"Redemption" unfolds in an insular farming community in upstate New York, focusing on the Hawthorne family as they grapple with a devastating tragedy. Jack Hawthorne accidentally kills his younger brother David in a farming mishap, which sends shockwaves through their family. The story explores their individual paths to healing, particularly Jack's difficult journey.

The Accident and Its Aftermath

The narrative immediately thrusts the reader into turmoil with the announcement of David's untimely death. Jack was operating a tractor when his brother fell, and the machinery crushed David before Jack could react. This incident leaves a profound impact on each family member, setting the stage for their varied responses to the tragedy.

Dale's Struggles

Dale, Jack's father, is deeply affected by the loss of his son. Known for his gentle nature and love of reciting poetry at community events, Dale spirals into self-destructive behavior. He indulges in dangerous motorcycle rides, smoking, and extramarital affairs, as he fluctuates between anger at God and a crisis of faith. Dale's internal conflict underscores the pervasive despair within the family.

Betty's Resilience

Betty, Jack's mother, veils her sorrow, choosing to display strength for her surviving children. A devout woman, she leans on her network of friends for support and focuses on helping Jack and his sister through their grief. Betty insists on maintaining some normalcy by ensuring that her children continue with their music lessons; Phoebe practices the piano while Jack persists with the French horn.

Jack's Isolation

Jack retreats into solitude, shying away from family and friends despite their attempts to reach out. The memory of the accident haunts him relentlessly, and he battles with thoughts of ending his own life. Finding a modicum of peace in his farm chores, Jack gradually shows signs of care for others, as demonstrated by a poignant moment when he comforts his distraught sister by pretending to have said grace.

A Glimmer of Reconciliation

When Dale returns after a period of absence, a scene of emotional rawness unfolds as he seeks forgiveness from his wife. Jack, witnessing his father's emotional breakdown, embraces him but harbors resentment for his father's previous neglect. This complex interplay of forgiveness and anger highlights the ongoing tension within the family as they attempt to mend their broken bonds.

Music as an Escape

Music becomes Jack's refuge from his grief, offering him a semblance of escape from his overwhelming emotions. Each Saturday, he travels to Rochester for lessons with Arcady Yegudkin, a seasoned Russian musician with his own tumultuous past. Through these lessons, Jack finds a mentor and a temporary escape from his internal struggles.

The Turning Point

In a pivotal moment, Yegudkin's masterful playing captivates Jack, prompting him to question his own potential. Yegudkin's laughter at Jack's inquiry about achieving such skill is a moment of release for Jack, allowing him to confront the pressure of perfection. This exchange signifies a breakthrough for Jack, as he embraces his imperfections and continues on his musical journey.

The Path to Healing

The story concludes with Jack hurrying to catch his bus home, symbolizing the beginning of his emotional recovery. This journey mirrors his father's earlier quest for redemption, suggesting a shared familial path toward healing. As Jack sets off, there is a lingering sense of hope that, like his father, he too will find peace.