Start Free Trial

How did the Catholic Church respond to Luther, Calvin, and the Protestant movement?

Quick answer:

The Catholic Church responded to the challenges of Luther, Calvin, and the Protestant movement initially in a somewhat mild way, allowing Luther to argue his position. When Luther refused to retract his position, his theses were deemed heretical, he was excommunicated, and, after the Diet of Worms, support of Luther was prohibited. The Church was forced to show tolerance to Lutheranism after the Peasants War.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

One of the long-term responses of the Catholic Church to the Reformation was the construction of many beautiful new churches, built in an ornate, lavish style called baroque. The sale of indulgences, which had provoked Luther's initial attack on the Church, raised substantial sums for the rebuilding of St. Peter's basilica in Rome. Luther thought this a monstrous extravagance, yet the Catholic Church's response was to double down on its lavish spending on great works of art and architecture designed to redound to the glory of God, and by extension, the Church.

At a time when most Europeans were still illiterate, lavish church designs had an important role to play in teaching the faithful the Word of God. Scenes from the Bible would be depicted in opulent stained-glass windows, and dramatic statues of Christ, the Virgin Mary, and the saints would tower over the faithful, overawing them with an intoxicating combination of aesthetic beauty and spiritual force.

As many Protestants, most notably Calvinists, chose to worship in plain surroundings—in churches with whitewashed walls and a complete lack of ornamentation—the Catholic Church went in the exact opposite direction, becoming ever more assertive in its passionate belief that lavish art and architecture had a vital role to play in securing the hearts and minds of the faithful.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Catholic Church's immediate reaction to Martin Luther's Theses was actually quite mild, with many elements of the church agreeing with the need for reformation. The bishops, who disagreed with Luther, merely asked Luther's immediate superior to help calm him. However, the effects of the Theses spread far beyond that which was intended by Luther, namely the curbing of indulgences, and began to feed into a general discontent with the Catholic Church. With this sentiment growing rapidly, the Pope ordered crackdowns and, fearing to lose control, declared the dissidents heretics. It was only as a result of this persecution that Luther actually broke from Rome and was then targeted for inquisition. This eventually led to Luther's excommunication from Rome. However, by then Luther's teachings were highly popular within the Holy Roman Empire, popular enough that the emperor was willing to protect Luther. Therefore Luther was able to go to and from the Council of Worms unmolested. However, the power of Rome still held sway over the Holy Roman Empire, and Luther was declared an outlaw. Thereafter Luther translated the Bible into German, causing the spread of the Protestant movement. The Church continued to attempt to fight its spread, and tensions eventually led to the Thirty Years' War.

Calvinism was considered simply part of the Protestant movement by the Catholics and was not truly considered an independent entity.

However, the largest example of a Catholic response to the Reformation is the Counter-Reformation. The Counter-Reformation was a series of reforms aimed at addressing many of the concerns of the Theses and weakening the Protestant movement. While this did mitigate the effects of the Protestant Reformation, the tensions remained and resulted in the Thirty Years' War. The Thirty Years' War ended with the Peace of Westphalia, which guaranteed the rights of Protestants in Europe.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Martin Luther is credited with the initiation of the Protestant Reformation that was opposed by the Roman Catholic Church. Luther communicated his ideas through writings such as the Ninety-Five Theses, which eventually led to the clear disconnect between the Lutherans and the Catholics during the Diet of Worms where Luther refused to denounce his ideology and religious public remarks. The Catholic Church reacted by banning all citizens of the Holy Roman Empire from supporting Lutheranism at the pain of having their property taken away. Luther was declared an outlaw, and an order for his arrest was made. He was protected by Frederic III while he continued his reform agenda.

John Calvin was a controversial theologian and a reformer alongside Luther during the Reformation. Calvin left the Catholic Church after the violent persecution of Protestants in France. The Catholic Church, as expected, opposed the reformation and imposed strict penalties on supporters and forced some of them out of their territories. The hostile environment was only addressed by a raft of treaties, with the first targeting the Lutherans (Peace of Augsburg) and later the Calvinists (Peace of Westphalia).

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In 1517, Martin Luther posted his 95 Theses to the door of All Saints' Church in Wittenberg, Germany. In these theses, Luther questioned the Catholic Church's sale of indulgences to reduce punishment in Purgatory for sins and argued that faith, not works, led to salvation.

The Catholic Church's first response to his theses was to summons him to Augsburg in 1518 to argue his position before Cardinal Thomas Cajeton. The debate with Cardinal Cajeton lasted three days, and Luther refused to retract his positions, leading Luther to need to escape arrest and imprisonment in Rome.

The Catholic Church's second response was for Pope Leo X, by 1520, to issue a papal bull declaring Luther's theses to be heretical. When Luther still did not retract his positions, he was excommunicated.

A third response of the Catholic Church was for Prince Frederick III, brother of Roman Emperor Charles V, to summons Luther to appear before the Imperial Diet, meaning assembly, at the Diet of Worms, in 1521. Here, Luther was asked by Johann Eck to defend the positions in his writings, which Luther did, including his rejection of the supremacy of the pope. The Diet of Worms led to Emperor Charles V issuing the Edict of Worms, forbidding anyone to support Luther upon punishment as a heretic.

After the bloody Peasants War raged from 1524 to 1525, the Catholic Church was forced to show tolerance to the emergence of Lutheranism. However, true peace was not established between Catholics and Protestants until the Treaty of Hamburg was signed after the Thirty Years' War ended in 1648, having begun in 1618.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial