. Griffiths, 1753, pp. 313–25.
• Charles Gildon, The Life and Strange Surprizing Adventures of Mr D-De F-, J. Roberts, 1719.
• Peter Hulme, “Robinson Crusoe and Friday,” in his Colonial Encounters: Europe and the Native Caribbean, 1492–1797, Methuen, 1986.
• Philip D. Morgan, Slave Counterpoint: Black Culture in the Eighteenth-Century Chesapeake and Lowcountry, North Carolina Press, 1998.
• Jean-Jacques Rousseau, “Rousseau on ‘Robinson Crusoe’,” in Defoe: The Critical Heritage, edited and translated by Pat Rogers, Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1972, pp. 52–4.
• Sir Walter Scott, “Daniel Defoe,” in On Novelists and Fiction, edited by Ian Williams, Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1968, pp. 164–83.
• Alfred W. Crosby, Ecological Imperialism: The Biological Expansion of Europe, 900–1900, Cambridge University Press, 1986.
• Peter Earle, The World of Defoe, Atheneum, 1977.
• Maximilian E. Novak, Defoe and the Nature of Man, Oxford University Press, 1963.
• John J Richetti, Popular Fiction Before Richardson, Clarendon Press, 1969.
• Pat Rogers, Robinson Crusoe, George Allen and Unwin, 1979.
• Arthur Secord, Studies in the Narrative Method of Defoe, University of Illinois Press, 1968.
• Diana Spearman, The Novel and Society, London, 1966.
• Ian Watt, The Rise of the Novel: Studies in Defoe, Richardson and Fielding, Chatto and Windus, 1957.
• Ian Bell, Defoe’s Fiction. London: Croom Helm, 1985.
• Harold Bloom, ed., Daniel Defoe: Modern Critical Views, New York: Chelsea House, 1987.
• F. H. Ellis, ed., Twentieth Century Interpretations of Robinson Crusoe, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1969.
• J. B. Moore, A Checklist of the Writings of Daniel Defoe, rev. ed., Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1971.
• John A. Stoler, Daniel Defoe: An Annotated Bibliography of Modern Criticism, 1900–1980, New York: Garland, 1984.