Compare and Contrast

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Late 1700s: Husbands and wives strictly divided their tasks. Men were responsible for farming, managing finances, and business affairs, while women took care of the home, children, and garden.

Today: Couples are more likely to share responsibilities based on individual strengths, yet women often still handle most house cleaning and child care duties.

Late 1700s: Laws made it challenging, if not impossible, for Dame Van Winkle to divorce her husband and remarry, even after being abandoned for two decades.

Today: A woman in Dame Van Winkle's situation could divorce her husband after abandonment and find a new partner to help manage the farm.

Late 1770s: Irving's hometown, New York City, was a major metropolitan hub with a population of 80,000, while the entire United States had fewer than 7 million people.

Today: New York City's population alone exceeds 7 million.

Media Adaptations

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Three outstanding unabridged versions of "Rip Van Winkle" are available on audiocassette or compact disc. Each version is paired with "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow." A reading by Jim Beach was produced in 1990 by Blackstone Books. James Hamilton narrates both stories in the 1993 recording by Recorded Books, LLC. Additionally, George Vafiadis's reading was recorded in 2000 by Sound Room Publishers.

Tales of Washington Irving (1987) is an animated film collection released on videocassette, featuring works from 1970. Distributed by MGM/UA Home Video, the 48-minute tape includes "Rip Van Winkle" and "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow," with voice performances by Mel Blanc and other well-known stars.

A children's video adaptation based on Irving's story, Rip Van Winkle, was created in 1997 by Rabbit Ears Productions. Narrated by Angelica Huston, it also features original music by Jay Ungar and Molly Mason.

Historical Context

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Becoming a Nation

Washington Irving was born in 1783, the year the American Revolution was officially concluded with the Treaty of Paris. Although his parents were born in England, Irving was part of the first generation to recognize from birth that they were not British subjects, but Americans. The nation was still in its infancy and largely undefined. The implications of the Revolution and how the new country would differ from the old colonies were not yet clear. Irving explored this issue in "Rip Van Winkle," where his characters passionately debate political change on election day.

Before the century's end, society's men and women donned elaborate powdered wigs and ornate clothing similar to that of the French court. However, the ideal shifted to the common man, and the notion of a nation governed by a wealthy aristocracy began to give way to a more egalitarian concept of "rule by the people," meaning rule by all white men, regardless of social class. In 1792, the Federalist and Democratic-Republican parties were established. Scenes like the one Rip encounters upon returning to his village, where a "crowd of folk" argue and are on the brink of rioting on election day, became common across the country. The shift to egalitarian rule was tumultuous. Topics such as "citizens' rights," including property rights, were hotly debated, often marked by ignorance and anger.

When "Rip Van Winkle" was published in 1819, the question of Native American habitation was largely unaddressed. Native Americans were frequently displaced as the new nation expanded westward, and in 1830, Congress established the Oklahoma Indian Territory, forcibly relocating thousands. The appropriate role for Native Americans in the new America became an increasingly debated issue. In 1848, Irving added a "postscript" to "Rip Van Winkle," following the "Note." This addition, often omitted in modern editions, recounts several Native American traditional stories about ghosts and spirits in the Catskill region, reinforcing the ancient mystery Irving sought to evoke in the story.

The New American Literature

"Rip Van Winkle" emerged during a time when America sought a new kind of literature to reflect its self-image. At the close of the eighteenth century, American writing primarily consisted of schoolbooks, sermons, and historical essays, developing ideas originating from Europe. There was little to distinguish American literature from British literature. A handful of plays—most of them poor in quality and none still performed—featured American characters, but readers looking for fiction had to import novels from England. The new nation now wanted to forge ahead, creating American ideas and models for future generations to emulate.

One of the most notable aspects of The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent. for contemporary readers is its strong European influence. Many of the thirty or so sketches and stories revolve around English characters in English settings. Some plots, such as that of "Rip Van Winkle," are adapted from German folk tales. However, readers in the 1820s were particularly impressed by two things: a few stories, including "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow," were set in the United States, and the writing was more compelling and vivid than anything else available at the time. The American-set stories featured romantic depictions of the stunning and formidable American landscapes, celebrating the desire to escape from society and reconnect with the wilderness—a theme that soon became quintessentially American.

For the next fifty years, Irving served as a model for writers on both sides of the Atlantic. A group of satirists in New York during the early nineteenth century even named themselves the "Knickerbocker Group" in his honor. Though they are largely forgotten today, Irving's humor and writing style influenced generations of prominent writers, including Edgar Allan Poe, Herman Melville, and Mark Twain. Despite his success in blending European material with American settings, Irving had no predecessors to guide him in this endeavor.

Expert Q&A

Which war takes place during Van Winkle's sleep in "Rip van Winkle"?

The American Revolution occurs during Rip Van Winkle's sleep. This war, fought between 1765 and 1783, was driven by American desires for independence from British rule and the establishment of republican values. Upon waking, Rip is shocked by the societal and political changes, still loyal to King George III, which makes him appear outdated. Through Rip's character, Irving conveys a sense of nostalgia for the pre-revolutionary colonial era.

What might Irving's "Rip Van Winkle" suggest about the impact of the Revolutionary War and democracy?

Irving might be suggesting that the American Revolution brought about great changes to the country. Rip Van Winkle falls asleep for twenty years and misses the entire American Revolution. When he wakes, he is shocked by the ways in which America has been transformed. For example, people no longer serve under the British king but are loyal to their president, George Washington. In addition, people are voting, which is something he has never done before. Irving implies that having missed just these twenty years makes someone hopelessly out of date in America, as it has changed so greatly in that time period. It has gone from being part of the British empire to being its own democratic nation. Rip is completely out of date and can'

How do the war and Rip's wife's death impact the rest of Rip's life?

The war and his wife's death are both factors in Rip's retreat from the obligations of life.

How does the town's culture change before and after Rip Van Winkle's mountain trip?

Before Rip Van Winkle's mountain trip, his town is a quiet, rural community focused on farming and leisurely pursuits. After his 20-year sleep, he returns to find a dramatically transformed town, now larger and politically active due to the Revolutionary War and the upcoming presidential election. The once tranquil town is now vibrant and bustling, reflecting America's shift from a British colony to an independent nation.

How does "Rip Van Winkle" depict the American Revolution and its people? How does fiction reshape history?

"Rip Van Winkle" contrasts pre- and post-Revolution America, depicting the shift from apathy under British rule to energetic self-governance. Rip symbolizes the old mindset, content under King George III, while post-sleep, he encounters a politically engaged, vibrant community. Fiction reshapes history by creating a myth that independence brought about positive change and self-sufficiency, emphasizing a new national optimism despite the fact that colonial Americans were already resilient and vigorous.

"Rip Van Winkle" and Societal, Political, and Cultural Reflections

"Rip Van Winkle" by Washington Irving reflects significant societal, political, and cultural shifts in post-revolutionary America. The story contrasts the oppressive Puritan past and European influences with emerging American values. Rip's character, symbolizing the lethargic colonist, wakes to a transformed society post-American Revolution, where active citizenship and democratic engagement replace colonial apathy. The inn's transformation from a static gossip hub under British rule to a bustling political center underlines these changes, paralleling the newfound American independence and identity.

Why are Rip's political views suddenly unfavorable in "Rip Van Winkle"?

Rip Van Winkle's political views become unfavorable because, during his 20-year sleep, America undergoes a revolution, transitioning from British rule to an independent republic. Upon awakening, Rip unknowingly expresses loyalty to King George III, which angers the townspeople who now see him as a Tory and a potential spy. Only after realizing his identity and the reason for his outdated views do the villagers understand his situation.

Conflict and Historical Change in "Rip Van Winkle"

In Washington Irving's "Rip Van Winkle," the primary conflict arises from Rip's strained marriage to Dame Van Winkle, characterized by their opposing personalities: Rip's laziness and his wife's nagging. This personal conflict is resolved when Rip wakes from a 20-year slumber to find his wife deceased. The story also explores a broader moral conflict between the apathetic "Old World" values Rip embodies and the vibrant, democratic spirit of post-Revolutionary America, highlighting historical change and progress.

Gender and political issues in Washington Irving's "Rip Van Winkle."

In Washington Irving's "Rip Van Winkle," gender issues are depicted through Dame Van Winkle's domineering behavior, which symbolizes the oppressive nature of societal expectations for men. Politically, the story reflects the American Revolution, with Rip's long sleep representing the transition from colonial America to an independent nation, highlighting changes in governance and societal structures.

Rip Van Winkle's Sleep Through the American Revolution

In Washington Irving's "Rip Van Winkle," Rip's sleep symbolizes the transformative changes in society during the American Revolution. When Rip awakens after 20 years, he finds a completely altered world, reflecting the dramatic political, social, and cultural shifts that occurred during his long slumber.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Style, Form, and Literary Elements

Next

Connections and Further Reading

Loading...