Student Question
Is the trip in Robert Burns' "A Red, Red Rose" real, imaginary, and what is the purpose of mentioning separation?
Quick answer:
The separation in "A Red, Red Rose" is metaphorical, emphasizing the speaker's deep and enduring love for his beloved. Burns uses traditional imagery, like a fresh rose and sweet melody, to convey tenderness. The poem reflects both oral traditions and Enlightenment ideas, suggesting eternal love through hyperbolic expressions of time. Mentioning separation, common in 18th-century Scottish poetry, highlights the speaker's profound devotion, possibly alluding to historical contexts like Jacobite exile.
The separation here is not a literal trip. Instead, Burns is using the traditional idea of separation from a love to underscore the tenderness and purity of the speaker's feelings for his beloved.
He describes it as the freshest of roses "newly sprung in June", and a "melodie sweetly played in tune". The latter, of course, is a nod to the Scottish oral tradition on which Burns drew in writing his love poetry. The speaker then describes the depth of his love as as fair as his beloved herself. Here again, the expression of love is very traditional, and goes back well into the oral tradition.
However, Burns's description of the time period over which his love will endure marks him as an Enlightenment poet. He references the geological time recently identified when he discusses the seas drying up, and the rocks melting with the sun. The time he references here is well beyond the human lifespan, and demonstrates clearly the eternity of the speaker's love for his beloved.
It was quite common in Scottish poetry of the eighteenth century to reference a separation. This might be due to the speaker's allegiance to the lost cause of the Jacobites and an exile or it might be due to his forced service in the British army (an aftereffect of the failed Jacobite movement). The use of hyperbole in the final lines, however, underscores the depth of the speaker's love.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.