Religious Themes
In Norman Maclean’s novel A River Runs Through It, fly fishing emerges as a profound metaphor, weaving together themes of beauty, grace, and spirituality. The act of fly fishing serves not just as a pastime but as a means for Norman to strive for connection with his brother, Paul. This delicate art becomes a symbol of imposing order on chaos, a fleeting attempt to recapture the idyllic harmony of Eden amidst the stark realities of a fallen world. Within this framework, fly fishing transcends its earthly practice, merging seamlessly with worship, as the Maclean family finds no sharp distinction between their devotion to God and the tranquil pursuit of fishing.
Their spiritual journey is subtly shaped by a Calvinist Presbyterian theology, though Reverend Maclean stands out with his unusual embrace of beauty. He frequently uses the word "beautiful," most poignantly in reference to Paul, whose artistry he believes is a pathway to reclaiming lost grace. Despite humanity’s inherent "mess" and "fallen" nature, beauty in this narrative becomes synonymous with Christian grace, offering redemption and counteracting the despair that comes with loss.
Central to the novel is the enduring theme of being one’s "brother’s keeper." This notion haunts the narrator, Norman, over decades, as he grapples with his inability to protect Paul. Through his writing, Norman offers an act of grace to his brother, a tribute enshrined in Christian imagery as Paul embodies the "prodigal son." In the Maclean’s world, fly fishing again symbolizes a channel of grace, a way to embrace the family’s wayward member.
Underlying these themes is the Christian concept of Logos, an idea that permeates the text. The interplay of spirituality and language is highlighted in a conversation between Norman and his father, where they ponder "The Gospel of John" and its depiction of Christ as the divine Logos. Reverend Maclean’s assertion that "words are underneath the water" suggests that language precedes and pervades the natural world. This belief is vital for the Macleans, who perceive the river as a voice, speaking uniquely to each individual. Just as grace can be elusive, so too can understanding, yet both are deeply personal dialogues between the self and the divine. Despite Paul’s tumultuous life, this shared theological perspective reassures his father, implying that Paul, in his own way, grasped the profound truths of beauty and reality that others might overlook.
Unity of Nature and Religion
The narrative of A River Runs Through It finds its strength in the distinctive harmony it portrays between the Maclean family's Protestant Christian beliefs and the natural world. Maclean illustrates an intrinsic unity between the characters and their environment, devoid of any notion of human dominion over nature. Instead, the wilderness of Montana unfolds as a sacred backdrop, unmarred by threats, where humanity's trials stem more from interpersonal complexities than from untamed landscapes.
Amidst this setting, the natural world serves as a sanctuary, a place of solace and spirituality for the family. Their interactions with this environment reveal a deep-seated reverence, where the land itself demands resilience and moral integrity from its inhabitants. This aspect of Maclean’s storytelling underscores the expectation for individuals to embody toughness tempered by morality, a principle that the Maclean family adheres to with unwavering commitment.
However, the serenity of this natural world is juxtaposed with human fallibility, illustrated through characters like Neal and Old Rawhide, whose irresponsible behavior in this revered landscape stands out starkly. Their actions serve as a reminder of the discord that can arise when individuals fail to respect the inherent unity between nature and spirituality. The wilderness, thus, becomes a narrative force...
(This entire section contains 226 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
that accentuates the moral and emotional journeys of the characters, challenging them to navigate their lives in harmony with the sacred earth around them.
Fishing as a Spiritual Experience
Fishing, as depicted in the narrative, transcends mere sport to become a profound spiritual journey. When the brothers take to the river, they step into a "world apart," a sanctuary where life's chaos gradually fades away. Maclean portrays this escape vividly, describing how the tumult of daily existence is left behind, item by item, until a harmonious unity with the river is achieved. This immersion is not merely about the act of fishing but about entering a state of grace where the burdens of earthly life are momentarily lifted.
The novel intricately details the methods and tools of fishing, transforming them into symbols of deeper meaning. Casting, for example, is a meticulous and rhythmic process, beginning between two and ten o’clock, reflecting a meditative precision. Unlike typical fishing with a "pole," fly fishing employs a delicate "rod" of split bamboo, with elegant silk thread wrappings, emphasizing a connection to nature that is both intimate and respectful.
In a particularly evocative scene, Paul’s skill in shadow casting becomes a mystical dance with the supernatural. As the water forms a halo around him, this moment of artistry suggests a transcendence, as if he is momentarily part of a higher realm. The religious imagery woven into these descriptions underscores the theme of redemption and beauty, suggesting that even flawed humans can find moments of grace. The act of discovering a new fishing spot symbolizes a "fresh start in life," akin to the cleansing ritual of baptism, offering renewal and hope.
Writing and the Search for Meaning
In the same way that fishing acts as a balm for the spirit, writing serves as a conduit to discover the deeper currents of life’s meaning. Within the pages of Norman Maclean's novel, a poignant scene unfolds—a conversation between Maclean and his father about the profound opening of the Gospel of John: “In the beginning was the Word. . . .” This dialogue explores a philosophical conundrum: Did the Word precede the natural world, or did the elements of nature, such as rocks and rivers, give birth to the Word? As they ponder this, a poignant parallel emerges in the figure of Paul, who, while engrossed in catching what will become his final fish, embodies both grace and beauty. Yet, despite his undeniable elegance, Paul is adrift, lacking the moral bonds that tether one to society and the divine, leaving him unable to find salvation.
The Enigmatic Nature of Life and Death
The conclusion of A River Runs Through It weaves a poetic tapestry, yet leaves readers pondering the mysterious connections between life and death. The pronouns "it" and "their" float ambiguously, leaving the reader to ponder their meaning. Despite the passage of time and the loss of his brother Paul and father, Norman Maclean continues to fish the Big Blackfoot River. He reflects, "Eventually, all things merge into one, and a river runs through it." This river, shaped by an ancient "great flood," flows over rocks that seem to have emerged from "the basement of time." Beneath these rocks, Maclean senses words that belong to his lost loved ones, ending his reflection, "haunted by waters."