Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

Above all, Edmond and Jules de Goncourt valued truth in literature; in all of their novels, they attempted to find the truth of the subjects they chose. In this they were in the vanguard of a literary trend in the late nineteenth century known as naturalism, which reached its zenith in the works of Émile Zola. In Renée Mauperin, the Goncourts analyze with shrewdness and precision a particular segment of Parisian society. Viewing this world through the eyes of an intelligent and sensitive young woman, they depict the shallowness and pettiness of many of the self-satisfied people who dominate society and try to dominate her.

The book also describes the various conditions of women in mid-nineteenth century France. There is the impetuous young Renée, who as a child cuts Denoisel’s hair and smokes her father’s cigarette and who later struggles against the conventions imposed on young Parisian women in 1864. There is Madame Mauperin, with her passion for “symmetry” and her fairly ordinary habit of overvaluing her son and undervaluing her daughter. Two other typical types of the period are Madame Davarande, the society matron who is religious only because she believes that God is chic, and Madame Bourjot, an intelligent woman married to a shallow and petty fool. In this society, the authors seem to suggest, only a shallow person seems able to find contentment, and this seems particularly to be the case for women.

Many of the other...

(The entire section is 478 words.)