Reconstruction

Start Free Trial

Editor's Choice

What were the goals of Reconstruction post-Civil War and were they accomplished?

Quick answer:

The primary goals of Reconstruction were to reintegrate Southern states into the Union and protect the rights of freed slaves. However, these goals were largely unmet due to weak enforcement of civil rights, the rise of discriminatory groups, and the Compromise of 1877, which ended federal intervention in the South. While Reconstruction aimed to reform Southern society and politics to favor industrial interests, it ultimately failed to secure long-term protections for African Americans, leading to the era of Jim Crow laws.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Reconstruction's aim was to bring the South back into the Union while protecting the rights and safety of the newly freed slaves. At the end of the Civil War, there were nearly 4 million former slaves in the South. It was the hope of Reconstructionists that they could be integrated into the fabric of a free society. Unfortunately, Reconstruction would fall short of its goal.

The original structure of Reconstruction was largely designed by Abraham Lincoln. Had Lincoln lived to see it, he may have been able to guide Reconstruction through. His successor, however, was Andrew Johnson, a rare southern politician who had stayed loyal to the Union. Johnson tweaked Lincoln's plan significantly. He allowed most southern leaders to return to power. All they had to do was swear loyalty to the Union and ratify the 13th Amendment abolishing slavery. They were not required to protect the former slaves from abuses or treat them as full citizens.

In response to this, congressional Republicans reorganized the South into zones of military occupation. This resulted in the army being stationed in the South until southern states rewrote their state constitutions to protect black civil rights. In response to this, angry white southerners created groups such as the Ku Klux Klan which terrorized the black population and anyone who supported their newly won rights.

In 1874, the Democratic Party regained a majority in the House of Representatives. In 1877, Republican Rutherford B. Hayes was given the presidency in a disputed election under the condition that he remove federal soldiers from the South. This is known as the Compromise of 1877. This effectively ended Reconstruction. Without help from the federal government, the black population in the South was subjected to a century of Jim Crow laws, segregation, disenfranchisement, and abuse. Therefore, Reconstruction can be seen as a failure in that it did not succeed in its goal of integrating the black population into the social fabric of America.

References

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

When Reconstruction commenced, the South had just been reunited with the Union by the most violent war ever fought on the North American continent.  (There was no question of a peaceable reunion; the Southern states no longer had any say in the matter. Nor was Reconstruction about rebuilding the South. Whites were to remain more impoverished after the War than they had been before the War for at least a generation; blacks remained more impoverished after than before the War for about four generations.) The goals of Reconstruction were to reconstruct or reform the social and political institutions of the South so that Northern industrialism could be assured of national hegemony. Before the War, there had been so many wealthy planters that the agricultural social system competed with the industrial social system for hegemony in the southern part of the nation. When big businessmen and their politicians wanted to enact higher taxes, or spend more taxes in the North than in the South, big agriculturalist and their politicians often opposed them. The War had destroyed most of the wealthy planters. Without wealthy planters, agriculture could have little power in the federal government. The goals of Reconstruction were to see that there would be no new wealthy planters and that the electorate would be so constituted that more of the people elected to Congress would be favorable to or at least not hostile to the hegemony of industrialism throughout the nation, South as well as North. To this latter end, blacks were given the vote and organized and marched to the polls and told to vote Republican; most Southern whites were not allowed to vote. Reconstruction ended when the national hegemony of industrialism was assured.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Well, the goal of Reconstruction was to restore the union and compromise with the Southern states that ceded before and during the war.  In order for Lincoln to restore our union he had to allow some flexibility with new laws so that the South would be want to come back to the union peacefully.  The country was in a fragile state and even though many northerners were ready for complete civil rights for African Americans, if that were to happen the South would not be willing to come back to the Union.  First of all Lincoln and his Congress created the 13th amendment that would completely abolish slavery, which was the beginning stages of restoration. 

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The goal, of President Lincoln and his supporters, was to rejoin all of the states to the Union and to help rebuild the "South".  Lincoln was going to grant amnesty to all that rejoined the Union without fear of punishment.  He was committed to following through with the Emancipation of the Slaves, and to make sure of their future in the United States of America.  Were these goals met?  It depends on which history book you read.  If you read a book published before 1960 then no the goals were not reached.  According to William Dunning’s late nineteenth-century theory:

"the failure of Reconstruction could be blamed on carpetbaggers, (Northerners who came south) scalawags (southern Republicans who supported the Union), and freed slaves."

However, if you were enrolled in school following 1965 your history books might follow the ideology of John Franklin, who believed the Reconstruction was more successful.

"Franklin’s perspective on Reconstruction was almost point-for-point the exact opposite of Dunning’s. While Franklin acknowledged that Radical Republican governments were often corrupt, he mostly defended the actions taken by freed blacks, southern white Republicans, and what he termed “so-called carpetbaggers.” "

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial