In "The Great Automatic Grammatizator," a short story by Roald Dahl, Mr. John Bohlen, a wealthy inventor, praises Adolph Knipe for his exceptional programming skills. Bohlen, who had invented a machine that could perform complex mathematical calculations, could not get it to work properly. It was Knipe who, with his meticulous programming, was able to correct the errors and get the machine to function as desired.
Bohlen is so impressed by Knipe's abilities that he proposes they use the machine to write stories, as he believes the process of story writing is merely a mathematical one. He praises Knipe, saying, "You, Knipe, are the only man in the world who could do it!"
Knipe's reaction is a mix of flattery and apprehension. He is pleased by Bohlen's praise but is also wary of the implications of the proposal. He recognizes the potential dangers of such a machine, and how it could lead to the mechanization of art and the devaluation of human creativity. However, the prospect of financial gain and recognition eventually sways him, and he agrees to work on the project.
Knipe's reaction is significant because it highlights the tension between creativity and commercial success, a recurring theme in Dahl's story. Despite his initial reservations, Knipe chooses to prioritize profit over artistic integrity, leading to the creation of a machine that could potentially render human authors obsolete.
The AI-generated response is correct in its general assessment but makes some errors when quoting the narrative and describing some of the details.
This short story begins with John Bohlen lavishing praise on the young computer programmer Adolph Knipe for being instrumental in the development of a new computing machine.
I don’t think I have to remind you that your own contribution, especially to the original plans, was an important one. In fact, I might go so far as to say that without you and some of your ideas, this project might still be on the drawing-boards today.
However, the quote that the AI-generated answer erronously provides - "You, Knipe, are the only man in the world who could do it!" - does not appear in the text.
The AI's answer is mostly correct in assessing Knipe's reaction to this praise. Despite the recognition of his good work, he seems uneasy, even dissatisfied, as he considers the limitations of his project. One thing that troubles him is how this computing machine is unable to produce original thoughts. However, when he puts his mind to the project, Knipe enthusiastically upgrades the program to write stories and searches for a way to use it to make him rich.
The AI response is also incorrect in crediting the idea for the grammatizator program to Bohlen. It is actually Knipe's idea and Bohlen is initially doubtful when he first hears about it.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.