Describe Comte's three stages of human history. Does Comte think it is possible for all three stage to exist together in the same place at the same time? Please offer an example of how someone at each of the three stages of human history would explain the phenomenon of war.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Comte’s doctrine of social positivism, which he outlined in the Cours de philosophie positive (1830-42), asks: if we cannot acknowledge freedom of thought in either chemistry or biology, why should we acknowledge it in either ethics or politics? According to Comte each form of knowledge goes through three theoretical stages: the theological (fictitious), the metaphysical (abstract) and the scientific (positive). Each of these corresponds to three wisdom stages (fiction, abstraction, demonstration), which are in turn related to the three evolutionary ages of both individuals and humanity: childhood (ancient age), youth (middle age) and maturity (positive age).

Across this path, human wisdom gets rid of polytheism, fetishism and monotheism, which were pertaining to the first stage. It then gets to the second stage, where knowledge is rational, yet still lacking empirical verifications, to eventually reach the positive-scientific knowledge. Italian scholar Abbagnano provides a beautiful image of the positive ideal in Hegelian terms, describing it as the romanticism of science—the tendency, distinctive of romanticism, to identify the finite and the infinite, to consider the finite as the revelation, the progressive realization of the infinite. This tendency is projected by positivism into science.

Someone at each of the three stages of human history would explain the phenomenon of war differently. Within the first stage, where men are subjected to theocratic government, war would be seen as the natural consequence of the gods’ or God’s childish will for self-affirming through the ruler onto the enemy. At the second stage, where abstract philosophical categories take the place of deities, war might be viewed as an event provoked by intangible forces for the realization of ideals—such as those of the Enlightenment. The positive stage would be the accomplishment of an empirical rationality whereof humanity would be fully in charge of their actions, and peace and harmony would make the need for war eventually subside.

Contemporary criticism—as we may also infer from the idea, stated above, of positivism as the romanticism of science—warns us against the idolatry of science (which has not yet prevented the occurring of deaths from war) and encourages ethics to be put at the service of science. Comte was very optimistic: he believed that, despite the fact that science had entered the positive phase, culture and social order were not fully permeated yet by the same rational spirit. The three philosophies were then still coexisting, but, according to Comte, a system of positive philosophy would have eventually accomplished the overcoming of the previous ones in favor of a fully adult humanity.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Comte believed that human history had passed through the following three stages:

  1. The Theological stage, in which deities cause events or phenomena to occur. 
  2. The Metaphysical stage, in which natural events were explained by abstractions.
  3. The Positivity stage, in which events are explained by science and reason. 

Comte believed that although there is a general progression form the first to the third stage, many stages may or do occur at the same time and that societies may not progress from one stage to the next. The three stages can co-exist in the same society.

In the Theological stage, war would be explained as the anger of a deity with a distinct personality. In the Metaphysical stage, war might be explained as the outgrowth of an abstract concept, such as desire. In the Positivity stage, war might be explained as the urge of one society to control the natural resources of another to earn more money. 

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial