The Reluctant Fundamentalist Cover Image

The Reluctant Fundamentalist

by Mohsin Hamid

Start Free Trial

Student Question

How could Erica and Changez represent different responses to 9/11?

Quick answer:

Erica and Changez represent different responses to 9/11 through their emotional reactions and lack of introspection. Changez's anger and desire for revenge reflect the immediate, visceral reactions of many post-9/11, overshadowing critical reflection. Conversely, Erica's nostalgia for a pre-9/11 world and personal past symbolizes a retreat into idealized memories, paralleling America's initial response of exceptionalism and avoidance of self-reflection. Both characters embody emotional responses that hinder deeper understanding and introspection.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In similar respects, both Erica and Changez refuse to engage in open and introspective self- reflection as the post 9.11 world takes shape.  For Changez, his immediate reaction to the September 11 attacks rests in an anger similar to revenge.  His reaction to the experience of post- September 11 perceptions is one that is purely response.  His feelings of rejection that might have always existed under the surface are domains that percolate above the surface.  His reaction is a representation of the immediate demand for vengeance or retribution that came about after the September 11 attacks.  In another sense, one can consider his emotion to be a representation of anger in its purest form.  There is little reflection in Changez.  There is an immediate sense of anger.  While the target of his anger is different than the anger of Americans in the wake of September 11, the reaction is the...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

same in that anger subsumed the ability to think and reflect critically about the meaning of the attacks.

Erica's response of nostalgia is a representation of the desire to go back into a pre- September 11 world.  Her response of nostalgia for Chris is representative of the American ideal that no nation could limit the American exceptionalist march towards greatness.  For Erica, her reaction of flight into the nostalgia of the personal is reflective of the perception of American greatness that was awoken as a result of the September 11 attacks.  Erica's response is a nostalgia into the personal, while America's own "nostalgia" was entering nations like Afghanistan without much regard for anything else.  Both reactions of nostalgia are representative of the desire to simply evade reflection and critical thought.  In her reaction, one sees a representation of the national desire to evade critical reflection and self- introspection in calling an image of what was to supplant what is. The reactions of both Erica and Changez represent American emotional experiences that followed the September 11 attacks, ones that Hamid might be suggesting precluded open and introspective self- reflection.

Approved by eNotes Editorial